The Battle of Gettysburg **Game Thread**

[Gaucho]

Heh.

[slappybrown]

lololololol

Hey THG, could columbia have told us the actual result of his death?

[leaves to piss on columbia's grave]

[thehockeyguru]

lololololol

Hey THG, could columbia have told us the actual result of his death?

[leaves to piss on columbia's grave]

That sounds like something to discuss in the post game thread.

[MWB]

Meh. Not a big deal really. No reason to keep Columbia around to just continue the confusion.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Well it's no big deal except now the village has another red to deal with.

[MWB]

Well it's no big deal except now the village has another red to deal with.

The other option would be to have him hang around and kill off people randomly. I'm fairly certain that his "brother" is the vig who shot on even numbered nights. Long run, it's more detrimental to the village to have columbia around.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Let's consider who his brother is.

If we assume his brother didn't vote to kill him, those that didn't vote for him including myself are the following:
IrishEyes
Rylan
MWB
pittsports87

I don't think its ps87. My bet is on rylan.

[MWB]

As a result of Columbia’s death his partner and remaining Gettysburg Mason enlisted as a Confederate Officer to avenge the death of his brother. You could say that his new role allowed him to do a little of this and a little of that.

I'm guessing that the brother was the one shooting on even nights, and now that has changed to more of a JOAT-like role?

[ExPatriatePen]

As a result of Columbia’s death his partner and remaining Gettysburg Mason enlisted as a Confederate Officer to avenge the death of his brother. You could say that his new role allowed him to do a little of this and a little of that.

I'm guessing that the brother was the one shooting on even nights, and now that has changed to more of a JOAT-like role?

I know i'm not supposed to be posting in this thread, but I *am* following it closely because I obviously have a lot to learn. but what's a JOAT? T.I.A

[slappybrown]

A jack of all trades. Standard issue is one vig shot, one investigate, and one protect, to be used one at a time at joats discretion. Can be modified by the mod to include more of each of these, and/or more powers like role block, vote rig (cancel or double) etc

[ExPatriatePen]

A jack of all trades. Standard issue is one vig shot, one investigate, and one protect, to be used one at a time at joats discretion. Can be modified by the mod to include more of each of these, and/or more powers like role block, vote rig (cancel or double) etc

Wow, thanks Slappy. Back to lurking.

[thehockeyguru]

Write up coming

[thehockeyguru]

Once again Night had fallen over the Battlefield at Gettysburg. On this night there was plenty of activity abound. Gen. Robert E Lee again after deliberating with his officers over the plan of action chose to shoot:

Spoiler:

the wicked child who was a regular villager

On the other side of the battle field Gen. George Meade honed in on his target.

Spoiler:

but decided against using his bullet on this night

Players Remaining:

1. IrishEyes
2. Zarovich
3. Rylan
4. bhaw
5. MWB
6. Troy Loney
7. Letang Is The Truth
8. Kraftster
9. pittsports87
10. slappybrown
11. Sam's Drunk Dog

Spoiler:

Night 1 - No Kills.
Day 1 - ExPatriatePen - Maj. Gen. J.E.B. Stuart was killed at the Battle of Brandy Station
Night 2 - Relantel a regular villager and Benny Fitz a regular villager both were found dead in the streets of Gettysburg.
Day 2 - mac5155 - Maj. Gen. John Buford was killed at the Railroad cut
Night 3 - NAN - a regular villager was found shot to death on the streets of Gettysburg.
Day 3 – Redwill - a regular villager was surcame to his wounds in his new-fangled observation balloon and was feasted on by a school of rabid jellyfish.
Night 4 - Canaan a regular villager was found dead in the streets of Gettysburg.
Day 4 – Columbia a Gettysburg Town Masons was killed as the Union retreated to Cemetery Hill.
Night 5 - TWC a regular villager was found dead in the streets of Gettysburg.

It is now Day 5. It takes 6 to fire upon

Deadline is 8PM

[MWB]

I'm guessing there are three reds and two greens at this point. I think sloppy is the best vote.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

I agree MWB. He was a little to quick to fire upon columbia and mac.

Fire upon Slappy

[MWB]

(6) - Columbia - (Bhaw, Kraftster, Slappy, TL, Zaro, TWC, LITT)
(1) - Slappy - (SDD)

7 to Fire Upon

Deadline at 8PM

This is the vote order on Columbia. Early votes would probably not be the brother. Any could be red if they believed what he was saying and thought the kill would help them.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

I think Rylan could possibly be the brother. I just think slappy is bad.

[slappybrown]

And you're still wrong.

[slappybrown]

Yea, I went back and read through the thread, and you are just bad at this game.

First, I voted for EPP. The mac vote has been explained. I understood redwill to be making a role claim.

If your justification now is that I was too quick to jump on columbia, I voted at 9:35, and then don't even vote for columbia until almost an hour later, and only once I've engaged in some conversation with him to try to get some more information. If you read my exchange with him, its anything but "jumping on him too quick."

Have there been any recruits in writeups since mac investigated SDD? I think its just you are bad at the game rather than being bad in the game.

I'm inclined to vote for one of MWB, kraftster, or LITT. MWB because I never have any idea what he is, and Kraftster because of a hunch.

Litt also hasnt been himself.

PS87 has been quiet as well which is unlike him, but I dont really know his style in this game as I think hes new to these games.

[Kraftster]

Irish Eyes and Rylan are players I'm not familiar with this late in games who have been pretty quiet. I actually forgot Irish Eyes was even still around.

I have concern about Troy being so quiet. I seem to be bad at reading him, so his quietness leaves me wanting to vote for him. LITT on the quiet side too but seems blue to me.

This is definitely quiet for ps87, though he gave a RL excuse I think? for being so quiet.

MWB, Zaro, bhaw pretty standard games for each player.

SDD seems to be too out in the open to have a role, imo.

slappy seems blue to me to be honest.

shoot Troy

[slappybrown]

shoot irish eyes in her stupid face

when in doubt this always works. what say you IE

[Troy Loney]

Well...I was wrong about TWC.

I'm leaning towards kraftster...he made a pretty long post without saying very much at all.

[thehockeyguru]

(1) - Slappy - (SDD)
(1) - Troy Loney - (Kraftster)
(1) - Irish Eyes - (Slappy)

It takes 6 to Fire Upon

Deadline is 8PM

[slappybrown]

I think IE and Krafty are both bad. IE played similarly when I was on her team as baddies. I could vote for either.

[Zarovich]

Fire upon Slappy

I was for this last vote as well. Thought columbia was blowing smoke...