HOLIDAY WARS GAME THREAD

[Azkar]

2 for troy

[Letang Is The Truth]

well that is not ideal.

i think a troy vote could be good as would a pfidc. and i think that getting a vet here would be good because they seem to be going after all the experienced players.

[count2infinity]

on second thought... if we get rid of another vet that is on our side, then we're at a disadvantage. don't mind me, i'm just taking whatever pops into my head and putting it on here... jambalaya...

[dagny]

Remember, we don't have to rush this. It is still the weekend. I'm leaving for work soon. I don't want to cast a vote just to make sure I get in the vote, in case it finishes before I get home from work.

I would like to see if any of the nominees have anything to say.

At this point, I am willing to go along with a slappy or PFIDC vote.

[tfrizz]

on second thought... if we get rid of another vet that is on our side, then we're at a disadvantage. don't mind me, i'm just taking whatever pops into my head and putting it on here... jambalaya...

Yeah, that thought crossed my mind too. As did the possibility that NAN was killed off to make Troy and/or dags look a little fishy... but we still don't have a lot to go off right now. Troy was fairly vocal in NHL Wars, but has been almost non-existent in this one.

[sdm5055]

I'm going to vote to unwrap slappybrown or PFIDC.

Without much to go on, here is my reasoning.

I believe PFIDC has a role where he can kill. I held off drawing attention to it, in case he was our vig. Now that our vig has been killed, I believe PFIDC to be a bad guy or independent. Unless he was framed.

slappy, cuz he's the RP who held up the game on the weekend last time, even though he was online. Also, he and cup keeper voted to kill wally earlier in the game.

I have to go to work soon. I'll see what you guys have to say, and cast a vote for one of these two, barring new evidence, before I leave.

what's the reasoning behind PFIDC. I could get behind that but what did he say or why do you think he was "framed"?

[dagny]

I'm going to vote to unwrap slappybrown or PFIDC.

Without much to go on, here is my reasoning.

I believe PFIDC has a role where he can kill. I held off drawing attention to it, in case he was our vig. Now that our vig has been killed, I believe PFIDC to be a bad guy or independent. Unless he was framed.

slappy, cuz he's the RP who held up the game on the weekend last time, even though he was online. Also, he and cup keeper voted to kill wally earlier in the game.

I have to go to work soon. I'll see what you guys have to say, and cast a vote for one of these two, barring new evidence, before I leave.

what's the reasoning behind PFIDC. I could get behind that but what did he say or why do you think he was "framed"?

the jaysmiter shooting

[dagny]

i'm in a hurry, so i just entered the above post.

jay got shot right after he got into it with Jesus Christ. I noticed, but didn't say anything in case he was our vig. He is not, so now I am suspicious.

[count2infinity]

jay and pfidc have a beef or something?

[npv708]

jay and pfidc have a beef or something?

If i remember correctly without looking, I believe jay made a joke about Jesus or Christianity or something, and PFIDC responded unpleasantly.

[sdm5055]

i'm in a hurry, so i just entered the above post.

jay got shot right after he got into it with Jesus Christ. I noticed, but didn't say anything in case he was our vig. He is not, so now I am suspicious.

I took they Jay killing as a mod kill.. right before that he was saying that he wanted to switch out of the game with someone who missed out because he thought he would say something to get him booted

[the wicked child]

I took they Jay killing as a mod kill.. right before that he was saying that he wanted to switch out of the game with someone who missed out because he thought he would say something to get him booted

Nah, IMO they would have swapped him out with jwienand rather than outright kill him. I believe hew as killed by another player in the game... whether that was NAN or not is up for discussion.

[Malkamaniac]

In the grand scheme of things this is exactly what the mafia wants. People jumped on board with the obvious vote, by calling out the people that were mentioned. Obviously they want you to go that way. I'm not comfortable voting for Tory or SDM, as they were mentioned. Plus, this was pretty much the exact strategy we used last game.

[dagny]

I'm leaving to get ready for work now. I hope we haven't reached a final decision before I get home. I'll only be gone a few hours!

