CBear3 wrote:If that's true, redwill would have known who a green was (the non-recruit night 2). He voted for nan yesterday. It's possible that they tried to recruit nan night 2 and failed. So he votes for him day 3 (day 2 was shaf). Seeing obhave be so determined tips the reds that she's probably another green, hence her death on night 4.
Make any sense?
Yes, but they also would have known the angel after night 1, assuming that was indeed a save. So it's possible they failed night 1 (protect), night 2 (failed to recruit vig), and succeeded night 3.
They would know there was an angel, but not who it was night 1. A failed recruit on night 2 would tell them they found a green, but not the role.
Obhave being a super snipe probably tipped her as the seer.
Or there was a day 3 recruit when redwill was in his death throws.
Willie Kool wrote:No, my basic premise is that you were at first trying to cast doubt on there having been a recruit. Then, after the write up said there had been one, trying to make it seem like it just happened so we couldn't look back at the previous day. Looking through the game, I think you are by far the best play today. As far as my play being a change up, I was on shaf like white on rice day 1.
Yet you still don't have an explanation for my early vote on redwill. Or an explanation of night 2. I'm just trying to flesh out all the options instead of being so focused on just one thing.
CBear3 wrote:They would know there was an angel, but not who it was night 1. A failed recruit on night 2 would tell them they found a green, but not the role.
Obhave being a super snipe probably tipped her as the seer.
Or there was a day 3 recruit when redwill was in his death throws.
Clarifying that its entirely possible they failed to recruit obhave night 2, couldn't afford to off her on night 3 because she didn't budge off redwill on day 2 even with all the momentum on shaf. In which case they don't know any of the surviving greens.
CBear3 wrote:They would know there was an angel, but not who it was night 1. A failed recruit on night 2 would tell them they found a green, but not the role.
Obhave being a super snipe probably tipped her as the seer.
Or there was a day 3 recruit when redwill was in his death throws.
Yes, night one they would know who the angel is. They put in the kill and see that the person was saved. The angel would only save himself night 1.
So they try to kill NAN night one, but he's the angel and saves himself.
They try to recruit obhave night 2, but find she's green.
Have to recruit night 3, because obhave has already set the wheels in motion to get Redwill lynched on day 3.
Night 4 they finally get to kill obhave, the seer.
Not sure that got me much closer, but oh well. After last game's quiet, and ulf calling my logic false yesterday, I decided I'd just post my stream of consciousness,
I would rather people do that than just spout votes off.
As for Troy, the whole telling everyone to slow down then makes a vote himself still sits uneasy with me.
But no one bothers me enough at this moment to make me want to vote. Luckily I have today off and wouldn't mind waiting a couple hours to see where things go.
newarenanow wrote:I'm between Rylan and ulf. Have to go back and look at a few things.
Why them?
I know I'm going to get heat for this, but I'll put it out there anyway. The angel and vig should come out. We have seven left. If we can eliminate two suspects, that leaves us only five. Having two trusted players would really help right now.
I think if anyone comes out it should only be the angel. He can at least protect himself from harm and there would be no repercussions since the reds already know who he is.
MWB wrote:Yes, night one they would know who the angel is. They put in the kill and see that the person was saved. The angel would only save himself night 1.
This being the case, I think it might help to let the village know I am Ned Flanders
