Box Office Wars Game Thread

[Kraftster]

Didn't rel say all along he shot THG that night? I've been reading back through a lot, trying to make some notes. Will probably post later tonight. I'm more inclined to go with Juice today because he seems to be more of a sure thing. I've been slow to suspect relantel, so I'm hoping a re-read with everything we now know in mind will help me to see things differently (or the same, which would be equally helpful).

[shafnutz05]

I did not lie at all about the role claim. I thought it was a good time to come out. The fact relantel is going after both myself and Klinger is telling. To me, anyway.

[relantel]

Didn't rel say all along he shot THG that night? I've been reading back through a lot, trying to make some notes. Will probably post later tonight. I'm more inclined to go with Juice today because he seems to be more of a sure thing. I've been slow to suspect relantel, so I'm hoping a re-read with everything we now know in mind will help me to see things differently (or the same, which would be equally helpful).

I did. I did not take credit for NAN because I did not submit a kill on NAN.

[Juice]

i'm saying we go for the vig who hasn't shot anyone red yet and will undoubtedly shoot a blue tonight
gaucho looks at bluice (blue juice LOL)
i'll come in at the end of the game and lead us to victory!

[relantel]

I did not lie at all about the role claim. I thought it was a good time to come out. The fact relantel is going after both myself and Klinger is telling. To me, anyway.

If you did not lie, then the last two then have to be either Juice or Hammer.

[Kraftster]

klinger, I haven't played an impotent vig card, it's been an observation of others.

I am the vig. No more no less.

If I am blocked, the red need not fear the return bullet.

I think the switches to me are far more telling given I am the lone confirmed green.

How are you confirmed green? Did you kill Nan?

I did shoot that night. Not directly at NAN but it did miss the intended target. Don't have an explanation for that - but absent someone else stepping up to that kill, it has to reason that it was an indirect result to my bullet.

Whoa, missed this. Interesting.

[TheHammer24]

I did not lie at all about the role claim. I thought it was a good time to come out. The fact relantel is going after both myself and Klinger is telling. To me, anyway.

If you did not lie, then the last two then have to be either Juice or Hammer.

I agree with this logic, and that is why I find it so odd that you and Klinger came out of nowhere on a rel crusade?

[TheHammer24]

Rel - who have you submitted shots on?

You admitted everyone you missed (Redwill, THG, ?). You now admit to shooting and missing Nan and Columbia?

[relantel]

Rel - who have you submitted shots on?

You admitted everyone you missed (Redwill, THG, ?). You now admit to shooting and missing Nan and Columbia?

No - i have shot redwill on night 1, thg on night 4, and slappy on night 5.

[TheHammer24]

Rel - who have you submitted shots on?

You admitted everyone you missed (Redwill, THG, ?). You now admit to shooting and missing Nan and Columbia?

No - i have shot redwill on night 1, thg on night 4, and slappy on night 5.

See. Now you appear to be contradicting yourself. Those were three misses. But earlier you threatened a return bullet. If your only shots were misses, what is a "return bullet." You also said that you have shot on some nights and nothing in the write up happened other than a kill of someone else. Thus, you think you pulled off this kill. I' confused as to what you are claiming. If you're green, why aren't you being fully candid?

I still think Juice is a no brainer in this round.

[relantel]

to my knowledge we have not figured out how NAN and canaan died. No one has stepped up to claim those. Canaan was on a night I did not shoot so the missed shot hitting a different target doesn't pan out. So it is not very likely that the NAN death was connected to the missed shot.

[relantel]

hammer, it's been pretty clear since you claimed to shoot thg after night 4. I called you on it, because I knew I shot thg.

[relantel]

Rel - who have you submitted shots on?

You admitted everyone you missed (Redwill, THG, ?). You now admit to shooting and missing Nan and Columbia?

No - i have shot redwill on night 1, thg on night 4, and slappy on night 5.

See. Now you appear to be contradicting yourself. Those were three misses. But earlier you threatened a return bullet. If your only shots were misses, what is a "return bullet." You also said that you have shot on some nights and nothing in the write up happened other than a kill of someone else. Thus, you think you pulled off this kill. I' confused as to what you are claiming. If you're green, why aren't you being fully candid?

I still think Juice is a no brainer in this round.

as far as I can tell, all shots are live. So the reds still need to be wary of the return-fire shot. a role block blocks the return shot. ergo, reds shoot me. No role block, reds can't take that chance, and they narrow our suspsects by going for someone else.

[TheHammer24]

hammer, it's been pretty clear since you claimed to shoot thg after night 4. I called you on it, because I knew I shot thg.

I don't think I claimed to have shot him. I was pretty clear on how I thought the role was going down. I thought the shot was symbolic of me finding him, and, in fact, I was quite irritated with the write up making it so obvious I was the other highlander. After you noted that you shot him, I realized the reds had shot at me. I never claimed to shoot THG -- I had one shot after that battle. But I thought my seeing him was responsible for the missed shot.

[shafnutz05]

Oscar relantel


Razzy juice

Fair enough. I still am extremely suspicious of relantel but I'm fine going with Juice today.

[Crpl_Klinger]

Oscar relantel

Razzy juice
Fair enough. I still am extremely suspicious of relantel but I'm fine going with Juice today.

[TheHammer24]

Alright, that's 5.

Juice (5) - Relantel, Hammer, Juice, Krafster, Shaf

Hopefully Pavel is here so we can get a quick turn around.

[relantel]

hammer, it's been pretty clear since you claimed to shoot thg after night 4. I called you on it, because I knew I shot thg.

I don't think I claimed to have shot him. I was pretty clear on how I thought the role was going down. I thought the shot was symbolic of me finding him, and, in fact, I was quite irritated with the write up making it so obvious I was the other highlander. After you noted that you shot him, I realized the reds had shot at me. I never claimed to shoot THG -- I had one shot after that battle. But I thought my seeing him was responsible for the missed shot.

you did claim to have tried to kill him, in the message where you roleclaimed.

[relantel]

Alright, that's 5.

Juice (5) - Relantel, Hammer, Juice, Krafster, Shaf

Hopefully Pavel is here so we can get a quick turn around.

don't think so - you have juice in there. don't think he self voted did he?

[relantel]

hammer, juice and klinger have votes in on me. so we do not have 5 yet.

[TheHammer24]

hammer, juice and klinger have votes in on me. so we do not have 5 yet.

My vote is and has been on Juice

[TheHammer24]

http://www.letsgopens.com/scripts/phpBB ... 5#p2058125" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

[relantel]

hammer, juice and klinger have votes in on me. so we do not have 5 yet.

My vote is and has been on Juice

was directed at you - perhaps should have used semicolon to indicate that juice and klinger have votes on me.

[Crpl_Klinger]

Juice (5) – Gaucho, Hammer, Kraftster, relantel, shaf
Relantel (2) – Juice, Klinger

I was going to switch to make it 5, but realized that you guys missed Gaucho's earlier vote.

[TheHammer24]

hammer, juice and klinger have votes in on me. so we do not have 5 yet.

My vote is and has been on Juice

was directed at you - perhaps should have used semicolon to indicate that juice and klinger have votes on me.

Lol. No that was grammatically correct. I fell victim to persons' misuse of the serial comma.