NHL WARS I GAME THREAD

[mac5155]

all 10 RPs must have to send a PM

[Letang Is The Truth]

the human torch was denied a bank loan

[slappybrown]

STOP TALKING

[slappybrown]

PMs in, writeup coming...

[mac5155]

and there was much rejoicing.

[slappybrown]

After a long night out on the town, Jaromir Jagr (dagny) and Michael Peca (Juice) begin to bicker on their way home.

"Stop it"

"No You stop it!"



"This is why no one likes you Peca"

"Whatever you say, why dont you move to Russia or something"

And they go their separate ways, promising they would not talk to each other ever again. How right they were.

The village awakens the next morning to find each of them -- DEAD. Or worse, in the KHL! With Jaromir Jagr - Dagny (Superstar) and Michael Peca - Juice (Superstar) both dead and gone, the village finds itself in an early hole. Suspects abound.

Still alive in BUTTMANVILLE:

1. Beerman - Rico Fata
2. Shafnutz - Bob Errey
3. Pavel Bure
4. Troy Loney
5. Cup Keeper - Don Cherry
6. crayz - Ogie Ogilthrope (we can let it slide)
7. dagny - Jaromir Jagr
8. Malkamaniac - Marty Straka
9. sdm5055 - Steve McKenna
10. mac5155 - Joe Dziedzic
11. MWB - Jiri Slegr
12. Zarovich - Marian Hossa
13. Redwill - Joey Mullen
14. Azkar - Pierre McGuire
15. Senka - Ryan Whitney
16. count2infinity - Eddie Olczyk
17. npv708 - Charlie Conway
18. Juice - Michael Peca
19. JS(c) - Gary Roberts
20. Kicksave - Chris Bourque
21. Hockeyguru - Dino Ciccarelli
22. jaysmiter - Wojtek Wolski
23. tfrizz - Joe Sakic
24. PFiDC - Ian Moran
25. IrishEyes - Superstar Max Talbot
26. jwienand - Scott Hartnell

With 24 players left, you need 13 to waive, otherwise leading vote getter at 10:45 PM Tuesday evening.

[npv708]

waive scott hartnell (jwienand)

[mac5155]

waive Marian Hossa (Zarovich)

[Malkamaniac]

Well this has started out wonderful

[count2infinity]

Well this has started out wonderful

let's make it better....

waive Marty Straka

[Pavel Bure]

Well this has started out wonderful

let's make it better....

waive Marty Straka

I can get on board with that. waive Marty Straka

[redwill]

So there are eleven RPs. After two Superstars got deaded, that makes eleven RPs out of twenty-four, huh?

Wow.

[crayz]

waive Dino Ciccarelli


2 reasons:

1) He is new, first time player...which usually means they end up confusing us later on or don't play
2) He asked if he should reply to all mods - that makes me think he is an RP and since he was wasn't killed on night one by whatever the bad people are....that makes me think he is a bad people.

[mac5155]

can we either use real names or at least put the real names in the vote....... im getting sick of going back and looking who so-n-so is.. at least in the beginning.. or maybe put the NHL name in the 'location' of ur sig?

[redwill]

Right. I'll go with crayz for now.

waive thehockeyguru (Dino Ciccarelli)

[redwill]

Malkamaniac - 2 (count2infinity, Pavel Bure)
thehockeyguru - 2 (crayz, redwill)
jwienand - 1 (npv708)
Zarovich - 1 (mac5155)

[npv708]

I can get with Malkamaniac...

claim Jwienand
waive Malkamaniac

[npv708]

let me try that again

claim Jwienand
waive Malkamaniac

[Pavel Bure]

I don't like killing a possible role player this early in the game. I'm only OK with the Malkamaniac waive because he's instantly on the "this is bad" routine even though it's only 2 people down in a 26 player game and neither was a role player. Typically it's a mob play to make an obvious "this is bad" comment to try and look sympathetic with the town.

[mac5155]

yeah obviously this is bad but its day 1 what do you expect

[redwill]

I don't like killing a possible role player this early in the game. I'm only OK with the Malkamaniac waive because he's instantly on the "this is bad" routine even though it's only 2 people down in a 26 player game and neither was a role player. Typically it's a mob play to make an obvious "this is bad" comment to try and look sympathetic with the town.

I agree that Malkamaniac's comment theoretically looks a little suspicious. I'd be willing to switch to him.

However, what's with your comment about not liking "killing a possible role player this early in the game"? Who likes that? What gives you any indication of who's a possible role-player?

[Pavel Bure]

I don't like killing a possible role player this early in the game. I'm only OK with the Malkamaniac waive because he's instantly on the "this is bad" routine even though it's only 2 people down in a 26 player game and neither was a role player. Typically it's a mob play to make an obvious "this is bad" comment to try and look sympathetic with the town.

I agree that Malkamaniac's comment theoretically looks a little suspicious. I'd be willing to switch to him.

However, what's with your comment about not liking "killing a possible role player this early in the game"? Who likes that? What gives you any indication of who's a possible role-player?

This

waive Dino Ciccarelli


2 reasons:

1) He is new, first time player...which usually means they end up confusing us later on or don't play
2) He asked if he should reply to all mods - that makes me think he is an RP and since he was wasn't killed on night one by whatever the bad people are....that makes me think he is a bad people.

[redwill]

Hmm.

[crayz]

Like I said in my post...If he is an RP, why wouldn't bad guys kill him right away? I'm a little leery on trusting "RP's this game"...after zaro did some good damage to the last game as a evil detective.

[Pavel Bure]

Like I said in my post...If he is an RP, why wouldn't bad guys kill him right away? I'm a little leery on trusting "RP's this game"...after zaro did some good damage to the last game as a evil detective.

There's too many reasons to count. It could be they didn't pick up on it. It could be they wanted someone they consider a more dangerous player out of the way rather than a noob. It could be like you said and he's bad. There's various other reasons but naming them all only serves to muddy up the game. At this point waiving him based simply because you think you picked up on him being a RP of some sort is very thin. I'd rather go with a proven mafia tell than risk killing a useful RP this early on.

Basically we have the info that he's most likely a RP, so it's not like he's going to go unnoticed the rest of the game.