History Mafia -- GAME THREAD

[beerman]

9 – redwill (npv708, Senka, Azkar, crayz, Twisted Wrister, Zarovich, newarenanow, Letang Is The Truth, MWB)
4 – npv708 (PensFanInDC, IrishEyes, Troy Loney, count2infinity)
3 – newarenanow (slappybrown, hockeynut, kicksave)
2 – Troy Loney (the wicked child, tfrizz)
1 – bhaw (Corvidae)
1 – Corvidae (bhaw)
1 – Senka (redwill)
1 – Twisted Wrister (cup keeper)

I'll be going to lunch in a little bit

[slappybrown]

I'd like to point out that someone called you "yeehaw" in another thread, and I laughed and laughed.

[Hockeynut!]

I'd like to point out that someone called you "yeehaw" in another thread, and I laughed and laughed.

[Kicksave]

I'd like to point out that someone called you "yeehaw" in another thread, and I laughed and laughed.

[count2infinity]

i'm just gonna throw this out there...i'm willing to go nan today npv tomorrow, if that clears this whole thing up by 1 o'clock

[Kicksave]

I'm doing what we should have done yesterday - lynch nan.

From there, we're going to get the most information than if we blindly lynch redwill. I absolutely HATE how we just ignore the past day and just bring up random people for lynching instead of looking back and making decisions that way. Look at who has been killed, voting patterns, etc. Don't just ignore these clues.

[count2infinity]

unlynch npv

lynch nan

we'll get a little bit of info, one way or another and i think we still have npv in our pocket for later. i highly suggest coming off of redwill as a blind bandwagon vote.

[Letang Is The Truth]

I'm doing what we should have done yesterday - lynch nan.

From there, we're going to get the most information than if we blindly lynch redwill. I absolutely HATE how we just ignore the past day and just bring up random people for lynching instead of looking back and making decisions that way. Look at who has been killed, voting patterns, etc. Don't just ignore these clues.

i think where i am caught up is that several of the dead people are RPs and may have some insight to what is going on

[slappybrown]

http://www.letsgopens.com/scripts/phpBB ... w#p1159845" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

pwnt

[Kicksave]

I'm doing what we should have done yesterday - lynch nan.

From there, we're going to get the most information than if we blindly lynch redwill. I absolutely HATE how we just ignore the past day and just bring up random people for lynching instead of looking back and making decisions that way. Look at who has been killed, voting patterns, etc. Don't just ignore these clues.

i think where i am caught up is that several of the dead people are RPs and may have some insight to what is going on

We lost 2 masons, the deputy and the doctor. From when I ran Holiday Wars, the deputy wouldn't have had any powers unless the town cop died so he wouldn't have any info. Same with the doctor. The masons are essentially useless.

I'm not going to blindly listen to a dead person PM.

[relantel]

9 – redwill (npv708, Senka, Azkar, crayz, Twisted Wrister, Zarovich, newarenanow, Letang Is The Truth, MWB)
4 – npv708 (PensFanInDC, IrishEyes, Troy Loney, count2infinity)
3 – newarenanow (slappybrown, hockeynut, kicksave)
2 – Troy Loney (the wicked child, tfrizz)
1 – bhaw (Corvidae)
1 – Corvidae (bhaw)
1 – Senka (redwill)
1 – Twisted Wrister (cup keeper)

I'll be going to lunch in a little bit

I think that's wrong - I thought MWB voted npv?

[tfrizz]

9 – redwill (npv708, Senka, Azkar, crayz, Twisted Wrister, Zarovich, newarenanow, Letang Is The Truth, MWB)
4 – npv708 (PensFanInDC, IrishEyes, Troy Loney, count2infinity)
3 – newarenanow (slappybrown, hockeynut, kicksave)
2 – Troy Loney (the wicked child, tfrizz)
1 – bhaw (Corvidae)
1 – Corvidae (bhaw)
1 – Senka (redwill)
1 – Twisted Wrister (cup keeper)

I'll be going to lunch in a little bit

I think that's wrong - I thought MWB voted npv?

That matches what I've got...

[relantel]

9 – redwill (npv708, Senka, Azkar, crayz, Twisted Wrister, Zarovich, newarenanow, Letang Is The Truth, MWB)
4 – npv708 (PensFanInDC, IrishEyes, Troy Loney, count2infinity)
3 – newarenanow (slappybrown, hockeynut, kicksave)
2 – Troy Loney (the wicked child, tfrizz)
1 – bhaw (Corvidae)
1 – Corvidae (bhaw)
1 – Senka (redwill)
1 – Twisted Wrister (cup keeper)

I'll be going to lunch in a little bit

I think that's wrong - I thought MWB voted npv?

That matches what I've got...

http://www.letsgopens.com/scripts/phpBB ... 0#p1160015" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

[tfrizz]

PFIDC, I'm just wondering why some people are voting for npv based on night posts (that aren't game related) instead of voting for someone who is actually posting game stuff at night. If that is a person's reason for voting for him then it seems like flawed logic to me.

my reasoning is a little different. zaro put a vote on him and then npv came out with this giant list of people that he suspects to be the mafia godfather, then he even brings a quote from another thread to implicate zaro. it all seemed odd to me.

