History Mafia -- GAME THREAD

[Zarovich]

lynch troy loney

cupkeeper has a vote on troy already but I could switch to bhaw. I dunno if the mafioso set this up to look like this, but I'm willing to follow what LITT saw since he was good.

[the wicked child]

Call me crazy here, but if the mob wanted bhaw dead, why wouldn't they just kill him? Why "frame" him by killing LITT?

No offense to LITT, but he wasn't really contributing a lot that I recall before his crusade against bhaw earlier today. Killing him wasn't really helpful to the mob IMO unless they thought he was a RP for some reason... perhaps they thought he was the Cop.

Right away 4 different people pop in with 4 different votes, thus ensuring chaos will ensue yet again.

lynch bhaw

Aside from causing chaos each day, the NAN thing was just too convenient for my liking. The LITT killing stands out to me as not being a frame job - it just doesn't add up to me.

[bhaw]

lynch troy loney

cupkeeper has a vote on troy already but I could switch to bhaw. I dunno if the mafioso set this up to look like this, but I'm willing to follow what LITT saw since he was good.

I don't remember playing with LITT in previous games but does he even have a track record of being right? If this is the case, might as well as look at tfrizz's votes too b/c he was good and must know something else.

I never suspected TL despite fighting with him, but I haven't paid too much attention to him other than when we were arguing for a bit.

[Twisted Wrister]

ill get behind a TL vote, he doesn't have a great defense.

[Twisted Wrister]

record and is just trying to lay low.

Lynch TL

[bhaw]

Call me crazy here, but if the mob wanted bhaw dead, why wouldn't they just kill him? Why "frame" him by killing LITT?

Is this really a legit question? How many times have you played this game?

[Twisted Wrister]

Call me crazy here, but if the mob wanted bhaw dead, why wouldn't they just kill him? Why "frame" him by killing LITT?

Is this really a legit question? How many times have you played this game?

sounds like reverse psychology to me.

[the wicked child]

Call me crazy here, but if the mob wanted bhaw dead, why wouldn't they just kill him? Why "frame" him by killing LITT?

Is this really a legit question? How many times have you played this game?

Enough to know you have a history of lying.

[bhaw]

Call me crazy here, but if the mob wanted bhaw dead, why wouldn't they just kill him? Why "frame" him by killing LITT?

Is this really a legit question? How many times have you played this game?

Enough to know you have a history of lying.

touche...

[Corvidae]

Lynch Zaro for kinda pretending to be the Cop. I don't think it's a "Azkar good, Senka bad" situation, though I'm not saying I trust him. I don't buy the "Troy setting up bhaw" thing either.

[Senka]

I think we need to take down redwill... we started to, and then held off. he hasnt defended himself.

Im also with bhaw on the IE vote... but we throw new names everyday.

[bhaw]

another reason for cup keeper vote... after laying low this whole time, he suddenly jumps out after the write up is over with an epiphany after saying he has no clue and following the bandwagon for the previous rounds.

[Senka]

Redwill, Irisheyes, WickedChild. in that order. ill do all i can. lol

[bhaw]

lynch troy loney

Killing the guy that was gunning for bhaw looks like a set-up play to me.

Why does that have to be TL? That could have been anyone of 15 people setting me up.

He was the one arguing with you. Should I just meekly go back to senka or redwill or would it be better to get some more names out there and get people talking?

What are your thoughts on redwill being called out by the dead before? I'm concerned it was canaan and he actually knew something at this point. But everyone has seemed to let him off the hook.

[npv708]

My top three right now are:

Senka
Redwill
Troy Loney

I'm really alright with a vote for any of those. I'm going to leave my vote till the morning, I'll be up early, but I'll be out till at least 5pm judging a Model UN thing, but I'll have my ipod so I'll try to check in and keep updated...

[cup keeper]

What are your thoughts on redwill being called out by the dead before? I'm concerned it was canaan and he actually knew something at this point. But everyone has seemed to let him off the hook.

I understand that all of the dead people at the time we got the message about redwill were villagers, but dead villagers know nothing more than those of us still playing. The only other time I remember a deputy being in a game was in Holiday Wars when I was mafia cop and the deputy role was a town role until the lead investigator was killed and then he took over that role. So I don't think canaan knew anything as the deputy. At this point I'm willing to vote for redwill hust so we can put the issue to rest.

[bhaw]

Redwill, Irisheyes, WickedChild. in that order. ill do all i can. lol

I buy it on 2 of the 3 for sure (the first 2). Not sure about twc yet... although he called me a liar... and I don't like people that call me a liar.

I think we are at the point where people need to start coming up with more than one vote because ultimately we need 5 mafia.

My top 3 right now are redwill, IE, and cup keeper in no particular order.

redwill mainly b/c I don't want to sit back on what the deputy may have known.

IE because you can't trust a woman (and all the other stuff I said before)

cup keeper is giving off bad vibes and after being pretty under the radar is leading this TL vote right out of the gate. The conclusion that it had to be Troy that set up the bhaw framing with the LITT kill is odd since it could have been anyone.

[bhaw]

unlynch cup keeper

lynch redwill

seems as though several people have them in their top 3.

If he turns out red, I think IE is a pretty done deal as he sneakily said he trusts her.

[bhaw]

What are your thoughts on redwill being called out by the dead before? I'm concerned it was canaan and he actually knew something at this point. But everyone has seemed to let him off the hook.

I understand that all of the dead people at the time we got the message about redwill were villagers, but dead villagers know nothing more than those of us still playing. The only other time I remember a deputy being in a game was in Holiday Wars when I was mafia cop and the deputy role was a town role until the lead investigator was killed and then he took over that role. So I don't think canaan knew anything as the deputy. At this point I'm willing to vote for redwill hust so we can put the issue to rest.

Mods have been changing the game pretty much every time. Why would this game be one where they don't throw in any change ups?

[bhaw]

unlynch cup keeper

lynch redwill

seems as though several people have them in their top 3.

If he turns out red, I think IE is a pretty done deal as he sneakily said he trusts her.

meant to say several people have HIM

Also, the counter to my last sentence would be that if redwill is blue, IE would seem fairly safe.

[cup keeper]

I think we should answer the question about the dead messages since people will keep bringing it up if we don't.

unlynch troy loney

lynch redwill

[bhaw]

Troy - 3
redwill - 3
bhaw - 1
zaro - 1
senka -1

should be right.

[redwill]

You all know my vote. I laid it out in as much detail as I could in my "stuff" on p. 40. Reason after reason. I was pushing for it from Day 3. It's obvious to me.

No one has responded to that. bhaw has pointedly ignored it.

I don't know what else I can do.

Luckily, there may be a saving grace for this village in the air.

But that takes a far distant second-place to

lynch Senka

[bhaw]

You all know my vote. I laid it out in as much detail as I could in my "stuff" on p. 40. Reason after reason. I was pushing for it from Day 3. It's obvious to me.

No one has responded to that. bhaw has pointedly ignored it.

I don't know what else I can do.

Luckily, there may be a saving grace for this village in the air.

But that takes a far distant second-place to

lynch Senka

Just because i asked for your opinion doesn't mean I ever trusted you

[redwill]

Just because i asked for your opinion doesn't mean I ever trusted you

Oh, I know that quite well, boy-o.