HOLIDAY WARS GAME THREAD

[slappybrown]

Slappy is quickly becoming suspicious.

Please read above regadring the reasoning. If you really think I would try to vote for mac bc he just left as strategy, then I dont know what to tell you.

[JoseCuervo]

so mac is the angel and you're a bad lister?

I think that's a good assumption with just one kill last night. Unless the bad listers recruited somebody...

People who immediately post comments regarding the state of the angel/doctor etc are often goons. See Troy Loney in the Nintendo Wars game, and Malks in the NHL Wars game.

not something a really noticed in any of the WW games to be honest

[npv708]

My top 5 suspicious persons:

1) Troy - I'm almost always suspicious of him
2) Slappy - for recent events
3) LITT - see troy.
4) Mac - slappy may be right about this, but I'm not that sure.
5) Corvi - same as what was said for Juice, if he survives this long, it probably has some deeper reason...

[JoseCuervo]

though I guess by stating that he may be trying to get the angel to come out, which would probably suck for us

[MWB]

Kinda shady voting for someone who just left so can't really respond.

Yea, because I fully expect 12 votes to materialize in the next hour or two, given the pre-existing suspects.

It happened last game with IE.

[JoseCuervo]

My top 5 suspicious persons:

1) Troy - I'm almost always suspicious of him
2) Slappy - for recent events
3) LITT - see troy.
4) Mac - slappy may be right about this, but I'm not that sure.
5) Corvi - same as what was said for Juice, if he survives this long, it probably has some deeper reason...

I say keep corvo around. He's a dead man walking at this point.

[Corvidae]

I wrote this and saved it as a draft...

The writing was on the wall that THG was a good RP. As of now, I have a reasonable suspicion that 2-3 of these 6 are bad guys:

Code: Select all

Malkamaniac, PensFaninDC, slappybrown, Troy Loney, Letang Is The Truth, Joose

unwrap Juice

So, I'm going for one of the others. I just don't know which one yet.

[Corvidae]

My top 5 suspicious persons:

1) Troy - I'm almost always suspicious of him
2) Slappy - for recent events
3) LITT - see troy.
4) Mac - slappy may be right about this, but I'm not that sure.
5) Corvi - same as what was said for Juice, if he survives this long, it probably has some deeper reason...

I've never been a bad guy in any of these games. Not once.

[slappybrown]

so mac is the angel and you're a bad lister?

I think that's a good assumption with just one kill last night. Unless the bad listers recruited somebody...

People who immediately post comments regarding the state of the angel/doctor etc are often goons. See Troy Loney in the Nintendo Wars game, and Malks in the NHL Wars game.

not something a really noticed in any of the WW games to be honest

http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php ... ding_Mafia" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

This specific tell has been correct each of the past two games. Mac's statment is softer than Troy's/Malks in the last two games, but I think its better than anything else we have righ now. And having played and now modded the game, if you guys really think that I voted for mac bc OMG HES GONEZ NAO HE WILL GET UNWRAPPED then this village is epic fail.

[MWB]

Slappy is quickly becoming suspicious.

Please read above regadring the reasoning. If you really think I would try to vote for mac bc he just left as strategy, then I dont know what to tell you.

BTW, not saying you're bad, just would want to make sure that mac were able to respond before any vote on him comes to completion. I understand your reasoning for calling him out though.

[npv708]

My top 5 suspicious persons:

1) Troy - I'm almost always suspicious of him
2) Slappy - for recent events
3) LITT - see troy.
4) Mac - slappy may be right about this, but I'm not that sure.
5) Corvi - same as what was said for Juice, if he survives this long, it probably has some deeper reason...

I've never been a bad guy in any of these games. Not once.

K. I thought you had... but i get confused easily.

but 3 of my list are in yours.

so either LITT, Slappy, or Troy.

[Malkamaniac]

Blind voting for Mac surely is a good way to get someone wagon-ed. He made mention of having to take a final and the vote was then thrown out by slappy with no reasoning. Even if you think it won't happen regardless, it has and can happen to anyone immediately. Very suspicious slappy.

[Troy Loney]

I'll just plead my case here.