[MWB]

I'm going to vote to unwrap slappybrown or PFIDC.

Without much to go on, here is my reasoning.

I believe PFIDC has a role where he can kill. I held off drawing attention to it, in case he was our vig. Now that our vig has been killed, I believe PFIDC to be a bad guy or independent. Unless he was framed.

What makes you think PFIDC has a killing role?

[Letang Is The Truth]

I'm going to vote to unwrap slappybrown or PFIDC.

Without much to go on, here is my reasoning.

I believe PFIDC has a role where he can kill. I held off drawing attention to it, in case he was our vig. Now that our vig has been killed, I believe PFIDC to be a bad guy or independent. Unless he was framed.

What makes you think PFIDC has a killing role?

cuz jays was killed and he and pfidc had a spat with the christianity bit

[Kicksave]

Disclaimer: If there was a mod-suicide, I would have said so.

[tfrizz]

In the grand scheme of things this is exactly what the mafia wants. People jumped on board with the obvious vote, by calling out the people that were mentioned. Obviously they want you to go that way. I'm not comfortable voting for Tory or SDM, as they were mentioned. Plus, this was pretty much the exact strategy we used last game.

Like I said, I thought of all that. The biggest factor for me is the difference in Troy's play. He was quite vocal last game, but has hardly posted at all this one... but he's been around.

[count2infinity]

In the grand scheme of things this is exactly what the mafia wants. People jumped on board with the obvious vote, by calling out the people that were mentioned. Obviously they want you to go that way. I'm not comfortable voting for Tory or SDM, as they were mentioned. Plus, this was pretty much the exact strategy we used last game.

what's this we stuff? you were mafia last game...

[the wicked child]

fwiw, I am wary of Troy playing differently as well. That said, it doesn't mean he is guilty... Senka did the same last game and was normal. It's more than we really have to go on otherwise though so I can get behind that vote if we decide to go that way.

It's a toss up in my mind whether pfidc killed jaysmiter. On one hand, it is obvious because he got into the religious spat with him. On the other hand, you have to ask yourself if he would go after jay that soon after the fight.

All things considered, I believe it is possible that pfidc would do it, because he has shown selfishness in the past.

So, I am willing to go with one of these 2 options.

Also, so people are aware, I have 2 decent length meetings to attend tomorrow, so my participation during work hours is likely limited to lunch.

[Letang Is The Truth]

the more i think about it the more i think killing pfidc right now might be a bad idea. if he killed jays that would be too obvious. pfidc is smarter than that... isnt he?

[Malkamaniac]

In the grand scheme of things this is exactly what the mafia wants. People jumped on board with the obvious vote, by calling out the people that were mentioned. Obviously they want you to go that way. I'm not comfortable voting for Tory or SDM, as they were mentioned. Plus, this was pretty much the exact strategy we used last game.

what's this we stuff? you were mafia last game...

Exactly, we did this same tactic and had you guys fooled for the most part. It looks to be the same, and we can work with it. The biggest thing, is not following blindly for people that were called out prior. It's just a set up scheme and it works handedly for the most part.

[count2infinity]

we can do a no lynch (or wrap) can't we? i realize it's not taking a shot at anyone so we can't eliminate a bad lister, but it'd be better than eliminating another good lister until we get more info wouldn't it?

[Malkamaniac]

we can do a no lynch (or wrap) can't we? i realize it's not taking a shot at anyone so we can't eliminate a bad lister, but it'd be better than eliminating another good lister until we get more info wouldn't it?

Majority rules, so technically the Mafia could blindly vote for someone and get a kill.

[the wicked child]

we can do a no lynch (or wrap) can't we? i realize it's not taking a shot at anyone so we can't eliminate a bad lister, but it'd be better than eliminating another good lister until we get more info wouldn't it?

I am personally against a no-wrap, even if the victim would be myself.

To me, the reasoning is simple. You need to "thin the herd" a bit to improve chances of getting a bad guy, as well as establishing voting records and discussion. Without voting records and discussion, there is nothing to look back on later when you are trying to weed out the remaining bad guys.

hence a no-wrap is simply not a good decision in my mind.