Monsters I: GAME THREAD

[columbia]

lol


a seer showdown.

[thehockeyguru]

After IE turning it down I saw her Night 1. Night 2 I saw Benny because I knew either he or Ulf was Red. Benny was blue. Night 3 I saw Ulf. He is Red.

[Kraftster]

Well, if I'm stuck believing one of you, its thg. Good play yesterday, ulf.

salve columbia
jagger ulf in the face

[columbia]

i hate switching my votes back and forth like this, but....


lynch ulf

[thehockeyguru]

Had you guys listened to me after I gave you IE on a platter Canaan would still be here to protect me. I knew they weren't going to wack me after I came out for Ulf yesterday, just had to make sure he was Red.

[thehockeyguru]

I am pretty sure I'm going to die tonight, but if I can see someone its going to be Kraftster.

[Kraftster]

Sorry, thg. I read your messages as the best I'm-the-seer-without-saying-I'm-the-seer messages in a while, I just didn't give ulf enough credit to make the play he did yesterday.

[Kraftster]

Don't waste your see.

[ulf]

U mad thg

[thehockeyguru]

U mad thg

No. After the village was so dense yesterday I knew I would have to come out today. I expected that you would role claim, so in the end I got the outcome I expected.

[Kraftster]

I am pretty sure I'm going to die tonight, but if I can see someone its going to be Kraftster.

But, seriously, I do hope you cool off and think it through and don't waste it. I voted with you on ulf yesterday. I gave you my reason for cooling on him today and really I just felt we could get more out of today than a bandwagon ulf vote given the fact that a green was voted off on three votes. I'm assuming one of those three voters was red - how can you not?

Please see redwill.

[thehockeyguru]

I am completely befuddled. I give you IE on a platter day 1 and no one would follow me on Day 2.

[columbia]

I am completely befuddled. I give you IE on a platter day 1 and no one would follow me on Day 2.

I was offline that whole Day phase, so I'll plead guilty to not picking up on that part.

[Kraftster]

I am completely befuddled. I give you IE on a platter day 1 and no one would follow me on Day 2.

If it was someone other than you posting like you were, I would have read that you were the seer for sure. You always post with the same matter-of-factness and conviction, though, so it made it easier to question whether that was the right read.

[Troy Loney]

So,

Do we think there is any correlation between IE declining the nomination and being red?

[redwill]

Please see redwill.

Yes. Please do.

[columbia]

So,

Do we think there is any correlation between IE declining the nomination and being red?

If we assume that the sheriff is independent, then I would say yes.
Redwill could certainly comment on that....

[thehockeyguru]

So,

Do we think there is any correlation between IE declining the nomination and being red?

Yes. But at the same time I wouldn't go as far as clearing you because you accepted.

[redwill]

Do we think there is any correlation between IE declining the nomination and being red?

Hard to say. bhaw was not red. I am not red. Are you?

[Troy Loney]

So,

Do we think there is any correlation between IE declining the nomination and being red?

If we assume that the sheriff is independent, then I would say yes.
Redwill could certainly comment on that....

I'm just wondering if its a coincidence or not. I accepted the nod because i didn't know anything really about what it entails...so IE declining makes me think that people with roles would decline the nod, and blues would just accept.

[Troy Loney]

Do we think there is any correlation between IE declining the nomination and being red?

Hard to say. bhaw was not red. I am not red. Are you?

I'm blue....take it for a grain of salt, but ulf decided to throw my name out there as his blue see.

[thehockeyguru]

What is the count?

[thehockeyguru]

I believe we reached the limit.

ULF - (6) THG, Redwill, Relantel, TL, Columbia, Kraftster.

[Senka]

thx for update

[thehockeyguru]

I am completely befuddled. I give you IE on a platter day 1 and no one would follow me on Day 2.

If it was someone other than you posting like you were, I would have read that you were the seer for sure. You always post with the same matter-of-factness and conviction, though, so it made it easier to question whether that was the right read.

That's the way your supposed to play the game, in a manner that doesn't change.