History Mafia -- GAME THREAD

[count2infinity]

PFIDC, I'm just wondering why some people are voting for npv based on night posts (that aren't game related) instead of voting for someone who is actually posting game stuff at night. If that is a person's reason for voting for him then it seems like flawed logic to me.

my reasoning is a little different. zaro put a vote on him and then npv came out with this giant list of people that he suspects to be the mafia godfather, then he even brings a quote from another thread to implicate zaro. it all seemed odd to me.

[MWB]

PFIDC, I'm just wondering why some people are voting for npv based on night posts (that aren't game related) instead of voting for someone who is actually posting game stuff at night. If that is a person's reason for voting for him then it seems like flawed logic to me.

my reasoning is a little different. zaro put a vote on him and then npv came out with this giant list of people that he suspects to be the mafia godfather, then he even brings a quote from another thread to implicate zaro. it all seemed odd to me.

Yeah, I understand that... part of why I'm also suspicious of him. I'm more talking about pfidc and IE who used the initial reasoning of night posting as a vote for him. I'm torn between redwill and npv but think we can get good info from this vote. If the deadline is indeed 1pm I'm not sure how much I'll be on before then, so I'm going to throw out my vote now.
lynch npv

[Kicksave]

I'm down for a bhaw or nan lynching.

[tfrizz]

Vote Count

Code: Select all

9 – redwill (npv708, Senka, Azkar, crayz, Twisted Wrister, Zarovich, newarenanow, Letang Is The Truth, MWB)
4 – npv708 (PensFanInDC, IrishEyes, Troy Loney, count2infinity)
2 – Troy Loney (the wicked child, tfrizz)
1 – bhaw (Corvidae)
1 – Corvidae (bhaw)
1 – newarenanow (slappybrown)
1 – Senka (redwill)
1 – Twisted Wrister (cup keeper)

Have Not Voted

Code: Select all

Hockeynut!, Kicksave, relantel

Changed Votes

Code: Select all

* Hockeynut! unlynched newarenanow (00:27)
* bhaw unlynched Azkar; lynched Corvidae (00:17)
* the wicked child unlynched Azkar; lynched Troy Loney (01:56)
* count2infinity unlynched cup keeper; lynched npv708 (02:58)
* Twisted Wrister unlynched newarenanow; lynched tfrizz (03:07)
* count2infinity unlynched npv708 (00:26)
* npv708 unlynched newarenanow; lynched redwill (05:12)
* Senka unlynched npv708; lynched redwill (04:41)
* crayz unlynched newarenanow; lynched redwill (06:23)
* Twisted Wrister unlynched tfrizz; lynched redwill (04:17)
* Zarovich unlynched npv708; lynched redwill (12:02)

[PensFanInDC]

PFIDC, I'm just wondering why some people are voting for npv based on night posts (that aren't game related) instead of voting for someone who is actually posting game stuff at night. If that is a person's reason for voting for him then it seems like flawed logic to me.

my reasoning is a little different. zaro put a vote on him and then npv came out with this giant list of people that he suspects to be the mafia godfather, then he even brings a quote from another thread to implicate zaro. it all seemed odd to me.

Yeah, I understand that... part of why I'm also suspicious of him. I'm more talking about pfidc and IE who used the initial reasoning of night posting as a vote for him. I'm torn between redwill and npv but think we can get good info from this vote. If the deadline is indeed 1pm I'm not sure how much I'll be on before then, so I'm going to throw out my vote now.
lynch npv

I am in now way 100% sure npv is mafia. I have said that. My reasoning, as it always is this early, is that there really isnt much to go on this early in a game. I picked 2 things (night posting and change of style) as my reasons for npv. The change of style makes me feel better about the vote as you (I think it was you) mentioned. The night posting was my initial reason but his change in style is more of a red flag to me at this point. It just came out after my initial vote.

[Kicksave]

...why have you guys not gone back to bhaw/nan thing yesterday?

