newarenanow wrote:Well, it was just dumb luck on my end to pick MWB out of a list of 5 or 6 quiet players. Honestly, people will keep questioning me, and not focus on the true reds, so go ahead and finish me.
I still think someone like c2i or thg, someone that is being really quiet is a good target.
This is one reason why I wanted the angel to come out earlier. Because of my blind vote, we'll just kill another villager because we didn't have info the wolves had. The focus is scattered. And now it's most likely going to be another wasted day because we didn't have a key piece of info.
lynch c2i
I guess surprised that you randomly picked me out of the quiet players. If the goal was to go for quiet, why not go for fewer posts or people with just votes?
I think you had like 2 or 3 posts at most. You are usually much more involved. I found that suspicious. You didn't have many more posts than the others.
Once I'm dead, I would consider c2i just based on his last post. Most people know that I dont' care about the self preservation route.
I also thinkk one of Juice or Pavel is bad, but I'm not as confident of that.
redwill wrote:I'm liking the nan vote more now with his defensiveness.
I'm not being defensive. I played a horrible game and got myself into trouble.
I just think when you are playing a game when the bad guys have the advantage, they are known, and the village does not know anything, when a piece of information is now known by the bad guys, it serves no purpose to keep it hidden from the rest of the village, who are already in the dark.
I randomly pick someone, it happens to be the angel, so one more villager is killed. If that info was known, I may still have been voted out, but we wouldn't have to base it on this crap.
Going to give nan the benefit of the doubt here. I don't see the reds trying to out the angel. I also suspect since they know who the angel is, they would stay away from voting for the angel until late, not early. Columbia to agree with MWB's vote as well. Possible red tell.
Granted, we are trusting MWB in his angel claim.....But I think it's best to go along with a known green.
The village is being pretty heavily played in this game*, so I'll side with any known ally.
* Juice and/or Pavel certainly raise some suspicions, with their let's duel at dawn routine.
Juice and Pavel are either two villagers with totally different views, or two bad guys that said from the beginning that they should just go all out against each other, take the chance that the village will let them slide since they are participating, and if for some reason one gets killed, the other will probably get let go since they are arguing opposite positions.
columbia wrote:Granted, we are trusting MWB in his angel claim.....But I think it's best to go along with a known green.
The village is being pretty heavily played in this game*, so I'll side with any known ally.
* Juice and/or Pavel certainly raise some suspicions, with their let's duel at dawn routine.
This makes me even more suspicious of Columbia. I think either he or nan are god votes.
Obviously my angel claim will be trusted. Reds would just be giving up one of their players to make that claim.
Unless the real angel is one of the people that has never posted in the thread and has no idea the game is going on. But agreed, your claim has a high belief level.
But, they would have protected themselves on Night 1. So they at least were playing at the start. MWB is the angel. I don't know what "other" possibility you are referring to.
slappybrown wrote:But, they would have protected themselves on Night 1. So they at least were playing at the start. MWB is the angel. I don't know what "other" possibility you are referring to.
The one that you stated....Anyway, I'm cool with the idea of MWB being the angel and - as I mentioned - is part of the reason I am comfortable with the vote on NAN.
Juice/Pavel - I think they are either both bad or both villagers. I can't get a good read though
thg - he has been quiet, hasn't posted much, could be sitting back, threw out a vote on me, knowing it would take off. I don't think the baddies have killed me at night yet because they could easily get me out during the day
c2i - same as thg
slappy - he is just playing weird and isn't really helping out much
relantel - strangely quiet
I dont' know. I don't have a good read on anyone yet. Usually ifyou get the first bad guy, things start falling into place. Obviously hasnt' happened yet.
Slappy is pinging because obviously the Angel is so obviously paying attention or they would have been dead. He caught himself in the mistake which is why he posted a couple posts later, paraphrasing, "Oh yeah he has to be paying attention cause he protected himself." I'm also buying MWB as the Angel because most everyone that plays understands the game pretty well and if MWB was red and claiming Angel I believe the real Angel would show themselves immediately cause that's an excellent trade for the village.
I'm also staying on NAN cause he looks bad all around, leading 2 town trains, now doesn't think the Angel should have come out because, "The reward was minimal." No it's not, I explained why the reward gives a big increase for the vig to hit a red, and lastly above he made a post where he's suspicious of half the people left in the game.
