History Mafia -- GAME THREAD

[bhaw]

I'm glad you guys got swayed the other day off nan.

Are you saying you knew he was bad?

So the mafia has no seer anymore, right?

[bhaw]

^err... it's night... don't answer that yet.

[slappybrown]

pwnt

[Kicksave]

[npv708]

NO!!!

you're killing the village!!! You must be mafia if you post pictures like that at night?

[mac5155]

quick writeup coming cuz i have a doc's appt

[npv708]

quick writeup coming cuz i have a doc's appt

[mac5155]

I got that BOOM BOOM POW! proclaims the assassin as he goes lock and load on

Hockeynut! - Sitting Bull

Then the mafia screams "I'll do you one better!!"

and grabs..

Spoiler:

O NO! A TOWN RP!!

and converts them as one of their own!


Still alive:

1. count2infinity - Benedict Arnold
2. slappybrown - Helen Herron Taft
3. npv708 - Aaron Burr
4. IrishEyes - Calamity Jane
5. Troy Loney - JP Morgan
7. relantel - John Adams
8. MWB - Robert E. Lee
9. Twisted Wrister - John F. Kennedy
10. Zarovich - Ben Franklin
12. crayz - Henry Ford
13. Kicksave - Andrew Carnegie
15. Corvidae - Richard Nixon
16. Redwill - Emperor Pedro II of Brazil
19. bhaw - Jesse James
20. cupkeeper - Robert Morris
21. tfrizz - Al Capone
22. PensFanInDC - George Patton
23. Senka - Joseph Schantz
26. the wicked child - George Washington
27. Azkar - Betsy Ross
28. LetangIsTheTruth - Jonas Salk


There are now:
5 Mafia Members
3 Town RPs
13 Townies

In the encyclopedia with two dates:

canaan - George Washington Carver - TOWN DEUPTY killed by the Mafia on Night 1.
thehockeyguru - Ferdinand Magellan - regular Townie lynched on his boat on day 1.
Dagny – Pocahontas – Mason killed by the Mafia on Night 2
Malkamaniac – Abe Lincoln - Regular Townie killed by the Assassin on Night 2
sdm5055 - Franklin D Roosevelt - Mason lyched by the Townies on Day 2
jaysmiter - Joseph Stalin -TOWN DOCTOR bound and killed by the Mafia on night 3
newarenanow - John Hancock - MAFIA COP lynched by the village on day 3
Hockeynut! - Sitting Bull - shot by the assassin on night 4

11 to lynch!!

[Kicksave]

Ok, after nan came out as red, who jumped on that bandwagon? Chances are he came out as red so when people jumped on, it would look less suspicious. I bet there is a baddie hiding in that list.

[PensFanInDC]

wtf!? I thought RPs couldnt be converted.

[Hockeynut!]

[Kicksave]

I'm glad you guys got swayed the other day off nan.

Are you saying you knew he was bad?

So the mafia has no seer anymore, right?

I'm not the good cop, if that's what you're asking. Nan was just acting weird and usually when we're closing to stringing someone up and then just switch, chances are that person always ends up bad.

[PensFanInDC]

Ok, after nan came out as red, who jumped on that bandwagon? Chances are he came out as red so when people jumped on, it would look less suspicious. I bet there is a baddie hiding in that list.

I was one of them. But how does that make me or anyone else that jumped on bad? He said he couldnt play anymore and outed himself as mafia. Of course people are going to switch to him.

[npv708]

Ok, after nan came out as red, who jumped on that bandwagon? Chances are he came out as red so when people jumped on, it would look less suspicious. I bet there is a baddie hiding in that list.

I have a couple of ideas about this, thinking that NAN probably said something to them like "hey I'm going to out myself, hop on and vote for me and it will help you guys throw the scent."

but, my first vote goes to Senka, who doesn't switch their vote for somebody that admits they're red. Even if you're unsure about their position, its the best lead we got all day.

[Corvidae]

Lynch bhaw. Add swaying everyone off NAN day 2 to my list.

[cup keeper]

What if nan told his mafia buddies that he wasn't going to be able to play and then they led the charge against him?

[PensFanInDC]

What if nan told his mafia buddies that he wasn't going to be able to play and then they led the charge against him?

Do you mean before or after he outed himself?

[MWB]

I think bhaw, npv, or redwill are the leading candidates. There has to be a reason that nan outed himself that way. Reading back over that section it was almost like he and bhaw were working together. bhaw calls him out, nan says to vote for him because he's sick, bhaw says that he's probably okay but stays with the vote... I don't know, just seemed odd.

I say npv and redwill because they both had votes when nan came out.

[crayz]

here's my thoughts....i dont have time to research atm while at work but if someone can...

1) List out who voted for nan on day 1 and who would not vote for nan
2) List who swapped off nan vs who stayed on nan
3) Who voted for nan yesterday/wouldn't vote

analyze these and i think we can make a suspect list

[cup keeper]

What if nan told his mafia buddies that he wasn't going to be able to play and then they led the charge against him?

Do you mean before or after he outed himself?

I mean before he outed himself.

[MWB]

I'm glad you guys got swayed the other day off nan.

Are you saying you knew he was bad?

So the mafia has no seer anymore, right?

I'm not the good cop, if that's what you're asking. Nan was just acting weird and usually when we're closing to stringing someone up and then just switch, chances are that person always ends up bad.

I also don't like how bhaw did this at night (even though his next post said not to answer it). Seemed like he was fishing.

[Troy Loney]

lynch bhaw

We need to know why he came out early to defend a nan vote.

[PensFanInDC]

What if nan told his mafia buddies that he wasn't going to be able to play and then they led the charge against him?

Do you mean before or after he outed himself?

I mean before he outed himself.

Yeah, that makes sense. If he did it after outing himself it would not.

[MWB]

Ok, after nan came out as red, who jumped on that bandwagon? Chances are he came out as red so when people jumped on, it would look less suspicious. I bet there is a baddie hiding in that list.

I have a couple of ideas about this, thinking that NAN probably said something to them like "hey I'm going to out myself, hop on and vote for me and it will help you guys throw the scent."

.

So it would more likely be people who voted for nan before he came out, right?

[npv708]

here's my thoughts....i dont have time to research atm while at work but if someone can...

1) List out who voted for nan on day 1 and who would not vote for nan
2) List who swapped off nan vs who stayed on nan
3) Who voted for nan yesterday/wouldn't vote

analyze these and i think we can make a suspect list

I agree that this is a good way to go. I voted for NAN a few times over the last few days, but switched on/off. It won't do much to help my case, but it might help a little bit.