WW XXIV: An Ode to lycanthropy (Game Thread)

[Rylan]

So why not consider another vote and have the vig shoot shad. Shad knows its coming and can block it. If he does we get a red tomorrow. Cause we are driving ourselves insane.

[ulf]

So why not consider another vote and have the vig shoot shad. Shad knows its coming and can block it. If he does we get a red tomorrow. Cause we are driving ourselves insane.

this makes sense to me.

[DocEmrick]

blue shad

kill CBear

[shafnutz05]

wait so because he didn't say "I'M THE SEER GUYS!!!111!!!" ?? I mean, read my previous post quoting everyone. It was widely understood as a green role claim.

I feel like I am speaking a foreign language...no one is denying he made an obvious role claim. I pointed it out at the time.

What IS in dispute is when he came out as the SEER, a point that is vital to his argument and he is flat out lying about. He made a green role claim, he didn't come out as the seer.

So what does he do? He goes back to his "i don't SEE this working out well for the village" and tries to pretend he was actually trying to identify himself as the seer there. That is laughably unbelievable.

[DocEmrick]

Shad...do you have HBP?

[obhave]

So why not consider another vote and have the vig shoot shad. Shad knows its coming and can block it. If he does we get a red tomorrow. Cause we are driving ourselves insane.

this makes sense to me.

What if he is not able to save himself two nights in a row?

[ulf]

wait so because he didn't say "I'M THE SEER GUYS!!!111!!!" ?? I mean, read my previous post quoting everyone. It was widely understood as a green role claim.

I feel like I am speaking a foreign language...no one is denying he made an obvious role claim. I pointed it out at the time.

What IS in dispute is when he came out as the SEER, a point that is vital to his argument and he is flat out lying about. He made a green role claim, he didn't come out as the seer.

So what does he do? He goes back to his "i don't SEE this working out well for the village" and tries to pretend he was actually trying to identify himself as the seer there. That is laughably unbelievable.

So then you're fine with Rylan's idea right? Vig is going to shoot you tonight, and you'll stop it because you're the angel. Then we will know for sure and kill a red tomorrow. There is 0% chance we can kill a green in this situation. Am I missing something?

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Uh if we vote cbear and he is red I think there's a pretty slim chance shad is red. And unless the write up says the vig shot at the angel, it's going to take the vig to out himself for us to know that occurred. It would be a waste of a kill shot.

[Rylan]

So why not consider another vote and have the vig shoot shad. Shad knows its coming and can block it. If he does we get a red tomorrow. Cause we are driving ourselves insane.

this makes sense to me.

What if he is not able to save himself two nights in a row?

It's a suggestion that I think needs discussed

[Letang Is The Truth]

Is it possible that the seer and the angel are able to communicate and they are staying quiet ergo they know who the angel will protect?

[ulf]

Uh if we vote cbear and he is red I think there's a pretty slim chance shad is red. And unless the write up says the vig shot at the angel, it's going to take the vig to out himself for us to know that occurred. It would be a waste of a kill shot.

I don't think Rylan's play means we kill cbear. I think it's best to not vote either, and shoot shad tonight. If Shad is alive tomorrow, we kill cbear.

[Kaizer]

So why not consider another vote and have the vig shoot shad. Shad knows its coming and can block it. If he does we get a red tomorrow. Cause we are driving ourselves insane.

this makes sense to me.

What if he is not able to save himself two nights in a row?

It's a suggestion that I think needs discussed

well if he's the angel, he has that info.

[Rylan]

Exactly ulf. We think about another player and go from there. It would give us a better idea of what's going on instead of all this confusion. The village needs to take back control.

[shafnutz05]

Exactly ulf. We think about another player and go from there. It would give us a better idea of what's going on instead of all this confusion. The village needs to take back control.

Your plan is fine in theory, but we are way too close to the deadline IMO to implement this. Is it a plurality or majority vote? (On phone)

[Kaizer]

i think theres enough people to get a majority on someone in time, if we manage to agree

[Rylan]

When is the deadline?

[Kaizer]

save shaf

so who?

[Kaizer]

When is the deadline?

9 pm

[obhave]

So why not consider another vote and have the vig shoot shad. Shad knows its coming and can block it. If he does we get a red tomorrow. Cause we are driving ourselves insane.

this makes sense to me.

What if he is not able to save himself two nights in a row?

It's a suggestion that I think needs discussed

well if he's the angel, he has that info.

yes he does, but if he is the real angel its not like you want the reds knowing how often you can save yourself or how many times in a row you can save the same person. That is very valuable information for the reds.

[ulf]

9:00 AM I thought

[ulf]

Shaf said it's fine in theory. Guessing he can protect himself every night then

[shafnutz05]

I am trying really hard to not give up all the info as far as what my protection schedule is, and this plan being pushed forward would force me to do that...

[canaan]

9:00 AM I thought

this is correct

[shafnutz05]

This plan is a really, really bad idea, ok?

[Kaizer]

the deadline is set 21:00 hours

? that isnt 9 am