*** Jellyfish Invasion IV: The Phantom Jelly GDT ***

[MRandall25]

Just putting this here:

net MRandall

1) Day 1 bandwagon (2 votes on him and 4 others at 1)
2) His play last game

net Mrandall25

Since he seemed so enthusiastic about it in the sign up thread.

That was on Day 1, when I had only 1 vote (Crankshaft, who always votes for me Day 1, to try to piss me off).

... the reds can't be THIS bad. It's impossible to be this bad.

This makes me think mr is bad.

This was the day phase that MWB was killed, and we found he was red.

Why would reds push that hard to get rid of one of their own, especially that late in the game (in MWB's case)?

Honestly, c2i, give me one reason why you think I'm red, other than the fact I was the one who said we should vote you off?

And, if you do in fact think NAN and I are both red, why would I have voted for NAN in 2 consecutive day phases early in the game (one of which you were also in on)?

[dagny]

I would've thought the fact dodint and PFIDC tried to start the bandwagon rolling on me day 1 would've been an indicator to you guys that I'm not red, but...

THIS actually would have been a smart thing for them to do, knowing that you were likely to be killed first. They'd have the same liability with me. I normally get killed fast. If the reds got stuck with me, their smartest bet would be to distance themselves from me, ASAP.

[MRandall25]

Still doesn't explain why MWB tried to get a vote started on me later in the game.

[Rylan]

Yea especially since Randall gets killed quite often because of his play style.

[count2infinity]

Randall is really the new THG... he's either dead in the first few days, or he's red.

[MRandall25]

I've tried to make it fairly clear that I'm not red during the game.

If I were red, you know for a fact I wouldn't have gone after you as hard as I did. That would just be dumb, for me to stick my neck out there like that.

Think instead of making snarky comments, just for this once.

[dagny]

This game interrupted by friendly board moderator PSA:

It seems a reminder is in order, that in warz games TAKE NOTHING PERSONAL!

We made a separate section, partly so that the moderating could be loosened in the spirit of being able to play the game. We've had games where people have had to assume certain roles, and be total jackasses to the other players. Messing with each other is a strategy to get reactions from people. These are role playing games. TAKE NOTHING PERSONAL

slappy says he wants to shoot me in the face repeatedly... I laugh... because we're playing warz. If one is going to play these games, then they need to understand and be able to accept certain unspoken rules of this forum. It's a game. It's supposed to be fun. We all give each other crap here. It's not personal.

We now return you to your regular broadcasted game.... Play on!

[MRandall25]

I take it personally that you think I'm taking this personally

[count2infinity]

Can I change my vote from net randall to shoot him in the face?

[MRandall25]

Seriously, just say the only reason you think I'm red is because I pushed for your demise.

Say it.

[count2infinity]

you couldn't be more red... it's not even funny at this point, just sad.

[MRandall25]

That's fine. We'll see what pops up when you waste a vote on me.

[dagny]

Still doesn't explain why MWB tried to get a vote started on me later in the game.

Same reasoning. Knowing your life in the game is limited and/or that crank could investigate you, if he'd started a vote and you turned up red, he looks like the hero.

I'm not sold that you're red, but you sure are fighting hard. (See? This is part of how we narrow it down, discussion and reactions, before throwing out actual votes.) I haven't played warz enough with you to know how strategic you think.

If it wasn't the start of the weekend, NAN's and Pecky's silence right now would be more cause for suspicion for me. But, they may just not be around.

[MRandall25]

Still doesn't explain why MWB tried to get a vote started on me later in the game.

Same reasoning. Knowing your life in the game is limited and/or that crank could investigate you, if he'd started a vote and you turned up red, he looks like the hero.

I'm not sold that you're red, but you sure are fighting hard.

Sure I'm fighting hard. I don't want the village to waste the day voting out a blue. Especially since we lost the seer and a blue in the last night phase. Voting me would be a waste of the village's time. I'd say "believe me", but I'm just as blue to you as anyone else on your list of 3.

If it wasn't the start of the weekend, NAN's and Pecky's silence right now would be more cause for suspicion for me. But, they may just not be around.

They've had the entire game to be active though. NAN and Pecky were both conveniently absent during votes on reds. I could see Pecky being busy, but NAN has been active elsewhere on the site. I don't think he really has an excuse.

And that is why I think NAN is our guy.

[MRandall25]

I'd say "believe me", but I'm just as blue to you as anyone else on your list of 3 (which is to say, not very convincing, at this point).

An addendum, since I can't edit.

[count2infinity]

we have a list of 3, out of 11 right? we kill all three of them, the reds then kill 3 straight nights that gets us down to 5 people left. Either way the village comes out looking alright. Might I suggest we start with randall?

[obhave]

If anything Mrand seems like an indie. The red votes dont add up. Pecky or man seems more likely to me.

[count2infinity]

The indie roll wasn't something I thought of but would explain the voting and him freaking out with just one vote on him.

[MRandall25]

I don't see how me trying to defend myself and presenting an argument for someone who's arguably a better candidate to vote of than I "freaking out".

If I were an independent, and my goal was to outlast the reds and the village, why would I be putting myself into this position to start? How I play is incredibly counterproductive to survival (and I've said it, I'm surprised I've lasted this long).

If I were an independent, I would sit back and hide, just like NAN and Pecky are.

[MRandall25]

Like, if I were an independent, helping out the village and being an active player would be the last thing I would even think of doing.

Sort of like my play during the c2i vote. Neither a red nor an independent would ever have made that play, because it was really dumb of me to stick my neck out like that and push that hard. That vote is likely why my name is even coming up in the discussions right now. If I hadn't gone so hard on it, we'd likely be arguing the merits of a NAN or Pecky vote.

A red or independent, in my experience, would never put themselves out there like I did. It would be (and almost is) basically suicide since it was inevitable c2i was going to come back like he does in these games.

[Rylan]

[count2infinity]

I think at this point, you're just too big of a question mark. We need to kill you or we'll never know.

[the wicked child]

mod note: I wouldn't typically do this, but I made a slight update to the previous writeup. I realized after reading through some posts that I had left something out.

[obhave]

Ah, so the jellies did kill crank

[dagny]

I note it's singular: "A" satisfied jelly.

If there is only one left, and we don't get them this vote, we face the risk they might be able to recruit in the next night phase.