The Battle of Gettysburg **Game Thread**

[Zarovich]

shoot MWB

I have no idea why you would put the village into, and then point out, a no win situation.

What are you talking about?

If LITT is good this vote will take off - bad for village
If LITT is bad this vote won't go anywhere - no vote doesn't help

There is no plus side to this vote the way you have laid it out. And even more so, if your goal was to gain knowledge of who is bad by seeing how long the vote takes, you ruin any chance of that by specifically pointing out that that is what your intention is.

It's almost indirectly accusing anyone who doesn't vote for LITT.

MWB pretty much said he thinks LITT, you and myself are bad....

[bhaw]

It would be nice to get your thoughts, Zaro. They have been noticeably absent despite you chiming in every once in a while.

You are someone I have been suspicious of for a while.

[bhaw]

To clarify - your increased pop ins without voting or contributing has made you increasingly suspicious. Doing it again is not helping. Need some input from your side.

[bhaw]

save mwb

fire upon zaro

i feel good about that one.

[Zarovich]

Its a coin flip for me between bhaw and litt.

Looking at this post, I think it got Troy killed. Bhaw didn't vote for LITT and flipped off of rylan to vote for IE. I admit being wrong on IE, but I was sure she was red. Even now, bhaw won't vote for LITT.

[Zarovich]

fire upon bhaw

You may not feel I have been contributing, but I called out you, troy and canaan for not participating earlier. I even put a vote on you and then you started posting and completely ignored my vote. That is a smooth red play there.

I feel good on this vote.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

shoot MWB

I have no idea why you would put the village into, and then point out, a no win situation.

I still believe one of Rylan or ps87 is bad, but MWB is sticking out to me big time.

I also have questions around SDD. If he came back blue and was blue, the reds seem to be killing off the known good guys. Unless they feel SDD is way off, it would reason that they would have killed him by now.

I don't think ps87 and Rylan are RPs, because the last night phase ended pretty early. Of course unless they sent in there votes without participating in the game.

[thehockeyguru]

(2) LITT - (MWB, SDD)
(1) Zaro - (Bhaw)
(1) Bhaw - (Zaro)

4 to Fire Upon

[bhaw]

fire upon bhaw

You may not feel I have been contributing, but I called out you, troy and canaan for not participating earlier. I even put a vote on you and then you started posting and completely ignored my vote. That is a smooth red play there.

I feel good on this vote.

Hahaha, really? You called me out (I went back to look) Tuesday morning at 7:45 (my time, 10:45 yours). My first post was 12 hours later in the game thread. I guess you can have an indefinite timeline because if my first post would have been Friday, it was still technically after you "called me out." I ignored your vote because there was nothing to address. You said I hadn't posted, which was correct.

Like I said, if you think I'm the best vote, go for it. But if your justification is that you called me out then I started posting, that's bunk. There was just under 12 full hours (11h 40some min).

[Letang Is The Truth]

shoot MWB

I have no idea why you would put the village into, and then point out, a no win situation.

I still believe one of Rylan or ps87 is bad, but MWB is sticking out to me big time.

I also have questions around SDD. If he came back blue and was blue, the reds seem to be killing off the known good guys. Unless they feel SDD is way off, it would reason that they would have killed him by now.

I don't think ps87 and Rylan are RPs, because the last night phase ended pretty early. Of course unless they sent in there votes without participating in the game.

the logic implicating quiet players as RPs because write ups have been taking longer is always spotty

[bhaw]

The game is over. We can't get enough votes. I'm pretty sure Zaro is bad, and my 2nd bet is MWB but I have no way of getting a vote on them since people aren't here. If they are both red, it's impossible.

I guess I'm done b/c arguing or providing evidence is pointless. If 2 reds are participating, it can't happen.

[Letang Is The Truth]

im leaning owards mwb. i think they tried to set me up with that troy kill. reading back i dont think SDD is bad, he has been on the kraftster and EPP votes.

[thehockeyguru]

(2) LITT - (MWB, SDD)
(1) Zaro - (Bhaw)
(1) Bhaw - (Zaro)

4 to Fire Upon

deadline is 9PM

[bhaw]

im leaning owards mwb. i think they tried to set me up with that troy kill. reading back i dont think SDD is bad, he has been on the kraftster and EPP votes.

I think it's him and Zaro, tbh. I'm not sure about you, but based on what I'm reading, I think it's those two.

Zaro was 2nd to last vote for EPP, last vote on IE (which he used as a negative for me).

Point being is that if there are 2 bad players left who are participating, a majority can't happen. At best, there are 3 votes on someone and the time runs out and we hit a lucky one. Problem is SDD has to pick the right 2 to align with, as the groundwork has been laid to say that you and I are paired up. As Zaro stated, the fact that I haven't voted for you shows I'm protecting you. In reality, he said LITT and bhaw. I know I'm blue, so I don't trust his instincts on LITT knowing that if he's looking at the same thing for both of us, he's wrong.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Dodge LITT

Fire upon Zaro

I agree with you bhaw. I've been suspicious of Zaro for sometime now. Still not sure who is good or who is bad. But' I'm fine with being wrong to help at least advance the game and put an end to it.

LITT we need you to vote for Zaro so that something happens at the time limit.

[bhaw]

I really hope SDD isn't bad. That post wreaks of red, but since you're new, I almost want to ignore it.

Hopefully I'm right.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

I know I'm blue. I have no idea what anyone else is at this point.

[bhaw]

I'm banking on probability with you. The circumstances that would have to take place for you to be bad:

1. you were viewed and came back blue
2. the rules were set up so a red comes back as blue (alpha)
3. in your first game ever, you are the 1/20 that is picked as the alpha
4. you play a really solid game for your first game as the leader of the red team

Statistics say that the odds of this happening are so low, I'm ok with being on your side.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Can someone explain to me why General Meade hasn't made any night kills?

[bhaw]

Can someone explain to me why General Meade hasn't made any night kills?

lol... i was seriously about to bring up the vig.

Considering this is potentially the last vote, we should figure out who he is. Eliminate 1 person.

[Zarovich]

I'm banking on probability with you. The circumstances that would have to take place for you to be bad:

1. you were viewed and came back blue
2. the rules were set up so a red comes back as blue (alpha)
3. in your first game ever, you are the 1/20 that is picked as the alpha
4. you play a really solid game for your first game as the leader of the red team

Statistics say that the odds of this happening are so low, I'm ok with being on your side.

LOL. If this isn't the biggest red sucking up to an outed blue ever, then someone show me.

[thehockeyguru]

(2) Zaro - (Bhaw, Zaro)
(1) LITT - (MWB)
(1) Bhaw - (Zaro)

4 to Fire Upon

deadline is 9PM

[bhaw]

I'm banking on probability with you. The circumstances that would have to take place for you to be bad:

1. you were viewed and came back blue
2. the rules were set up so a red comes back as blue (alpha)
3. in your first game ever, you are the 1/20 that is picked as the alpha
4. you play a really solid game for your first game as the leader of the red team

Statistics say that the odds of this happening are so low, I'm ok with being on your side.

LOL. If this isn't the biggest red sucking up to an outed blue ever, then someone show me.

I wouldn't need to push to hard as a red at this point. There's very minimal opportunity for blue.

[bhaw]

[MWB]

Can someone explain to me why General Meade hasn't made any night kills?

lol... i was seriously about to bring up the vig.

Considering this is potentially the last vote, we should figure out who he is. Eliminate 1 person.

If you haven't figured it out, I'm not sure what to say. That's part of why I think both you and litt are bad. Also, I still say that if litt were blue, the game would be done.