[count2infinity]

...why have you guys not gone back to bhaw/nan thing yesterday?

ummm...for me it's because i was never on the bhaw/nan thing yesterday.

[relantel]

You guys have been busy, and appear logjammed. Almost caught up, and will consider my vote when I read the last couple pages.

[Kicksave]

...why have you guys not gone back to bhaw/nan thing yesterday?

ummm...for me it's because i was never on the bhaw/nan thing yesterday.

You didn't read all that went down?

[count2infinity]

...why have you guys not gone back to bhaw/nan thing yesterday?

ummm...for me it's because i was never on the bhaw/nan thing yesterday.

You didn't read all that went down?

i did, but i wasn't really buying into it.

[Letang Is The Truth]

...why have you guys not gone back to bhaw/nan thing yesterday?

ummm...for me it's because i was never on the bhaw/nan thing yesterday.

You didn't read all that went down?

can you summarize what happened? i may have missed something important. nothing really stood out to me

[relantel]

Sorry, took the time to look at the Tim Horton's commercial. I don't know that we really know anything. I was half tempted to random.org my vote, but being 3 votes out, and an 8-5 count redwill to npv, looks like it is between them at this point. I'm almost to a coin flip.

[count2infinity]

Sorry, took the time to look at the Tim Horton's commercial. I don't know that we really know anything. I was half tempted to random.org my vote, but being 3 votes out, and an 8-5 count redwill to npv, looks like it is between them at this point. I'm almost to a coin flip.

heads i win, tails you lose?

[PensFanInDC]

Sorry, took the time to look at the Tim Horton's commercial. I don't know that we really know anything. I was half tempted to random.org my vote, but being 3 votes out, and an 8-5 count redwill to npv, looks like it is between them at this point. I'm almost to a coin flip.

heads i win, tails you lose?

Joey - ohh ohh! Ducks is heads, cause ducks have heads!!

Chandler - What kind of sick ass clowns came to your birthday!?

[slappybrown]

...why have you guys not gone back to bhaw/nan thing yesterday?

ummm...for me it's because i was never on the bhaw/nan thing yesterday.

You didn't read all that went down?

Well you know where my vote is, but no one else is buying. I still think the potential tell plus the added potential for a lot of information coming out of a NAN vote is better than anything else we have.

[Hockeynut!]

This is a clusterfudge.

I'm going with the same vote I made yesterday.

Lynch NAN

We could actually learn something from this (maybe). Everything else is just a shot in the dark at this point.

[count2infinity]

i'd go with nan as an info kill tomorrow. today i'm really thinking we should go after npv. i think that blindly following the dead, and killing zaro is a bad idea. if you want to go after zaro, come up with a better reason.

[Letang Is The Truth]

who is saying to go after zaro?

[count2infinity]

redwill...sorry was thinking zaro as the person that npv was trying to get people to go after.

[count2infinity]

and in case that post didn't make sense, substitute redwill into my post that said blindly following to vote zaro, i meant to say redwill. i'm not going to post again until i've eaten lunch and have a cleared mind. lol

[relantel]

Sorry, took the time to look at the Tim Horton's commercial. I don't know that we really know anything. I was half tempted to random.org my vote, but being 3 votes out, and an 8-5 count redwill to npv, looks like it is between them at this point. I'm almost to a coin flip.

heads i win, tails you lose?

Could be, c2i, could be...

[Kicksave]

lynch nan

[PensFanInDC]

Is this thing on?

[bhaw]

After catching back up, NAN is acting way different than most games. Way less participation and his last post was definitely weird.

To be honest, there are a bunch of people I'd be "fine" with voting for right now, but no one I'm dead set on.

I'm way less suspicious of the people voting for npv and nan than those on redwill.

[Letang Is The Truth]

After catching back up, NAN is acting way different than most games. Way less participation and his last post was definitely weird.
To be honest, there are a bunch of people I'd be "fine" with voting for right now, but no one I'm dead set on.

I'm way less suspicious of the people voting for npv and nan than those on redwill.

which post was that?