Malkamaniac wrote:I don't think that's the case at all. Two known "good" people can do far more damage to the Bads. They didn't kill them because I believe that THG and Krafster aren't good.
I agree with you. I said I have to think they're bad.
My comment about "inventive baddies" was sort of a personal joke. slappybrown was quite inventive in Sherwood Wars. And I've seen others try weird things.
Malkamaniac wrote:I don't think that's the case at all. Two known "good" people can do far more damage to the Bads. They didn't kill them because I believe that THG and Krafster aren't good.
I agree with this. Especially with the angel already dead it makes no sense why they didn't kill one of them. One (or both) of them have to be bad.
I'm obviously trying to figure out how I am still here too.
I guess it makes a little more sense when you look at things from yesterday. I indicated that I could only see on even nights, so the baddies knew that I was no threat to learn anything last night. Zaro was the only person who seemed to have an issue with my role and that was clearly just based on a hunch since Zaro turned out to be blue. My guess is that the baddies figured they could potentially get the mob to do their job for them on Day 5 so that they could use their kills elsewhere. Me not dying alone brings suspicion, then to have Zaro be the one to die I think really points the finger. I can only surmise that that was intentional.
If there is a J.O.A.T. out there, maybe I can have a protect tonight. I get a see tonight, so, who do you guys think we should take a look at on the off chance that I make it through another night?
I am also very skeptical of thg going back to my comment that
Kraftster wrote:
thehockeyguru wrote:i knew he was an RP, but was hoping he wasn't good.
Killing someone you "know" is an RP "hoping" that he is bad seems unnecessarily risky at this stage. Why run that risk? Trying to be a hero or what?
Anyway, I guess it doesn't matter because at least Nexus and possibly one other party it looks like targeted MWB.
i don't think it's odd at all that THG and krafty are still around. krafty (as he just said) can only see on even nights, so he was no threat last night. if thg really is the vig, the baddies are probably sitting back and banking on the fact that in the past and once again in this game, thg is a bad vig.
I think we should ignore everything that THG and Kraftster say. I don't think we should kill them, but if they are honestly a threat then the bad guys will kill them....i know this has been said before and the idea of people being invincible to lynching is only good for the bad guys.....i just think that their roles will be revealed to us in time. i dont think we should spend the whole day arguing with them, surviving the night automatically puts their story into question, so my conclusion is to not debate about them, but certainly don't listen to anything they tell us to do.
Troy Loney wrote:I think we should ignore everything that THG and Kraftster say. I don't think we should kill them, but if they are honestly a threat then the bad guys will kill them....i know this has been said before and the idea of people being invincible to lynching is only good for the bad guys.....i just think that their roles will be revealed to us in time. i dont think we should spend the whole day arguing with them, surviving the night automatically puts their story into question, so my conclusion is to not debate about them, but certainly don't listen to anything they tell us to do.
Troy Loney wrote:I think we should ignore everything that THG and Kraftster say. I don't think we should kill them, but if they are honestly a threat then the bad guys will kill them....i know this has been said before and the idea of people being invincible to lynching is only good for the bad guys.....i just think that their roles will be revealed to us in time. i dont think we should spend the whole day arguing with them, surviving the night automatically puts their story into question, so my conclusion is to not debate about them, but certainly don't listen to anything they tell us to do.
So do you have an alternative suggestion for a vote today?
To be honest, I agree with you, but I wonder if your motivation is that you'd rather not have Kraftster revealed, for fear it would cast serious suspicion on you (since he "cleared" you).
pin nan
His voting has been all over the place with no real explanation. And it seems like right now it is either him, or 2 good/bad guys. I don't think it is a good idea to risk losing the vig or seer right now, so I think this is the logical choice.
Troy Loney wrote:I think we should ignore everything that THG and Kraftster say. I don't think we should kill them, but if they are honestly a threat then the bad guys will kill them....i know this has been said before and the idea of people being invincible to lynching is only good for the bad guys.....i just think that their roles will be revealed to us in time. i dont think we should spend the whole day arguing with them, surviving the night automatically puts their story into question, so my conclusion is to not debate about them, but certainly don't listen to anything they tell us to do.
So do you have an alternative suggestion for a vote today?
To be honest, I agree with you, but I wonder if your motivation is that you'd rather not have Kraftster revealed, for fear it would cast serious suspicion on you (since he "cleared" you).
I am tempted to vote for skullman because of his post last night, as bhaw pointed out, but, I'm going to pin NAN because of the link provided by bhaw. It really is just voting/vote changing without any substance for a few straight days now. And the same yesterday after being called out a bit.
That's because I have no idea who to vote for this game. The day and night phases are a little too long for my short attention span, especially the night phases. SO I haven't been paying that much attention.
I'm blue, but I'm no help to the vilalge this game.
