thought PB made sure to meation the League of Shadows a number of times.thehockeyguru wrote:The village has NO chance when they have no idea how many role players there are and what the roles are. Add in the fact that there was no mention of a conversion in any of the write ups doomed us from the start.
I don't know why that would tip off recruiting, especially when you could recruit a green RP.relantel wrote:thought PB made sure to meation the League of Shadows a number of times.thehockeyguru wrote:The village has NO chance when they have no idea how many role players there are and what the roles are. Add in the fact that there was no mention of a conversion in any of the write ups doomed us from the start.
I thought for sure the first cranky vs slappy day someone would pick up on it. Even moreso going into the 2nd day.
I thought I was being heavy handed with the league of shadows thing but I'm on the outside looking in :/slappybrown wrote:I dont think it was to be honest. Other than something being "amiss" at one point.
There was no mention of it in any write-up. Then Slappy was going on about how "there wasn't any kills" that he was role blocking.....canaan wrote:how many times was "recruit" even mention during the game. there was literally no heat in that regard.
What? Very rarely these days are the roles posted to start the game.thehockeyguru wrote:The village has NO chance when they have no idea how many role players there are and what the roles are. Add in the fact that there was no mention of a conversion in any of the write ups doomed us from the start.
Yeah if the leader dies no more recruitsrelantel wrote:Pecky was the last one.
It wasn't stated, but I assumed the League's recruiting ability would cease if I died.
this isnt the first game that recruitment was not mentionedthehockeyguru wrote:I'm fine with the roles not being posted, but if there is something out of the ordinary going on ie: players getting recruited its only fair that you mention it in a write-up
It is far more fun if one does not know going in what or how many there are. We just assume the main customary roles are there, as most games have them. A game like this is instructive in remembering to consider all the possibilities.Pavel Bure wrote:What? Very rarely these days are the roles posted to start the game.thehockeyguru wrote:The village has NO chance when they have no idea how many role players there are and what the roles are. Add in the fact that there was no mention of a conversion in any of the write ups doomed us from the start.
What? That would take away the cults advantage. Remember they start as one person not a mob.thehockeyguru wrote:I'm fine with the roles not being posted, but if there is something out of the ordinary going on ie: players getting recruited its only fair that you mention it in a write-up
HAd you recruited me and then turned on me, it would have been excellent. What could I have done but play along? Certainly a theory about what was really going wasnt going to be acceptedcanaan wrote:we had a good laugh at slappy's expense during this game. he was so angry that people werent listening to him, it ended up making him look guilty in the process. if not guilty, people were just happy to get rid of him. he was the League of Shadows' 2013 el oh el MVP(tm)
we, for a little bit, discussed recruiting slappy and then out him the next day phase just for the epic volcano that would have erupted.
Yeah, I don't know why that has any realevance, the number of RPs are never posted.Pavel Bure wrote:What? Very rarely these days are the roles posted to start the game.thehockeyguru wrote:The village has NO chance when they have no idea how many role players there are and what the roles are. Add in the fact that there was no mention of a conversion in any of the write ups doomed us from the start.
IN toher games with recruits we have played, if the red recuirts a green they both die.newarenanow wrote:Yeah, I don't know why that has any realevance, the number of RPs are never posted.Pavel Bure wrote:What? Very rarely these days are the roles posted to start the game.thehockeyguru wrote:The village has NO chance when they have no idea how many role players there are and what the roles are. Add in the fact that there was no mention of a conversion in any of the write ups doomed us from the start.
What made it almost impossible w/o killing rel early was that he had unlimited recruits, and he could recruit a green, especially in a small game like this.
You have to look at it from the village perspective in that we are blind and can't communicate. If a green is outed, the reds should have to make a choice between killing them at night and bypassing a recruit, or letting them live and help the village. Being able to recruit them made it an absolute no brainer, you get them on your side, the village has all the trust in them, and it takes away the only "eyes" if you will an otherwise blind village has.
IMO, there should be a limit on the number of recruits and greens shouldn't be able to be recruited.
The cult assumed that the village would figure out that it was all about recruiting, since there were no night kills happening....that didn't happen.thehockeyguru wrote:We were having a dialogue the whole 2nd/3rd day about why no one was getting killed at night. No one even mentioned recruting because there was no reason to believe it was going on. The only info we had was there was 1 role blocker who claimed to be Green.
i think this is validnewarenanow wrote:
IMO, there should be a limit on the number of recruits and greens shouldn't be able to be recruited.
That's because slappy said he role blocked everyone.columbia wrote:The cult assumed that the village would figure out that it was all about recruiting, since there were no night kills happening....that didn't happen.thehockeyguru wrote:We were having a dialogue the whole 2nd/3rd day about why no one was getting killed at night. No one even mentioned recruting because there was no reason to believe it was going on. The only info we had was there was 1 role blocker who claimed to be Green.