Monsters I: GAME THREAD

[thehockeyguru]

There are a lot of 1 votes out there.

[redwill]

There are a lot of 1 votes out there.

Yeah, that's interesting for the first day of voting. Usually we can count on the baddies jumping on votes and moving it quickly. In fact, I depend upon that happening when I play this game.

[redwill]

Please. My other option for my screen name was Tersester.

Haha. I couldn't think of the word "terse," and wanted to get my post up.

[ExPatriatePen]

Code: Select all

IrishEyes  4    (THG, ExPat columbia, Kraftster)
Canaan     1    (mac)
THG        1    (IE)
expat      2    (canaan, ulf)
Mac        1    (BFitz)
Kraftster  1    (redwill)

Takes 7 to lynch...

Takes 7 to lynch...

Was a deadline ever given?

[redwill]

Meh. I don't have a strong opinion on this.

unlynch Kraftster
lynch IE

[Senka]

Deadline tonite. We started 8am. It's a small game.

[ulf]

it seems like a pretty simple "lets frame IE by killing someone she voted for" tactic. i dont know if IE is bad or not, but the reasoning seems to be pretty L1. If IE ends up bad, yokes on my face, but to simply assume IE, being a red player, would be so out to get bhaw that she would make it known that she wanted to kill him and then follow through with it? whats the rationale behind that?

I just threw it out there. The fact that she was uber defensive makes me think there may be more to it.

Can you explain benefit that the Red's could get from "framing" IE this early in the game.

because it would be easy to pile on a player that is relatively new to the game, self-professed not a good player yet, and day 1's are easy to roll tide--an easy early play. these are just assumptions, mind you. i understand the uber-defensive mentality that you are saying and maybe im just basing my defense off of my assumptions of her naivete, but its just nothing more than a hunch on my part and maybe the same on yours and EPP's part.

The point I want to make is usually thats a tactic thats used later in games with talented players, not on Day 1 for self-professed average players. Being that it is Day 1 I'd rather vote on her with there being no other real options.

To be honest I'm more concerned that she turned down the nomination more than her being framed. I still think the reason she could have turned it down is not avoid being a target for conversation.

I dont get the decline nomination = possible baddie. Redwill accepted the nomination, is now the sheriff, and coincidentally is also at the bottom of everyone's suspicion list. Wouldnt IE want to be elected if she was red???

these were my thoughts regarding a baddie and sheriff. if anything, redwill openly (accidentally) voting for himself looks a little suspicious to me. but alas we have no clue if the other two voted for themselves either.

[Benny Fitz]

blue Mac because of his killer defense to my accusation
yellow IE for the sake of the game (ala the nan rule)

[Senka]

That's 6ie from phone. 1 and 2 else. Deadline is 8pm

[Senka]

Code: Select all

IrishEyes  6    (THG, ExPat, columbia, Kraftster, Redwill, Benny)
Canaan     1    (mac)
THG        1    (IE)
expat      2    (canaan, ulf)

Takes 7 to lynch...

[ExPatriatePen]

blue Mac because of his killer defense to my accusation
yellow IE for the sake of the game (ala the nan rule)

Speaking of NAN, he's been strangely quiet.

Hmmmm

[ulf]

i also enjoyed mac coming in voting, and not responding to benny at all lol

[ExPatriatePen]

Rel's been MIA too... Just things to keep in mind as we go forward.

[ulf]

i'll just switch and end it.

Spoiler:

ib4 omgz ulf was the last vote

blue epp
kill IE

[redwill]

[these were my thoughts regarding a baddie and sheriff. if anything, redwill openly (accidentally) voting for himself looks a little suspicious to me. but alas we have no clue if the other two voted for themselves either.

Haha. Do you think any of us who accepted nominations didn't vote for our self?

[Senka]

shush. wuc

[ulf]

yeah i realize you all probably did. i would have too haha.

[ExPatriatePen]

[these were my thoughts regarding a baddie and sheriff. if anything, redwill openly (accidentally) voting for himself looks a little suspicious to me. but alas we have no clue if the other two voted for themselves either.

Haha. Do you think any of us who accepted nominations didn't vote for our self?

I know I would have voted for myself. Seems to me that it's just logical that the games a lot more fun when you have a special role.

[Senka]

IrishEyes was so busy retelling funny things that comedians love to say, then explaining to people that didn’t understand it, that she let the riot against her go by the wayside. It’s been a long day of argueing and not much has been accomplished. One thing we know for sure is someone will pay for the loss of bhaw. The poor guy had an early exit from life due to… something? Everyone says there are monsters, but are there really any at all? What is a monster? Is it a green ogre looking thing? Are they Imps? The person that could answer this can have a cookie. I always imagined the boogie monster as a large grey colored towering thing that kind of looked like a man in a hazmat suit… Anyways.
…7 people at the town meeting agreed and we all know around here, majority rules. No one knows what the others can do or what they are capable. Some can lie and others can steal. In IrishEyes case, she begged (for forgiveness) from the others. Much like Jury Duty, some members just went with it for the sake of getting through it. In other news, NAN has a rule named after him.
BREAKING NEWS! THIS JUST IN! ….

Spoiler:

…false alarm.

At the end of the day, which is close to 5pm, IrishEyes falls victim to the first day fiasco. Can we find some information on this murder? Or were some crazy grandchildren of that old guy running around murdering people willy-nilly? Am I off topic much? I feel like I am.
They asked IrishEyes for her final words… As she looked, front and center stood with the rope THG, ExPat, Columbia, Kraftster, redwill, Benny Fitz & Ulf. They asked her for her final words, in which she exclaimed, sobbing, “I… wish you… would just believe me! … I’m… just… a … regular… ...”

Spoiler:

…suspenseful? I was trying to see if it would be…

Spoiler:

Goblin. Yeah that’s right. These things are Goblin-like. Why? The real question is “Why Not?”

Jaggerbush Run’s Population stands at 12.

Spoiler:

-Benny Fitz
-Columbia
-NAN
-THG
-Troy Loney
-Mac5155
-redwill
-canaan
-relantel
-Ulf
-ExPatriatePen
-Kraftster

Those that at no longer...

Spoiler:

Senka; whereabouts unknown.
bhaw, a regular townsperson that loves drinking Bartles and Jaymes was found behind the Post Office at 7 something AM.
IrishEyes killed by townspeople with the munchies

THOSE THAT SEND PMs, YOU CAN DO SO..

[columbia]

Nice.

[canaan]

Looks like some apologies will be in my future lol

[newarenanow]

What are the weekend rules? I'm not going to be around.

I will be eating corn in Iowa.

[Senka]

the rules during the day are slow. This game is going to take 2 weeks Not worried about it. so be it.

[ExPatriatePen]

ZZZZzzzzzzzzzzzz

Btw, NAN, enjoy your time in Iowa City, Melrose Street can be a real zoo. Head on over to the Magic Bus if you get a chance, those folks are absolutely nutz.

[ulf]

this stinks.