redwill wrote:dagny's JOAT explanation fits the write-ups too perfectly IMO.
but to reiterate...that should automatically mean that she's bad. i think she just needs to concoct a reasonable explanation for the village and at the same time not reveal her significance for fear of mod kill.
These explanations normally follow one of two templates:
1) The role fits what happened perfectly, no matter how odd the circumstances seems; or
2) The role involves powers that may not be revealed. This is despite the fact that an extraordinary amount of info CAN apparently be revealed.
dagny's claim has both of these. The odds are very good she's making it up.
redwill wrote:These explanations normally follow one of two templates:
1) The role fits what happened perfectly, no matter how odd the circumstances seems; or
2) The role involves powers that may not be revealed. This is despite the fact that an extraordinary amount of info CAN apparently be revealed.
dagny's claim has both of these. The odds are very good she's making it up.
I don't feel like this adds up to well either. Something is just meh.
Zarovich wrote:I bet Dagny was killed and the mods are thinking of a nice way to tell her they don't want her to help mod
All from while we were waiting during night 1.
capture thg
There is no telling if you put your action in before those quotes were said or not. When Zaro wrote what he said I believe the Mods were already deliberating. That means your protection would have been in by then right?
I personally feel that redwill is right. Something doesn't fit. Was Dagny even in question for most of the time? The only thing I gathered is that she was attacked and "protected"
I don't buy it for a heartbeat. Her entire "explanation" sounds so canned and rehashed it's ridiculous. "Can't reveal my power"..." a new and mysterious role"..."I could be a gamebreaker towards the end". No way.
capture THG
Dude wanted to vote for dagny before her explanation. Im willing to believe dagny for now but she is on my radar. HEY! Dagny is on someone elses radar now! HOW DO YOU LIKE THAT! HUH! HUH!!!!
as much as i would welcome offing TYM without any hesitation, i dont see the harm in keeping her around for now. Unless a vig tried to kill her last night (assuming there is one and thats what happened), and was shunted, beninati-style, i dont quite grasp the calling out of dagny, but at the same time i dont think its quite a suspicion on redwill/thg because they usually both play the game by sticking their heads out--even if they are completely wrong (well, except for the time THG was a baddy and kept quiet early in the game).
im gonna re-read when i get caught up with work-related work.
Malkamaniac wrote:I personally feel that redwill is right. Something doesn't fit. Was Dagny even in question for most of the time? The only thing I gathered is that she was attacked and "protected"
^This. I think Dagny used all of her nine lives, and now just wants a preemptive protection in case she gets targeted again. Asking for night protection from the angel, and for us to not vote during the day.
That explanation is just too rushed/desperate/I don't know.
redwill wrote:dagny's claim hangs on an alleged power that she may not reveal but will be a "game breaker."
Hah.
There is no point in dithering here.
Let's go.
I was almost willing to believe her until the "game breaker" part. The only person that would say something as desperate and pleading as that is someone that's red and likely important. Why would a green put an even larger target on their backs by stating that?
thehockeyguru wrote:
There is no telling if you put your action in before those quotes were said or not. When Zaro wrote what he said I believe the Mods were already deliberating. That means your protection would have been in by then right?
You'd have to actually go back and read to find out.
Zaro's first post in those quotes comes from page 2 of this thread.