MWB wrote:I could easily see a red getting on a shaf vote early on day 2. He knew he was going down after what happened on day 1, so the other reds knew he was going down. Voting early for him makes it look better.
Why take the risk? Look how long it took us to get back to canaan last game after he was one vote short of a lynch on day 1. You certainly don't cast the first vote like Rylan did. I gave an entirely flippant case for voting for him just to keep conversation going.
So shaf's a third of the way to being lynched, comes out as the vig, and redwill jumps in and laughs at him. Maybe red=red, I even sent him a PM commending him for calling shaf out (and giving my identity as Chief) before I came out as Chief Wiggum but didn't get a response. So maybe that does mean he's red.
I just think its throwing in the towel awfully early if a red voted on shaf that early when the tide could still be changed.
CBear3 wrote:You certainly don't cast the first vote like Rylan did.
I don't know about that. The reds had to know we would come back at shaf on day 2, and what better place to get cover than the first vote? I can't see Rylan as clear just because of that vote.
canaan wrote:im at the top of your list because i dont follow random.org...
Went back and checked, and in the last four games you've only followed the random once on day one, and that was after you'd already voted on somebody else.
I have to take off for a while, probably won't be back until around 7pm. With the info CBear just posted re: canaan and random.org votes, I would say it's going to be either redwill or TL for me.
CBear3 wrote:You certainly don't cast the first vote like Rylan did.
I don't know about that. The reds had to know we would come back at shaf on day 2, and what better place to get cover than the first vote? I can't see Rylan as clear just because of that vote.
Took you (somebody I believe to be blue) and MWB a page and half before you'd vote for him after he claimed vig. So obviously the claim of vig made people think, even after it was done last game and seemed unlikely with the number of players. And that's after people were sure they were coming back to him for day 2.
Like I said, I think that'd be a pretty scorched earth policy. That's why I'm not going along on a redwill vote today, and why it'll take a lot for me to be skeptical of Rylan.
How is it that nan has three votes? Redwill has his cockamamie theory, so he votes for him. TL votes for him and then states that maybe we should slow down and not rush things. And cbear votes for him because of his magic list. It's an interesting group of votes.
CBear3 wrote:save nan
I figure the last red would be more involved if the vote were this close to ending the game.
?
There's one red left?
Don't know, it would seem kind of stacked with three reds and 9 good guys; but I suppose they could have started at two, seen shaf blow his lid at the random and used their recruit early to get another quick in case he went down on day 2 like he did.
So maybe two left, but if we nab a red today I'd be shocked to see the village lose.
Just caught up and it seems to me that redwill was being really antagonistic. I don't know if that means anything but he's definitely in my top 2 with TL being the other one telling us to slow down but instead votes quickly. Seems odd.
But at the moment redwill seems like the best choice:
Rylan wrote:Just caught up and it seems to me that redwill was being really antagonistic.
I'm usually accused of that. At least you didn't call me a "sarcastic bastard" like Gaucho did a few games ago. I was green then, but am just blue now, if you believe that.
Rylan wrote:Just caught up and it seems to me that redwill was being really antagonistic. I don't know if that means anything but he's definitely in my top 2 with TL being the other one telling us to slow down but instead votes quickly. Seems odd.
But at the moment redwill seems like the best choice:
yellow redwill
I feel like we're just lynching the first person whose name gets thrown out there.
I just think the reasons for the MWB vote are weak. Also wanted to see your reaction...
