*** Wars of Beleriand Game Thread ***

[PensFanInDC]

Yeah, I'm with MWB. I don't buy everything MR25 is saying to be truth just because it's interesting.

I don't believe him because "it's interesting". I believe him (so far) because what he has said has come true so far. His theories on a Union notwithstanding.

[MWB]

Randall has been honest about everything so far and there is evidence to back that up. I don't want to mark him as bad just because his color is orange and he had been protected at night (something he had been totally honest about). In my experience the reds (or baddies) try to lie their way through. Honesty, when proven by actions, usually lends to innocence. I am not saying he is 100% good but he has been open and honest about his role.

How could we possibly know he has been honest? There is some stuff that was provable. There is also a lot of stuff that we have no idea about.

He was honest about Slappy's role (unless he and slappy are in cahoots)
He was honest about his color being orange and Shaf being part of his clan
He was honest about his ability to be protected at night

I'm not saying everything he said is infallible but it's been pretty spot on so far.

Do we know he is orange? Has that been proven?

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Before I vote for anyone, I think it is prudent to see if Zaro's seer found any additonal information last night that could help us.

Without any additonal info, I have Troy Loney at the top of my list. He seems to be spending too much time outing role players that aren't red.

[PensFanInDC]

Before I vote for anyone, I think it is prudent to see if Zaro's seer found any additonal information last night that could help us.

Without any additonal info, I have Troy Loney at the top of my list. He seems to be spending too much time outing role players that aren't red.

Good call. Paging Dr. Zaro!

[MWB]

Yeah, I'm with MWB. I don't buy everything MR25 is saying to be truth just because it's interesting.

I don't believe him because "it's interesting". I believe him (so far) because what he has said has come true so far. His theories on a Union notwithstanding.

That's the other thing that has caught my attention. Every time he mentions union he puts it in green, as if to subliminally tell us that he is good.

[dodint]

Like I said, any new news comes to light I'll move my vote. For instance, here are some people I know nothing about:

obhave
ulf
relantel
Kaizer

In no particular order, just folks on my list of notes that have nothing annotated next to their name.

[ulf]

Yeah, I'm with MWB. I don't buy everything MR25 is saying to be truth just because it's interesting.

I don't believe him because "it's interesting". I believe him (so far) because what he has said has come true so far. His theories on a Union notwithstanding.

That's the other thing that has caught my attention. Every time he mentions union he puts it in green, as if to subliminally tell us that he is good.

So someone else noticed that. I think he's trying really hard to make it seem like his faction is good. Why would Shad lie? Being dumb isn't a good answer (even if he is ;) )

Unless zaro gas some good info, i'm going with mrandall

[MRandall25]

I would assume an angel protected me last night, because as I understood it, I only got one free protect.

[dodint]

I noticed the Union stuff too but it's not quite that easy to sway me.

[Crankshaft]

Im thinking pfidc is the right play. He didnt vote for canaan or mac. Seems suspicious, no?

Also could be down for a mrandall vote.

I've had a gut feeling re: PFiDC but haven't had enough "proof" to really put it out there.

With that said, I'd vote for him.

Your gut sucks

I was right with canaan.

[MWB]

I would assume an angel protected me last night, because as I understood it, I only got one free protect.

You would assume but you don't know? Could you communicate with shaf via pm?

[PensFanInDC]

MWB's hard push on Randall is very suspicious to me. I want to wait for Zaro but so far I am aiming at MWB.

[MRandall25]

I would assume an angel protected me last night, because as I understood it, I only got one free protect.

You would assume but you don't know? Could you communicate with shaf via pm?

I didn't really want to give it away, but I was protected by my faction's angel last night.

[ulf]

You really don't give anything away by saying that

[MWB]

Why would you not want to give that away? Also, this is the second time you've made a vague post like that, then get questioned, then come clean right away. I can't tell if you're trying to hide something or if it's something else.

[Willie Kool]

Lynch MWB

[Kaizer]

That gives away nothing, as nobody else would have protected you.

[ulf]

I think we should wait for zaro before we get anything rolling here

[redwill]

That gives away nothing, as nobody else would have protected you.

Haha.

[Willie Kool]

That gives away nothing, as nobody else would have protected you.

MRandall is obviously trying to keep the reds guessing re: his protection abilities.

[obhave]

That gives away nothing, as nobody else would have protected you.

MRandall is obviously trying to keep the reds guessing re: his protection abilities.

Didnt he say previously his faction had an angel? This shouldnt shock anyone hah

[Willie Kool]

Unless some other faction tried to kill him the last two nights, he has sidetracked 2 red night kills.

If another faction has tried to kill him both nights, are the reds now unable to kill since their 'assassin' canaan was killed?

[Zarovich]

My seer looked a slappy and he is who mrandall is said he is. We didn't acquire the ability to pm him but we did acquire a day save. I was hoping we would be able to join houses like has been talked about but no luck.

I am still up in the air about mrandall and his house in this game but I would like to hear from slappy on this also.

[PensFanInDC]

Lynch MWB

[dodint]

What's the rationale with the MWB vote? Just reaction to the general silence so far or something tangible I missed? Genuinely curious.