History Mafia -- GAME THREAD

[count2infinity]

so we've basically got 2 on cupkeeper, 2 on zaro, and 2 on npv...

[count2infinity]

lynch cupkeeper, because at this point i think zaro pushed hard for redwill with little heat on redwill, and npv has voted for a lot of mafia (even though it may be planned out that way to clear his name).

[count2infinity]

also, cup keeper continues to disagree with everything bhaw says despite the fact that bhaw has been dead on everytime...

p.s... if there is a good town RP out there, you need to come forward NOW so we don't waste this vote.

[Troy Loney]

Two of the people i feel strongest about as mafia (c2i & pfidc) are on the cupkeeper vote...so i think that's the wrong direction.

They've essentially gone with the flow the entire game....

[bhaw]

just got back and caught up...

yikes...

[bhaw]

I'm inclined to vote for zaro because he has brought up the most question marks with me. Cup keeper as well. The problem is that I don't KNOW anything. Zaro has played it pretty similar to TWC, who I thought was bad.

c2i - Kind of like the packages last game, I cannot state what my other power is. However, I am allowed to mention that I have it as long as I don't give any other details. It does help us immensely (assuming people trust me on my research).

[bhaw]

crayz is dead for obvious reasons - he was the only person that could be trusted at this point.

I don't know whether I'm more wary of the people who feel I'm totally clean now or the people that realize (as I would) that I could still be lying my ass off

I'm going to categorize for brainstorming purposes...

People who have followed me since I came out:
PFIDC
Corvi
npv

People who still don't trust me despite what I've done:
Zaro
Cup Keeper

People who didn't trust me now suddenly do:
Troy
slappy

People who don't seem to put stock in anything either way:
relantel
c2i

I wasn't totally sure where to put c2i or slappy but someone correct me if these seem off.

[Corvidae]

^ That looks about right.

I think the whole idea of you being bad but coming out to get some villagers lynched and giving up a mobster (now 2) is freakin stupid. I'm willing to be the game on it. If there was another Cop, they would have came out by now. I don't think the people against you are necessary bad, but we certainly don't see eye-to-eye at the moment.

[Corvidae]

*be = bet

[slappybrown]

So I have been out all afternoon. Who am I voting for?

[slappybrown]

So I just read your post bhaw -- I was ok with following you (dont believe I have voted to lynch you ever), then was more suspicious because of the twc thing (though like I said, I personally thought he was bad too), but then with IE, I dont see how we can not trust you.

[npv708]

So I have been out all afternoon. Who am I voting for?

cupkeeper or zaro...everyone is just jealous of the other guy with votes...lol

[bhaw]

At this point, I trust Corvi's judgment (this could easily change later). Zaro makes the most sense. Basically there are a bunch of people who are equally suspicious, but that cop claim thing just puts him over the top. I'd hate to ignore that any further. Sorry if you are blue Zaro, but you made it through like 6 extra rounds after the "fake" cop claim thing. It's the only thing that separates you from a pack of others.

lynch Zaro

[bhaw]

So I just read your post bhaw -- I was ok with following you (dont believe I have voted to lynch you ever), then was more suspicious because of the twc thing (though like I said, I personally thought he was bad too), but then with IE, I dont see how we can not trust you.

So do you feel you belong more in the last section or the one you are in. Basically you are saying that you suddenly do trust me (I'm not passing judgment at this time as to which is the "wrong" category to be in). The difference between you and the top group is that you didn't trust me all along. The difference between you and the 2nd group is that you admit you trust me. So you're either in the 3rd or 4th group.

[PensFanInDC]

crayz is dead for obvious reasons - he was the only person that could be trusted at this point.

I don't know whether I'm more wary of the people who feel I'm totally clean now or the people that realize (as I would) that I could still be lying my ass off

I'm going to categorize for brainstorming purposes...

People who have followed me since I came out:
PFIDC
Corvi
npv

People who still don't trust me despite what I've done:
Zaro
Cup Keeper

People who didn't trust me now suddenly do:
Troy
slappy

People who don't seem to put stock in anything either way:
relantel
c2i

I wasn't totally sure where to put c2i or slappy but someone correct me if these seem off.

Troy Loney,

I've gone with the flow since our Cop outed himself. I believed him and now he's vindicated. Who wouldn't I 'go with the flow' when it follows our seer?

[PensFanInDC]

I think Zaro and cupkeeper are bad and Im sticking with my cupkeeper vote because he seems more sly. I don't like sly bad guys. It's sneaky.

I got my eye on you cupkeeper....

[Zarovich]

a vote for me is a vote for village failure

[PensFanInDC]

a vote for me is a vote for village failure

Great campaign slogan

[Zarovich]

a vote for me is a vote for village failure

Great campaign slogan

Well, if my lynching helps the village figure out who is red, fine by me.

[PensFanInDC]

a vote for me is a vote for village failure

Great campaign slogan

Well, if my lynching helps the village figure out who is red, fine by me.

If you are voted off what does that tell us about who is what?

[Zarovich]

At this point, I trust Corvi's judgment (this could easily change later). Zaro makes the most sense. Basically there are a bunch of people who are equally suspicious, but that cop claim thing just puts him over the top. I'd hate to ignore that any further. Sorry if you are blue Zaro, but you made it through like 6 extra rounds after the "fake" cop claim thing. It's the only thing that separates you from a pack of others.

lynch Zaro

You better be good bhaw.

[bhaw]

At this point, I trust Corvi's judgment (this could easily change later). Zaro makes the most sense. Basically there are a bunch of people who are equally suspicious, but that cop claim thing just puts him over the top. I'd hate to ignore that any further. Sorry if you are blue Zaro, but you made it through like 6 extra rounds after the "fake" cop claim thing. It's the only thing that separates you from a pack of others.

lynch Zaro

You better be good bhaw.

If you can explain to my why you even threw the cop thing out there, I'd be willing to listen. You've never explained it other than to say you were only kidding with the emotes. Why even try when it could lead to the real cop outing himself (if they were not very smart)?

[bhaw]

unlynch zaro

until he essplains.

[Zarovich]

I'm fine with a redwill vote if there's a reason, but are any of the dead people the seer? If not, this could just be someone else thinking they know it all now that they are dead.

No. I don't think any of the dead are the seer. I think canaan was the backup.

I also think it's dagny who is calling for redwill. Could he have been the one who was editing or deleting posts?

unlynch npv

lynch redwill

I still say we go for npv tomorrow if we go with redwill today.

This, before I suggested I may be the cop. There is another.

[Zarovich]

lynch redwill

There was a stink about posts being edited. We then got a message from the dead to lynch redwill. Redwill had 0 votes on him at the time.

Then I made this one.