History Mafia -- GAME THREAD

[PensFanInDC]

have we considered that TWC and bhaw might both be bad and that they are causing chaos on purpose?

[cup keeper]

unlynch twc
lynch redwill

[beerman]

redwill - 7
twc - 3
senka - 2
bhaw - 1
troy - 1

9 for a lynch

[bhaw]

twc isn't being confusing, he's being stupid.

he'd rather kill off the cop when you'll know pretty fast what I am. If redwill is blue, it's obvious. If redwill is red, it doesn't clear me, but my dead at night will. If I'm protected or they kill someone else, I either have to give up another bad guy to gain favor or I throw out good person and you have me nailed again.

twc is trying to get people to gang up on me to take me out so they don't have to. I also think the bad guys may not have converted the 2nd angel, so they know this is the only way to get me out for sure.

[bhaw]

or twc is trying to throw out just enough doubt to prevent the angel from protecting me.

[crayz]

twc isn't being confusing, he's being stupid.

he'd rather kill off the cop when you'll know pretty fast what I am. If redwill is blue, it's obvious. If redwill is red, it doesn't clear me, but my dead at night will. If I'm protected or they kill someone else, I either have to give up another bad guy to gain favor or I throw out good person and you have me nailed again.

twc is trying to get people to gang up on me to take me out so they don't have to. I also think the bad guys may not have converted the 2nd angel, so they know this is the only way to get me out for sure.

if they didn't convert the 2nd angel or you....then they converged the assassin which is

Based on assassin's kills..i don't think they have been converted yet, but could be wrong

[the wicked child]

have we considered that TWC and bhaw might both be bad and that they are causing chaos on purpose?

the only person causing chaos is bhaw. I am merely pointing out his lies.

for some reason people are willing to follow him when his claim made no sense. Whatever though. If people are willing to ignore the blatant lie about being blocked night 3 then I don't know what to say.

[PensFanInDC]

bhaw...can you explain the night 3 block please?

unlynch twc until I hear from you.

[bhaw]

have we considered that TWC and bhaw might both be bad and that they are causing chaos on purpose?

the only person causing chaos is bhaw. I am merely pointing out his lies.

for some reason people are willing to follow him when his claim made no sense. Whatever though. If people are willing to ignore the blatant lie about being blocked night 3 then I don't know what to say.

There was no lie... typically there is a JOAT and a role blocker for the bad guys. 2 roles could have been blocked that night OR what I posted in the thread. It seemed like me and canaan had to switch nights of who could research b/c someone from the dead happened to know redwill was bad. Canaan was the deputy and was dead when redwill's name got thrown out there.

[bhaw]

bhaw...can you explain the night 3 block please?

unlynch twc until I hear from you.

It wasn't explained to me. I actually didn't even get a PM that night after I asked to see jaysmiter. I pm'd mac and asked if it was b/c jaysmiter died that they just didn't pm me his role back. He said no, my powers were disabled yet again. So the term wasn't blocked, it was disabled.

[bhaw]

night 1 the same terminology was used "disabled"

[PensFanInDC]

bhaw...can you explain the night 3 block please?

unlynch twc until I hear from you.

It wasn't explained to me. I actually didn't even get a PM that night after I asked to see jaysmiter. I pm'd mac and asked if it was b/c jaysmiter died that they just didn't pm me his role back. He said no, my powers were disabled yet again. So the term wasn't blocked, it was disabled.

hmmm

[PensFanInDC]

alright...its cool

lynch redwill


my last unlynch said it was for twc...that was an error...my vote was and now is for redwill

[relantel]

It seems to me it would have to be a pretty long story if bhaw is lying. Regardless of redwill, we ought to know for sure if bhaw dies tonight. If bhaw lives tomorrow, then I think that casts some serious doubt on his claim as the cop. TWC might be too, but something tells me one of them is, and one of them isn't. I haven't played another game with bhaw as a player, so I don't know how to take the claims of others that he has gotten away with lying before in past games. Maybe is is niavete, but I'll take bhaw as being truthful for now. I see TWC's point, though, so it is a cautious trust right now.

For now, it's known quantities. There's 16 of us total, and bhaw has pegged one as blue (crayz) and one as red (redwill). That leaves 14 to be unsure about. Invariably, no one trusts anyone else.

bhaw says redwill is regular mafia - if he is certain someone else is also red would it not make sense to go after the red RP? I don't disagree that it makes sense to vote a known red out, but I think his original tact had merit. Voting off a known red really doesn't tell us anything, it just helps the numbers.

lynch redwill.

[relantel]

Blasted color.

Lynch redwill.

[count2infinity]

bhaw...i suggest you stop for fear of mod kill....

[IrishEyes]

bhaw...i suggest you stop for fear of mod kill....

He's not posting a PM. I think he's all right.

[bhaw]

bhaw...i suggest you stop for fear of mod kill....

I just can't quote the post. My understanding has always been that I can explain the PM all I want. I just can't post it with the time stamp and all that other fun stuff.

[Senka]

i was sitting in class ... and something hit me. (but i guess it hit yu too.)

unlynch twc, lynch redwill.if he was role blocked twice hed be dead possibly... a bad seer usually gets every other night,do they not??! check validity.

[Senka]

back at 1. id love to see this pan out...

[crayz]

bhaw -

When you were blocked 1 & 3...who were you investigating? I know 3 you said jaysmiter...who was night 1?

[Troy Loney]

thats 9 i think.

[bhaw]

that's 9 and the village has a bad guy for sure.

who should I research tonight?

[bhaw]

bhaw -

When you were blocked 1 & 3...who were you investigating? I know 3 you said jaysmiter...who was night 1?

kicksave was night 1

[crayz]

bhaw -

When you were blocked 1 & 3...who were you investigating? I know 3 you said jaysmiter...who was night 1?

btw its possible you were blocked by a good rp as well...Someone who saw you defending nan (a bad guy), so they blocked you thinking you were bad.