bhaw wrote:bandwagon lynching is such a bad idea for this version...
Why is it any different? People threw out some thoughts. Other than that we don't know anything.
I definitely agree that before Jose gets the 11th vote, we wait for a response though.
Since there is a time limit, there can't be any long, drawn out discussions that just go back and forth, back and forth.
B/c this time, if you bandwagon someone that doesn't even make sense to jump on right away (unless you somehow think that with zero comments, he's the alpha?), you lose a villager and another wolf is converted. So there is one more wolf and 2 less villagers because your vote was based on "everyone else was doing it." I think you have to put SOME strategy into your vote, even the 1st one.
Yeah, I definitely agree that you have to think this out some and not do it "just because everyone else does". I guess I didn't type out my thoughts that well.
I think you should explain why you are voting for someone, and everyone should have a chance to defend themselves before the final vote.
But I do think that eventually you have to make a choice, especially at the beginning when the odds of you lynching a villager are very, very high. It's 90% right now.
newarenanow wrote:Yeah, I definitely agree that you have to think this out some and not do it "just because everyone else does". I guess I didn't type out my thoughts that well.
I think you should explain why you are voting for someone, and everyone should have a chance to defend themselves before the final vote.
But I do think that eventually you have to make a choice, especially at the beginning when the odds of you lynching a villager are very, very high. It's 90% right now.
I think this as well. If you think it out and JC is your vote, great. But we already have a bunch of people saying they are voting for jose because it's the bandwagon and to just get it moving along.
newarenanow wrote:Yeah, I definitely agree that you have to think this out some and not do it "just because everyone else does". I guess I didn't type out my thoughts that well.
I think you should explain why you are voting for someone, and everyone should have a chance to defend themselves before the final vote.
But I do think that eventually you have to make a choice, especially at the beginning when the odds of you lynching a villager are very, very high. It's 90% right now.
I think this as well. If you think it out and JC is your vote, great. But we already have a bunch of people saying they are voting for jose because it's the bandwagon and to just get it moving along.
Even with the new rules how can someone make a really thought out guess at this point? JC is a good player and therefore would be in my top 3 choices to convert. Thats my reasoning. There's nothing much more to go on than that...
newarenanow wrote:Yeah, I definitely agree that you have to think this out some and not do it "just because everyone else does". I guess I didn't type out my thoughts that well.
I think you should explain why you are voting for someone, and everyone should have a chance to defend themselves before the final vote.
But I do think that eventually you have to make a choice, especially at the beginning when the odds of you lynching a villager are very, very high. It's 90% right now.
I think this as well. If you think it out and JC is your vote, great. But we already have a bunch of people saying they are voting for jose because it's the bandwagon and to just get it moving along.
75% of lynching a villager....10% chance of lynching a wolf......15% chance of lynching a role player....for the record.
newarenanow wrote:Yeah, I definitely agree that you have to think this out some and not do it "just because everyone else does". I guess I didn't type out my thoughts that well.
I think you should explain why you are voting for someone, and everyone should have a chance to defend themselves before the final vote.
But I do think that eventually you have to make a choice, especially at the beginning when the odds of you lynching a villager are very, very high. It's 90% right now.
I think this as well. If you think it out and JC is your vote, great. But we already have a bunch of people saying they are voting for jose because it's the bandwagon and to just get it moving along.
Even with the new rules how can someone make a really thought out guess at this point? JC is a good player and therefore would be in my top 3 choices to convert. Thats my reasoning. There's nothing much more to go on than that...
That's fine, but several people have said they are going with the bandwagon with no reasoning.