Super Mario Bros Warz: Bowser's Revenge GAME THREAD

[PensFanInDC]

Maybe he has a power to be protected from night attacks and knows it. Maybe the vig is rel or another quiet player who isn't checking the game thread and doesn't realize he should try and kill Doc. I think we have a red in our sights and we should finish him off. Worst case scenario is he's blue and our vig can attack someone else tonight and maybe hits a red.

[Willie Kool]

That sounds pretty red, PFIDC.

I'm kind of worried that Mario comes back blue to the seer.

[CBear3]

(2) rel - BigMcK, WK
(0) redwill - WK
(3) Doc - dagny, SDD, WK, PFiDC, redwill
(1) dagny- Doc

[Willie Kool]

I think we have a red in our sights and we should finish him off. Worst case scenario is he's blue and our vig can attack someone else tonight and maybe hits a red.

No, worst case is he is the vig, we kill him, waste another day and then have no vig.

Even if that weren't the case, the vig randomly killing at this point isn't a great idea considering the seer is out and the angel is protecting her.

[DocEmrick]

Blue dagny

Yellow relantel

[PensFanInDC]

He said "IM NOT MARIO!". He never said he wasn't red. We've killed one red and I can only assume the game started with more than 2.

I SWEAR I'M NOT MARIO

So you're red but not Mario. Toadstool?

POPCORN

Also you voted for doc less than 12 hours ago. All of a sudden he role claims when a bandwagon is on him so you let off?

And then there is this:

Actually, with the numbers we have, it might be best if Doc is lying for the real Hammer Bro to come out now. What does everyone else think?

It could be seriously argued that your behavior is more red than mine.

Crankshaft
Willie Kool (I know I'm a blue Goomba)
MR25
PFiDC
rel
SDD
redwill
dagny
Doc (claimed green - Hammer Bro #1)
Canaan
BigMcK

If we kill doc today the vig has a 1 in 6 chance at hitting a red if there is 1 red left and 1 in 3 if there are 2 reds left. Those are pretty good odds in my book.

And now Doc comes in and changes his vote from a green RP to rel. Why did you vote for dagny in the first place?

[CBear3]

(3) rel - BigMcK, WK, Doc
(0) redwill - WK
(3) Doc - dagny, SDD, WK, PFiDC, redwill
(0) dagny- Doc

[Willie Kool]

Also you voted for doc less than 12 hours ago. All of a sudden he role claims when a bandwagon is on him so you let off?

Isn't that how almost every game goes?

And then there is this:

Actually, with the numbers we have, it might be best if Doc is lying for the real Hammer Bro to come out now. What does everyone else think?

It could be seriously argued that your behavior is more red than mine.

LOL - getting a little defensive there. If you think I'm red, by all means argue for it.

If we kill doc today the vig has a 1 in 6 chance at hitting a red if there is 1 red left and 1 in 3 if there are 2 reds left. Those are pretty good odds in my book.

There is also a 1 in 6 chance of killing the angel and a 4 in 6 chance of hitting a good player. Really not such good odds.

And now Doc comes in and changes his vote from a green RP to rel. Why did you vote for dagny in the first place?

This I would like to see answered.

[Willie Kool]

If Hammer Bro #1 isn't Doc and he comes out we can kill Doc today. Dagny will get another see tonight to narrow things down even more. I really think this is the right play. If no one comes out as vig, we pretty much have to believe Doc's claim.

[relantel]

I am nothing of consequence. Was home with sick kid yesterday.

lynch doc. Sure seems like he is lying. But if he isn't, better me gone than a green.

re day one - thought I'd change it up. Since I am usually last... and I happened to be on before anyone had voted. So, yeah, that turned out real well.

[Willie Kool]

I am nothing of consequence. Was home with sick kid yesterday.

lynch doc. Sure seems like he is lying. But if he isn't, better me gone than a green.

You do know it goes to a weighted random if no majority, right? So you're 'better me than a green' is BS lip service if you have a vote on him.

[Willie Kool]

^your

[CBear3]

(3) rel - BigMcK, WK, Doc
(0) redwill - WK
(4) Doc - dagny, SDD, WK, PFiDC, redwill, rel
(0) dagny- Doc

[DocEmrick]

Blue rel

Lynch canaan

[Willie Kool]

No vote:

Crankshaft
MR25
SDD
canaan

2 hours to deadline

[MRandall25]

Sorry, slept in and was in the act of packing for the trip this weekend when all this went down.

I am inclined to believe Doc's claim, if only because I don't really want us to vote out yet another vig during the day phase (thanks again, WK). Worst comes to worst, he's lying and the real vig takes care of him tonight and/or dagny sees him to confirm his identity.

Lynch rel

He's been his usual quiet self, but almost too quiet. Also doesn't really make sense to say "better me gone than a green", then voting for the person who is claiming to be green. If you really didn't want to lose a green, you wouldn't have voted for him.

[relantel]

the method of doc's claim seemed dubious to me on reading - "I SWEAR I'M NOT MARIO" and then votes for the Seer.

[PensFanInDC]

And switches votes twice without explanation

[dagny]

What is your hammer bros. character, doc?

I was certain he was a RPer. The gamble is, which color? He struck me as red.

I'm having a really hard time believing him with the way he's "defended" himself.

[MRandall25]

So here's the conundrum: do we want to have this go to the blender again?

I could be convinced to change my vote to Doc, but if he is truly the vig, can we afford to lose him?

[MRandall25]

Accidentally hit submit before I really finished my thought, and can't edit, so...

... can we afford to lose him after we've already lost Hammer Bro #2 and the Koopa Troopa?

[DocEmrick]

What is your hammer bros. character, doc?

I was certain he was a RPer. The gamble is, which color? He struck me as red.

I'm having a really hard time believing him with the way he's "defended" himself.

Hammer Bros #1

[DocEmrick]

And switches votes twice without explanation

Vote for Canaan he's gotta be red.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

It would suck, but considering that the vigs have killed more blues than reds, it might not be a huge loss. Of course if Doc is green and survives, it is possible that him or dagny will not make it through the night if there is only one angel

[CBear3]

(3) rel - BigMcK, WK, Doc, MR25
(1) canaan - Doc
(0) redwill - WK
(4) Doc - dagny, SDD, WK, PFiDC, redwill, rel
(0) dagny- Doc

1 hour to go