Yeah, I understand that... part of why I'm also suspicious of him. I'm more talking about pfidc and IE who used the initial reasoning of night posting as a vote for him. I'm torn between redwill and npv but think we can get good info from this vote. If the deadline is indeed 1pm I'm not sure how much I'll be on before then, so I'm going to throw out my vote now.
lynch npv

rel is right... not sure why I've got him on redwill

[tfrizz]

Vote Count

Code: Select all

8 – redwill (npv708, Senka, Azkar, crayz, Twisted Wrister, Zarovich, newarenanow, Letang Is The Truth)
4 – newarenanow (slappybrown, Hockeynut!, Kicksave, count2infinity)
4 – npv708 (PensFanInDC, IrishEyes, Troy Loney, MWB)
2 – Troy Loney (the wicked child, tfrizz)
1 – bhaw (Corvidae)
1 – Corvidae (bhaw)
1 – Senka (redwill)
1 – Twisted Wrister (cup keeper)

Have Not Voted

Code: Select all

relantel

Changed Votes

Code: Select all

* Hockeynut! unlynched newarenanow (00:27)
* bhaw unlynched Azkar; lynched Corvidae (00:17)
* the wicked child unlynched Azkar; lynched Troy Loney (01:56)
* count2infinity unlynched cup keeper; lynched npv708 (02:58)
* Twisted Wrister unlynched newarenanow; lynched tfrizz (03:07)
* count2infinity unlynched npv708 (00:26)
* npv708 unlynched newarenanow; lynched redwill (05:12)
* Senka unlynched npv708; lynched redwill (04:41)
* crayz unlynched newarenanow; lynched redwill (06:23)
* Twisted Wrister unlynched tfrizz; lynched redwill (04:17)
* Zarovich unlynched npv708; lynched redwill (12:02)
* count2infinity unlynched npv708; lynched newarenanow (01:46)

[bhaw]

I could be down with voting for redwill. To me, dead people or bystanders see some things people playing don't.

Plus the train is rolling already. I don't like switching votes this early. It only causes confusion and trouble.

lynch redwill

This one. He usually talks more and the 2nd line is weird for him.

[beerman]

9 – redwill (npv708, Senka, Azkar, crayz, Twisted Wrister, Zarovich, newarenanow, Letang Is The Truth, MWB)
4 – npv708 (PensFanInDC, IrishEyes, Troy Loney, count2infinity)
3 – newarenanow (slappybrown, hockeynut, kicksave)
2 – Troy Loney (the wicked child, tfrizz)
1 – bhaw (Corvidae)
1 – Corvidae (bhaw)
1 – Senka (redwill)
1 – Twisted Wrister (cup keeper)

I'll be going to lunch in a little bit

I think that's wrong - I thought MWB voted npv?

That matches what I've got...

I copied what you had, hoping it was right...

I'm heading out for lunch and I'll tally them all up when I get back

[tfrizz]

I copied what you had, hoping it was right...

I'm heading out for lunch and I'll tally them all up when I get back

Should be good now, but never hurts to double check.

[cup keeper]

I could be down with voting for redwill. To me, dead people or bystanders see some things people playing don't.

Plus the train is rolling already. I don't like switching votes this early. It only causes confusion and trouble.

lynch redwill

This one. He usually talks more and the 2nd line is weird for him.

I was thinking the same thing with this post. NAN usually doesn't do silly things like want to listen to dead people talking.

unlynch twisted wrister
lynch nan

[bhaw]

lynch nan

Let's just get this done with and see if we find out anything. The redwill vote seems naive considering the deputy likely can't seer anyone and people are trusting the judgment of the dead blindly.

[cup keeper]

bhaw- you might need to unlynch corv first.

[newarenanow]

I could be down with voting for redwill. To me, dead people or bystanders see some things people playing don't.

Plus the train is rolling already. I don't like switching votes this early. It only causes confusion and trouble.

lynch redwill

This one. He usually talks more and the 2nd line is weird for him.

You guys can vote me out. I just got back from the doctors and have a scratched eyeball and I can barely even open it.

That, and between my year end closing at work, it was probably a bad idea for me to sign up the last two games. I don't have enough time to fully pariticpate.

[beerman]

also 1 pm isn't really a definite deadline it was more or less just something to work towards. I won't be back till near that time anyway just an fyi.

[the wicked child]

Alright. I am not down with th rw vote for reasons previously stated. I an still somewhat suspicious of another so I will go with that.

Unlynch Troy Loney
Lynch NAN

Color please.

[Kicksave]

Alright. I am not down with th rw vote for reasons previously stated. I an still somewhat suspicious of another so I will go with that.

Unlynch Troy Loney
Lynch NAN

Color please.