No Doc's Allowed Warz

[pittsports87]

Another day, another dead blue. nan, dissapointed with the findings, took himself and his empty gun to the bar. What he didn't know is that this bar was owned by Doc and his minions. He ordered a beer, and Doc's lead minion roofied his drink. He woke up on the mothership and was then dissected. All that was left of nan was his hammer he always carried around hidden, and the other figured out that he was

Spoiler:

three stars, head banner

The participants:

Spoiler:

1. columbia
2. Rylan
3. newarenanow- three stars, head banner was roofied and dissected on night 3.
4. relantel
5. mac5155
6. shafnutz05-A regular poster was banned by the group on day 2.
7. MWB
8. redwill-Admin, The know it all disected on night 1
9. Benny Fitz
10. Krafster
11. Hammertime
12. canaan A regular poster was force overdosed on adderal on night 2
13. bhaw A regular poster was banned by the group on day 1.
14. sdm5055 Rylan, Doc's 2nd minion was given the banhammer by *** on night 2.

Day 3.
With 8 left, it takes 5 to ban. Do work.

[columbia]

[relantel]

ban benny. color please.

[DocEmrick]

[pittsports87]

Benny- 1 (Relantel)

[Benny Fitz]

ban benny. color please.

allow me.

[Kraftster]

There were really three vote options from yesterday:

shaf - going back to the prior day and acting weird and missing the whole canaan kill, etc.
Benny theory: one of the four voters on sdm in slots 1-4 must have been bad. That left as the options nan, bhaw, columbia, hammertime. Benny liked columbia best.
NAN theory: one of the jumpers on the bhaw vote in slots 3-5 must have been bad. That meant Rylan, Benny, or columbia. nan liked Benny from that group.

shaf just wasn't behaving as himself, so that's why he got my vote. As between the other two theories, I found nan's reasoning to be better than Benny's, i.e., I thought it more likely that one of was bad as opposed to one of the four voters on sdm. NAN being killed nudges me further into thinking that he was on to something with saying that it must have been one of Rylan, Benny, or columbia.

My feeling is one of those three should be the vote today.

[columbia]

As I mentioned before, Benny is playing this game pretty much the way he always does....Good at leading the discussion.
I think either he or Rylan is a wolf, but I'll go for this now....

ban BennyFitz

Btw, who was leading the suspicion on Kraftster earlier in the game? That pretty much disappeared.

[Kraftster]

That was shaf with the first vote of the game. I think there was a second voter at some point.

Rylan hasn't really done enough for me to get a read on him. I'm torn as between Benny and columbia at the moment.

[columbia]

That was shaf with the first vote of the game. I think there was a second voter at some point.

Rylan hasn't really done enough for me to get a read on him. I'm torn as between Benny and columbia at the moment.

Right...that was shad saying the Redwill kill "screamed of Kraftster" or something like that.

[Kraftster]

That was shaf with the first vote of the game. I think there was a second voter at some point.

Rylan hasn't really done enough for me to get a read on him. I'm torn as between Benny and columbia at the moment.

Right...that was shad saying the Redwill kill "screamed of Kraftster" or something like that.

Yep, and now I remember voter 2 was relantel, who said it screamed of me or canaan, nan, shaf, or bhaw, or anyone else in the game, lol.

[Benny Fitz]

There were really three vote options from yesterday:

shaf - going back to the prior day and acting weird and missing the whole canaan kill, etc.
Benny theory: one of the four voters on sdm in slots 1-4 must have been bad. That left as the options nan, bhaw, columbia, hammertime. Benny liked columbia best.
NAN theory: one of the jumpers on the bhaw vote in slots 3-5 must have been bad. That meant Rylan, Benny, or columbia. nan liked Benny from that group.

shaf just wasn't behaving as himself, so that's why he got my vote. As between the other two theories, I found nan's reasoning to be better than Benny's, i.e., I thought it more likely that one of was bad as opposed to one of the four voters on sdm. NAN being killed nudges me further into thinking that he was on to something with saying that it must have been one of Rylan, Benny, or columbia.

My feeling is one of those three should be the vote today.

Columbia is on both of those lists!

[Kraftster]

I'm going to go ahead and ban Benny for right now. As I think about it, its unlike Benny to not address nan's logic and try to point out why it was/is flawed or present an argument as to why his logic is better. Could have been trying to avoid looking like he was trying too hard to steer. He's really steered on two straight kills to some extent and we've only gotten two blues. I like nan's thinking that the person who tipped things in favor of bhaw on day 1 (and away from sdm) should get a look and as you read through, that appears to have been Benny.

[pittsports87]

Benny- 3 (Relantel, columbia, kraftster)

5 to lynch

[Benny Fitz]

sigh, you leave me no choice....

I'm the angel.

[columbia]

The living:

1. columbia
2. Rylan
4. relantel
5. mac5155
7. MWB
9. Benny Fitz
10. Krafster
11. Hammertime

This has been such a disjointed game, that it's hard to keep track of who has been silent....mac is definitely among them.

[columbia]

Ahah.....a role claim.

[Benny Fitz]

Ahah.....a role claim.

any counter claims?

Can we get rid of columbia now?

ban columbia

[Kraftster]

mac has to be at the top of the quiets -- has he posted even once?
Rylan could be perceived as strategically quiet.
rel has not been playing like himself at all.

[Kraftster]

lift the ban on Benny for now.

[columbia]

Ahah.....a role claim.

any counter claims?

Can we get rid of columbia now?

ban columbia

I'm sticking with my benny vote after reading that.
Yinz can kill me if you wish, but it won't get you anywhere.....unless you are red.

[pittsports87]

Benny- 2 (Relantel, columbia)
Columbia-1 (benny)

5 to lynch

[Benny Fitz]

The living:

1. columbia
2. Rylan
4. relantel
5. mac5155
7. MWB
9. Benny Fitz
10. Krafster
11. Hammertime

This has been such a disjointed game, that it's hard to keep track of who has been silent....mac is definitely among them.

he should be mod killed. imo. we're in the throws of what makes this game special. simply coasting as a non-talkers (good or bad) is bs.

[columbia]

I don't know what's going on with mac....he claimed that he didn't know that the game had started.
then pretty much vanished.

[Benny Fitz]

as presumable the last living green why would anyone keep their vote on me?

c'mon people. i've got slappybrown conviction on this one.