History Mafia -- GAME THREAD

[Senka]

i agree with npv here on the dead vote. even if. thats why redwill remains on my list.

[npv708]

So why am I to vote for MWB again? Because he's not acting like his usual self?

1) Never voted for NAN, see crayz's research which shows the people that didn't vote for NAN
2) Wanted to vote for quiet people, but didn't vote for NAN, who was unusually quiet
3) Says he wants to vote for quiet people, but voted for me, who is the complete opposite of quiet...
4) He's in the mafia.

[Corvidae]

but you're not cleared, they are. I'm more willing to trust someone I know who is a 100% good, versus someone who I have no idea about.

I recall a WW game where JC was the Angel and everyone kept voting with him just because he was good. We lost that one.

Same principle. If the dead accuse someone, take a look at them and see if there's anything that stands out. As for redwill, he certainly hasn't stood out in any good or bad way, at least to me. Though if he continues to remain quite over the course of the next few days I'll become very interested.

[MWB]

How bout this?

Vote for MWB now. If MWB = red, I get another day. If MWB doesnt = red, then I'll take the fall the next day.

Have you even said why you're voting for me?

ya, you know...only in every page since the last writeup...

Since the last write-up this is the only reason I've seen:

Senka is #2 on my list right now. MWB is first. He never voted for NAN. Ever. He said he wanted to go after quiet people, but NAN himself was quiet and admitted he was red. Nothing from MWB.

You're right, I didn't EVER vote for nan, in either of my TWO votes. I also wouldn't consider nan a quiet person.

[tfrizz]

I'm sorry but this is kind of ridiculous....i got called out yesterday for voting for nan for no reason, and now people are calling others out for not having a reason to vote for nan?

who called you out for it?

TWC & Tfrizz i think.

I didn't call you out for voting for NAN. I called you out for being a very good player who apparently hasn't been targeted by the mafia yet -- aka, you've been Pavel'd.

[Troy Loney]

So why am I to vote for MWB again? Because he's not acting like his usual self?

1) Never voted for NAN, see crayz's research which shows the people that didn't vote for NAN

This is too convenient...you can aggressively push for a vote under the guise of someone else's reasoning....your on the watch list.

[MWB]

How bout this?

Vote for MWB now. If MWB = red, I get another day. If MWB doesnt = red, then I'll take the fall the next day.

This is the second time you've suggest something like this. Do you have a murder-suicide pact role?

If he's red you'll certainly be look at as "likely good." Blue or green wouldn't look so great for you but you won't be the only one voting for him.

No i don't, if it helps clarify anything...If I'm wrong I'd be willing to do the first/last vote on myself just to make sure everybody is comfortable with me dying if I'm wrong...

You said something to the same effect on a redwill vote earlier:

How about this, this will work out well for those who want to get rid of me soon anyways? If we do a redwill vote and he's red, I live. If he's green/blue, i'll gladly take the fall for following people I trust.

I don't understand how people can be so sure of things right now. You've now said you're sure of me and redwill. At best you're 1 for 2. What's made you leave redwill?

[MWB]

So why am I to vote for MWB again? Because he's not acting like his usual self?

Because I didn't vote for nan, EVER.

[npv708]

I don't understand how people can be so sure of things right now. You've now said you're sure of me and redwill. At best you're 1 for 2. What's made you leave redwill?

I think you're more dangerous than redwill if you're Mafia...

[Corvidae]

So why am I to vote for MWB again? Because he's not acting like his usual self?

Because I didn't vote for nan, EVER.

Well, if you NEVER voted for NAN in your entire LGP history, then I think you should be lynched and burned immediately.

[tfrizz]

How bout this?

Vote for MWB now. If MWB = red, I get another day. If MWB doesnt = red, then I'll take the fall the next day.

Fair enough. MWB is one of those ones I can never seem to get a read on, but I'll go with that idea.


unlynch npv708
[color=#fffff00]lynch MWB[/color]

[tfrizz]

How bout this?

Vote for MWB now. If MWB = red, I get another day. If MWB doesnt = red, then I'll take the fall the next day.

Fair enough. MWB is one of those ones I can never seem to get a read on, but I'll go with that idea.


unlynch npv708
lynch MWB

Color fail :facepalm:

[the wicked child]

Corvi beat me to it. The only good message I saw last game was from dagny telling Azkar not to believe the dead jellyfish. Every other one was nonsense or completely off base... So forgive me if I don't rush to follow.

On the flip side I see Mwb acting the same as last game. Trying to appear useful without making any real waves by pressing votes. That is enough for me.

[MWB]

So why am I to vote for MWB again? Because he's not acting like his usual self?

Because I didn't vote for nan, EVER.

Well, if you NEVER voted for NAN in your entire LGP history, then I think you should be lynched and burned immediately.

Actually, I don't know if I ever have in lgp history, so maybe npv is onto something.

[MWB]

Corvi beat me to it. The only good message I saw last game was from dagny telling Azkar not to believe the dead jellyfish. Every other one was nonsense or completely off base... So forgive me if I don't rush to follow.

On the flip side I see Mwb acting the same as last game. Trying to appear useful without making any real waves by pressing votes. That is enough for me.

I started the day phase by saying it should be bhaw, npv, or redwill this round.

[slappybrown]

Well seems like no one likes my suggestions this round, so lynch MWB to move this along

[MWB]

Corvi beat me to it. The only good message I saw last game was from dagny telling Azkar not to believe the dead jellyfish. Every other one was nonsense or completely off base... So forgive me if I don't rush to follow.

On the flip side I see Mwb acting the same as last game. Trying to appear useful without making any real waves by pressing votes. That is enough for me.

Also, I play this way every game. Like I've already said, I say who I think is suspicious but don't vote early.

[MWB]

I guess I'll make my vote since things aren't looking so good.
lynch npv
He's grasping at straws in his reasons for me and they're not even really accurate. He's also said twice now that if he's wrong he should be killed off.

[MWB]

Also, to add:
I'd be wary of bhaw for what happened earlier. That's kind of fallen away. He was also posting at night. Other night posters included c2i and tfrizz. Redwill has disappeared, but said he wouldn't be around until tonight anyway.

[Letang Is The Truth]

Lynch bhaw

Color plz

[mac5155]

someone have a vote count?/

[mac5155]

Lynch bhaw
Color plz

[cup keeper]

Vote Count
mwb-9-
bhaw-2-
redwill-1-
npv-1-
kicksave-1-

[beerman]

Count

MWB - 8 - crayz, tw, senka, npv, kicksave, azkar, tfrizz, slappy
bhaw - 2 - corvi, litt
redwill - 1 - bhaw
npv - 1 - mwb
kicksave - 1 - troy

11 needed

[mac5155]

thanks but who's right?!