This all started with nan pointing out that i was quiet on day 1...which i was and i had a reason....and i wanted to participate but i was busy at work.

Then NAN gets killed and people start voting for me right away last night....am i supposed to just sit back and let a bandwagon start on a sunday night?

but whatever...i'm nothing....all i've been able to do is defend myself, i'm not trying to decieve the village, only trying to save myself from being lynched, i got on letangs case because he mad a subtle post to kind of push along the votes for me last night...and he listed me and pfidc...the two people that goon kills drew attention to.

[Corvidae]

I'm going with slappy. I'll explain my list later in full (if I live), but I'm going with slappy since 3 of my 6 are in npv's list, then I pretty much picked him randomly from the 3.

unwrap slappybrown

[JoseCuervo]

People who immediately post comments regarding the state of the angel/doctor etc are often goons. See Troy Loney in the Nintendo Wars game, and Malks in the NHL Wars game.

not something a really noticed in any of the WW games to be honest

http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php ... ding_Mafia" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

This specific tell has been correct each of the past two games. Mac's statment is softer than Troy's/Malks in the last two games, but I think its better than anything else we have righ now. And having played and now modded the game, if you guys really think that I voted for mac bc OMG HES GONEZ NAO HE WILL GET UNWRAPPED then this village is epic fail.

That's a good site for everyone to use.

It said something about congratulating the doctor not just regarding their state. But honestly, you had an awesome game in nintendo wars. I might vote mac once he gets back to hear him out and make sure he isn't a RP- though at that point I'll probably be taking my own exam.

[Malkamaniac]

People who immediately post comments regarding the state of the angel/doctor etc are often goons. See Troy Loney in the Nintendo Wars game, and Malks in the NHL Wars game.

not something a really noticed in any of the WW games to be honest

http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php ... ding_Mafia" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

This specific tell has been correct each of the past two games. Mac's statment is softer than Troy's/Malks in the last two games, but I think its better than anything else we have righ now. And having played and now modded the game, if you guys really think that I voted for mac bc OMG HES GONEZ NAO HE WILL GET UNWRAPPED then this village is epic fail.

Hey

"Voting without any good reason, or indeed any reason whatsoever. "

That's on the how to tell if someone is mafia.

[slappybrown]

Blind voting for Mac surely is a good way to get someone wagon-ed. He made mention of having to take a final and the vote was then thrown out by slappy with no reasoning. Even if you think it won't happen regardless, it has and can happen to anyone immediately. Very suspicious slappy.

Its not a blind vote in any way, shape or form. Its based on past experience and the most common tells in this game. To claim otherwise a you have is, in fact, what is suspicious.

[JoseCuervo]

now slappy is defensive

[Malkamaniac]

unwrap mac

normally when you vote for someone you post the reason why. I'm thinking your good and I'm not getting an an argument with you, but you did just post a vote without saying anything.

[slappybrown]

Hey

"Voting without any good reason, or indeed any reason whatsoever. "

That's on the how to tell if someone is mafia.

Intentionally or strategically dense?

[slappybrown]

unwrap mac

normally when you vote for someone you post the reason why. I'm thinking your good and I'm not getting an an argument with you, but you did just post a vote without saying anything.

Thats fine. I posted before I even read the rest of the thread about him leaving. Just immediately posted it when I saw what he wrote.

[Malkamaniac]

Hey

"Voting without any good reason, or indeed any reason whatsoever. "

That's on the how to tell if someone is mafia.

Intentionally or strategically dense?

Like I said, I think your fine and I'm not willing to bicker with you.

[JoseCuervo]

looking back at the list, sdm, jarko, and cupkeeper have both been incredibly quiet so far. Sdm is usually quiet, but is cupkeeper? I only played one game with him.

[Malkamaniac]

looking back at the list, sdm, jarko, and cupkeeper have both been incredibly quiet so far. Sdm is usually quiet, but is cupkeeper? I only played one game with him.

cupkeeper hasn't played a vocal game so far I don't think.

[count2infinity]

has cupkeeper even voted yet? because last game he'd come in with a random vote here and there and not really participate too too much in discussion.