HOLIDAY WARS GAME THREAD

[IrishEyes]

Bad guys only kill everyother night...

This stuck out to me, too.

unwrapTroy Loney

[MWB]

Bad guys only kill everyother night...

This stuck out to me, too.

unwrapTroy Loney

So do you think that Troy is just a bad lister and there's no independent this game? I guess I've been going under the assumption that there is an independent serial killer.

[IrishEyes]

So do you think that Troy is just a bad lister and there's no independent this game? I guess I've been going under the assumption that there is an independent serial killer.

Even if he is the ISK, he's really not doing all that much to help us. He got Juice, yes. But that's the only bad lister we've gotten in this game. It's getting down to the wire, and if he's going to keep knocking off villagers, then he's more of a hindrance than a help.

[MWB]

I agree, I'm just wondering if there's any upside to keeping him around.

[count2infinity]

I agree, I'm just wondering if there's any upside to keeping him around.

the only upside is that maybe the goons will take a shot at him instead of one of us...

[the wicked child]

I agree, I'm just wondering if there's any upside to keeping him around.

Upside? Do you actually buy that the bad guys can only kill every other night?

[IrishEyes]

I agree, I'm just wondering if there's any upside to keeping him around.

the only upside is that maybe the goons will take a shot at him instead of one of us...

What if he's a goon though and messing with us? Is it worth keeping him around?

[crayz]

My top 3:

Troy <Although it may clear up the game for goons, it will also help clear it up for us>
Beerman <reasons stated yesterday- Then today jumps on the Corvi bandwagon when he was willing to eliminate himself, doesn't quite make sense for me>
jarrko <still the newbie card >

unwrap troy

[MWB]

So Troy is either the ISK who could do as much harm as good.
or
Troy is a goon who is trying to string us out as long as he can knowing that sooner or later he's going to get killed.

[Kicksave]

4 - Troy Loney (PensFaninDC, the wicked child, IrishEyes, crayz)
1 - Corvidae (beerman)

[count2infinity]

i've heard enough to actually vote on this round...

unwrap troy loney

[beerman]

Beerman <reasons stated yesterday- Then today jumps on the Corvi bandwagon when he was willing to eliminate himself, doesn't quite make sense for me>

how exactly did I jump on the Corvi bandwagon, I'm the only person to vote for him

[MWB]

I've got to go do some Christmas shopping.... I'm leaning towards Troy but want to wait on input from others before voting.

[sdm5055]

unwrap Troy

it just doesnt add up to me

unless this game is totally different

[JarkkoVision]

unwrapTroy Loney

[beerman]

I've got to go do some Christmas shopping.... I'm leaning towards Troy but want to wait on input from others before voting.

I've got no problem with a Troy vote, but something tells me he's protected and we'd be wasting a vote. I feel like his "I can't die today" yesterday was just like Malks was trying to make us believe he wouldn't die last game when he was trying to push the vote elsewhere.

[Kicksave]

7 - Troy Loney (PensFaninDC, the wicked child, IrishEyes, crayz, count2infinity, sdm5055, Jarkko Vision)
1 - Corvidae (beerman)

[crayz]

Beerman <reasons stated yesterday- Then today jumps on the Corvi bandwagon when he was willing to eliminate himself, doesn't quite make sense for me>

how exactly did I jump on the Corvi bandwagon, I'm the only person to vote for him

Fair enough, bad word choice. You jumped on Corvi...

[crayz]

I've got to go do some Christmas shopping.... I'm leaning towards Troy but want to wait on input from others before voting.

I've got no problem with a Troy vote, but something tells me he's protected and we'd be wasting a vote. I feel like his "I can't die today" yesterday was just like Malks was trying to make us believe he wouldn't die last game when he was trying to push the vote elsewhere.

Ignoring him won't make a difference though? If he is protected tonight, we will know and then can go tomorrow and finish him off. If we are just scared to off him we will never know?

[beerman]

Beerman <reasons stated yesterday- Then today jumps on the Corvi bandwagon when he was willing to eliminate himself, doesn't quite make sense for me>

how exactly did I jump on the Corvi bandwagon, I'm the only person to vote for him

Fair enough, bad word choice. You jumped on Corvi...

And I feel I have a good reason, he knew there was no possibility of dieing and it would make me look bad in the process.

[crayz]

And I feel I have a good reason, he knew there was no possibility of dieing and it would make me look bad in the process.

unless you are both bad and planned this...he takes the last hit instead of you, you vote him off, and it puts you in the clear

sorry dude, just the feeling I have is you is a bad dood

[count2infinity]

troy today, corvi tomorrow...

[slappybrown]

I keep getting played on timing. I thought Troy was full of it yeterday, and tht dags was a wasted vote but didnt make back in time. I think corvo and beerman and the whole thing they were doin with the Ill take one for the team is suspicious, and then beerman immediately votes for corvo this morning even though troys the obvious play. They would be my next two at this stage with mac in the mix.

The reason I wanted to vote Troy and not dags yesterday is because I am concerned that Troy is actually protected today somehow, and was lying about being protected yesterday. unwrap troy

[the wicked child]

And I feel I have a good reason, he knew there was no possibility of dieing and it would make me look bad in the process.

unless you are both bad and planned this...he takes the last hit instead of you, you vote him off, and it puts you in the clear

sorry dude, just the feeling I have is you is a bad dood

I kinda agree here. He also seems to be trying to sway people from voting for troy with the "oh noes what if he is protected" spiel.

[Kicksave]

8 - Troy Loney (PensFaninDC, the wicked child, IrishEyes, crayz, count2infinity, sdm5055, JarkkoVision, slappybrown)
1 - Corvidae (beerman)