newarenanow wrote:Only the vig knows if this is legit or not, because someone tried to kill her. And if it wasn't the vig, then dags is good.
I'm willing to take my chances right now because of that. So I'm not going to kill her yet.
But I'm also not willing to kill thg either. I don't think he is a baddie.
I'm going to go back to the list and start looking through it, see if there are any traditionally quiet ones. I always like starting there.
Any reason why you dont think THG is bad?
I also agree with the vig theory. It's WAY too early to ask the vig to out him/herself to clear this up. I dont want to risk whacking our JOAT on day 2.
GRR!! This is a toughy. If Dagny isn't a green JOAT, she is an Other. If she's not an Other, she is a green RP.
i'm not willing to kill dags just yet (but her story is starting to get fishier and fishier). i am willing; however, to change from THG to a quiet player and get them out now instead of wishing we did later.
I would take a close look at the people who seem to be a little more forceful than others in supporting dagny's hypothesis. pfidc and canaan right off the bat, but of course we don't even know if she is really red yet. As a matter of fact, pfidc is looking more and more suspicious to me.
GRR!! This is a toughy. If Dagny isn't a green JOAT, she is an Other. If she's not an Other, she is a green RP.
This is not the way pfidc normally acts in these games, with statements like this.
And to add to the note about pfidc, that is exactly the kind of "on the fence" comments that are popular with reds because they are noncommittal to either side. And I really don't understand his forceful push at implicating THG.
Unknown Survivor wrote:We've all begun to settle in now, realizing that immediate rescue is improbable.
I was playing an awesome game of 'go fish' with mac5155 by the fire when he excused himself to take care of some 'business' in the jungle. While waiting for him to return, I began to look around the beach and take in my surroundings. It was almost pretty...for being a craphole island.
Suddenly there was a huge ruckus over by dagny's tent. It was dark but I could just barely make out the silhouettes of several people crowded around. Then, without warning, her tent went up in flames! As the group of attackers faded away into the jungle, dagny crawled out of her burning tent, gasping for breath. She was alive but just barely.
I spent the rest of the night waiting for mac to return but he never did. Was he lost in the jungle? Did he fall down and get hurt? I guess we will have to wait until it gets light to look for him.
The write up says "several people", "group of attackers". Not indicative of a vig.
PensFanInDC wrote:
Any reason why you dont think THG is bad?
he's sticking his neck out for clarity on this. i think a baddie would have a pretty good idea what's going on here and would sit back and calculate potential options instead of sticking their neck out to demand explanations from dagny.
shafnutz05 wrote:And to add to the note about pfidc, that is exactly the kind of "on the fence" comments that are popular with reds because they are noncommittal to either side. And I really don't understand his forceful push at implicating THG.
Ill say it again. He wanted to vote for her before she explained herself. That's fishy to me.
PensFanInDC wrote:
Any reason why you dont think THG is bad?
he's sticking his neck out for clarity on this. i think a baddie would have a pretty good idea what's going on here and would sit back and calculate potential options instead of sticking their neck out to demand explanations from dagny.
THG, has made the play, not really worth being a baddie in my opinion at this time. He's put himself out there EARLY in the game. Usually it's a death sentence, because it's still early enough where people can sway votes onto him and make him look crazy.
At this moment in time, I don't know, but I think he's a blue.
shafnutz05 wrote:And to add to the note about pfidc, that is exactly the kind of "on the fence" comments that are popular with reds because they are noncommittal to either side. And I really don't understand his forceful push at implicating THG.
Ill say it again. He wanted to vote for her before she explained herself. That's fishy to me.
Speaking to Troy's point, a red player would not come out and continue to forcefully push for dagny's capturing, knowing that she is a good RP. No way. I am about 75% on dagny being red, but i am about 100% on THG not sticking his neck out like that if he was red.
shafnutz05 wrote:And to add to the note about pfidc, that is exactly the kind of "on the fence" comments that are popular with reds because they are noncommittal to either side. And I really don't understand his forceful push at implicating THG.
Ill say it again. He wanted to vote for her before she explained herself. That's fishy to me.
Speaking to Troy's point, a red player would not come out and continue to forcefully push for dagny's capturing, knowing that she is a good RP. No way. I am about 75% on dagny being red, but i am about 100% on THG not sticking his neck out like that if he was red.
Unless they are both red and it's a sacrifice. But I dont think that's likely.
shafnutz05 wrote:And to add to the note about pfidc, that is exactly the kind of "on the fence" comments that are popular with reds because they are noncommittal to either side. And I really don't understand his forceful push at implicating THG.
I don't know about PFIDC, but thg's lack of, not only reading comprehension, but reading AT ALL is incredibly disturbing. Not to mention annoying, useless, and possibly detrimental to the village.
The evidence is all right here. The answers to his questions are right in front of his face, yet he refuses to read?
That's more than enough to convince me he needs to go. All he's done is talk smack to wally and try to get an outed green RPer killed.