The Battle of Gettysburg **Game Thread**

[MWB]

Based on columbias posts, LITT was the other shooter. No red vig.

[MWB]

Why would bhaw have to be submitting anything if he's red? The leader, or some other red can do the submission. And why are you thinking there's just one red?

The red angel and seer are dead. There may never have been a red vig as the red leader could have had that power. So there is probably just one red left. I have eliminated PS87 and rylan based on my previous post, and bhaw. So that leaves you and me. I am blue and you said you are the vig. Red Vig or Green vig though that wasn't pointed out. But I trust you to be green. So due to a process of elimination, Zaro is red.

You've pretty much convinced me you're bad.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

How's that? Because you believe Zaro not be red?

[MWB]

How's that? Because you believe Zaro not be red?

Um, no. You just seem to push a lot of things. Hard to get a good read on you. But you still haven't answered why you're saying the red angel is dead.

[MWB]

Ok, let's hope there's a write up soon.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Whoops. I thought Kraftster was the red angel. So yeah there could be two reds left.

[pittsports87]

Sorry about my lack of participation, I've been really busy with school starting back last week and working. This is the first time I touched a computer all day, I should be good for tomorrow though to participate somewhat.

[bhaw]

We haven't had a ban on night discussion recently, so I don't see why we couldn't discuss it.

well, in the end, it's still up to MWB. I'm blue, but I have no way to prove that. Zaro is going to claim blue with no way to prove it.

I could show 10 reasons he is red, he could show 10 reasons I'm red. MWB seems to think I'm red though, so

There are four good players, and I'm assuming two red. Why do you keep saying it's up to me?

You can shoot. Maybe that's a bad assumption?

There's no such thing as a red vig. The alpha usually carries out the kills.

Bad angle or bad seer are optional roles. We don't know what's still out there. (to SDD, not MWB)

I don't know how many reds to assume (1 or 2).

[MWB]

There is/was a red angel. Who else protected kraftster. There was no red vig... Quite sure that was LITT. Based on the list of deads it doesn't seem the red angel is dead. So there are likely two red, unless the leader was able to protect. Possible.

[thehockeyguru]

Write Up Coming

[thehockeyguru]

General Lee once again was quick and accurate with his rifle. On this night he was able to take out:

Spoiler:

Pittsports87 a regular villager

Players Remaining:


1. Zarovich
2. Rylan
3. bhaw
4. MWB
5. Sam's Drunk Dog

Spoiler:

Night 1 - No Kills.
Day 1 - ExPatriatePen - Maj. Gen. J.E.B. Stuart was killed at the Battle of Brandy Station
Night 2 - Relantel a regular villager and Benny Fitz a regular villager both were found dead in the streets of Gettysburg.
Day 2 - mac5155 - Maj. Gen. John Buford was killed at the Railroad cut
Night 3 - NAN - a regular villager was found shot to death on the streets of Gettysburg.
Day 3 – Redwill - a regular villager was surcame to his wounds in his new-fangled observation balloon and was feasted on by a school of rabid jellyfish.
Night 4 - Canaan a regular villager was found dead in the streets of Gettysburg.
Day 4 – Columbia a Gettysburg Town Masons was killed as the Union retreated to Cemetery Hill.
Night 5 - TWC a regular villager was found dead in the streets of Gettysburg.
Day 5 – Kraftster the Confederate Recruit
Night 6- Slappybrown - Maj. Gen. Winfield S. Hancock the Union Angel. was killed by a the Confederates.
Day 6 - Irish Eyes a regular villager was found dead in the streets of Gettysburg.
Night 7 - Troy Loney a regular villager was found dead in the streets of Gettysburg.
Day 7 - LITT was a Gettysburgh Mason turned Confederate JOAT was killed on the Battlefield avenging the death of his Mason Brother.
Night 8 - Pittsports87 a regular villager was found dead in the streets of Gettysburg.

It is now Day 8

It takes 3 to Fire Upon

Deadline is 8AM

[bhaw]

MWB... if you are the vig, why no shots?

[bhaw]

How things appear:
MWB - vig
Rylan - nonparticipating could be anything
SDD - blue
Zaro/bhaw - red

My concerns:
MWB - claimed vig but no shots, no explanation. Is Rylan the vig and this was just a good play to claim green with the real vig MIA
Rylan - see above
SDD - along with MWB's idea, SDD potential red alpha that came back blue
bhaw - I'm really blue but no one believes me or I'm being set up by red to be voted
zaro - if MWB and/or SDD are red, zaro is blue

I don't think that's a combination, but based on what's been going on, all very possible.

[bhaw]

MWB, 2 questions for you:

1. Why aren't/can't you shoot(ing)?
2. You said that it should be obvious last round that you are the vig. Where are the hints?

I'm hoping how things appear is right because it makes it easy for me (vote zaro).

[Zarovich]

Fire upon bhaw

Not sure what to make of SDD's posts during the night phase. Still sure bhaw is bad though.

[MWB]

If I shot and was wrong it would be huge detriment. Now we have a solid chance still. Subtle things I've posted were meant as hints. Won't be on much this am, but I'm still leaning bhaw.

[mac5155]

LONGEST GAME EVER

[thehockeyguru]

LONGEST GAME EVER

[ExPatriatePen]

LONGEST GAME EVER

Much longer than the actual battle.

Even muskets didn't take this long to reload.

[bhaw]

My reasoning is still the same for zaro. He is gunning for me real hard and turning almost all of my posts as how they can be red. Go read the last 2 day phases and decide for yourself.

fire upon zaro

Zaro accused me of never voting for LITT, yet I don't see him voting for him ever. I think he has shown signs of being a reactive red. Throwing a lot of accusations my way, most of which apply to him as well.

If you want my defense, I could have let time run out on zaro yesterday when he had the most votes. I made the first switch, which was 100% not necessary if I was red. The limit would have hit, and I wouldn't have needed to knock out LITT.

[bhaw]

MWB... why didn't you just kill me AND zaro if those are your two choices?

[thehockeyguru]

(1) - Bhaw - (Zaro)
(1) - Zaro - (Bhaw)

It takes 3 to Fire Upon

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Fire upon Zarovich

Based on my earlier posts, I believe bhaw, which leaves Rylan and Zaro as the possible reds. Rylan hasn't been participating which leaves me to believe that only one red remains.

[thehockeyguru]

(2) - Zaro - (Bhaw, SDD)
(1) - Bhaw - (Zaro)

It takes 3 to Fire Upon

[Zarovich]

My reasoning is still the same for zaro. He is gunning for me real hard and turning almost all of my posts as how they can be red. Go read the last 2 day phases and decide for yourself.

fire upon zaro

Zaro accused me of never voting for LITT, yet I don't see him voting for him ever. I think he has shown signs of being a reactive red. Throwing a lot of accusations my way, most of which apply to him as well.

If you want my defense, I could have let time run out on zaro yesterday when he had the most votes. I made the first switch, which was 100% not necessary if I was red. The limit would have hit, and I wouldn't have needed to knock out LITT.

You voted for rylan, then switched to IE after I voted for her. LITT and IE both had 2 votes at the time and you avoided him.

Next phase you voted MWB, then switched to me, then to LITT. You are now asking MWB to shoot you. Looks to me like you are the Angel or can have nighttime protection.

Check this SDD, unless you are the red leader who came back blue.