History Mafia -- GAME THREAD

[mac5155]

3 - nan
1 - tfrizz
3 - npv
1 - bhaw
1- troy loney
1 - corvidae
think that's right anyone wanna confirm?

12 to lynch

[npv708]

unlynch cupkeeper for now and lynch npv... seems like he's really stretching to get focus off of himself...

how?

i think zaro voted on you, and you said "if i was a bad guy..." which was weird. You had a whole big list of suspects that you think are the godfather of the mafia, and you even brought something from another thread in for questioning (against a guy that voted for you btw...)

just all seemed odd.

Okay. I guess I get where you're coming from with that. I honestly had absolutely no idea zaro voted for me and I called Senka out for doing the same thing (Me calling him out, him voting for me). The whole "if i was a bad guy thing" is something people do a lot, its like the whole "think like a serial killer" to catch a serial killer. That's all. If you wanna catch a baddie then you have to think like one. The only reason I brought that part about Zarovich in from the other thread is that bhaw and I were talking about who had a grudge against Dagny and Jays. It just happens that he puts about how he would go after Dags and Juice. Juice isn't playing and Dagny was killed overnight. That's like me saying in the signup thread that "I hate corvi, if i have the power I'm going to kill him" and then Corvi is killed overnight, I'm going to look suspicious right? That's all. I still haven't voted for him, I'm just trying to throw theories out there.

[count2infinity]

well, while we're thinking like a baddie... "I hate corvi, if i have the power i'm going to kill him" and then corvi dies, i think i'd think it's a baddie move to frame you. i just don't think at this point we have enough to really go on... so i'm just going to revoke my vote for now and see what happens between now and tomorrow morning.

unlynch NPV

lynch THG again???

[Corvidae]

I don't like being the example in your hate theories.

[npv708]

I don't like being the example in your hate theories.

it could've been worse...I could've made it Corvidae is a baddie...

[Troy Loney]

meh.

unlynch Azkar
lynch Troy Loney

He's a veteran. I don't buy him piling onto that NAN vote over that reasoning.

What was your vote that round? What was your reasoning?

That was day 2, the first day lasted a whole what, 1 hour? It seemed to me the whole first day of the game (monday) was talking about how we were going to kill THG for some reason that i dont even know because i got killed off so quickly the last game and never paid any attention to it.

Truth be told, these 30 person games get a little overwhelming at first and i don't have the tension span to pay close attention to the early rounds, i do think its important to call out people and see how they respond and defend themselves and find some tells. Personally i was satisfied with nan's response to the bandwagon, he was just like, whatever you can kill me, no harm done and someone has to go this round.

If you take my lack of participation as lying low, your right, and your right to be suspicious, but i'm nothing.

[tfrizz]

I've got no problem with the Senka route. After 2 rounds of voting, he has yet to cast a single one (Twisted Wrister is the only other that hasn't). He's typically quiet, so nothing out of the ordinary there... but he is always dangerous because of that.

Any other thoughts?

tfrizz do you even read the thread at all. You said Senka hasn't voted and neither did I. Meanwhile if you look at the page before theres my vote.

Has NAN even posted to defend himself?

He's likely just a blue guy and doesn't care.

Unlynch NAN

Lynch tfrizz

Sorry, I've been playing catch up all day -- swamped at work all day, and out running errands most of the night.

[Corvidae]

it could've been worse...I could've made it Corvidae is a baddie...

Fixt

[tfrizz]

Anyway, in case I don't get a chance to get on again before bed...

Something just makes me uneasy with Troy still around, similar to the way Pavel did in Jellyfish Invasion. He's one of those guys that is typically an early target every game but is still alive.

lynch Troy Loney

[Troy Loney]

Anyway, in case I don't get a chance to get on again before bed...

Something just makes me uneasy with Troy still around, similar to the way Pavel did in Jellyfish Invasion. He's one of those guys that is typically an early target every game but is still alive.

lynch Troy Loney

Thats bogus...you can say that about any player on the list, we've played like 15 of these games...it was only last game that i was taken out right away.

[redwill]

I hate to add another name to the growing list, but I can't resist it: The hand of Senka in molding the current situation fits too perfectly IMO. And he's way too dangerous to leave around if he's a baddie.

lynch Senka

He's usually on late at night so I invite comment from him. Not that I'll be around to read it...

I'm off to bed and then I won't be on much tomorrow 'til later at night. Good luck, folks.

[Zarovich]

LOL. I think I frazzled npv. You must not follow these games close as I do kill Dagny every chance I get. My bit with Juice is that he always votes quiet people and I am always voted off by the village for being quiet.

[mac5155]

3 - nan
3 - npv
2- troy loney
1 - tfrizz
1 - bhaw
1 - corvidae
1- Senka
1- Twisted Wrister
think that's right anyone wanna confirm?

12 to lynch

[cup keeper]

mac- you missed my vote for tw

[Zarovich]

I thought some more and like my npv vote. Posted a bunch of nonsense at night, came up with a list of 10 potential baddies and then starts pulling posts from other threads. I think c2i had the right idea earlier of what npv was doing.

[MWB]

Is it me or is npv posting a lot more in this thread than in any of the previous games?

I'm also still not liking the posters who were talking about the game during the night phase, which includes tfrizz, c2i, and bhaw.

[Kicksave]

This is the absolute worst start for the village, ever.

[mac5155]

just flipped a coin to see if i should post another "dead" PM

so


MESSAGE FROM THE DEAD!!

Kill Redwill!

[npv708]

Is it me or is npv posting a lot more in this thread than in any of the previous games?

I'm also still not liking the posters who were talking about the game during the night phase, which includes tfrizz, c2i, and bhaw.

I'm definitely posting more, but that's because I'm actually available to play now...

[npv708]

unlynch NAN

I'm listening to the dead since they've all been good.

lynch redwill

[npv708]

Is it me or is npv posting a lot more in this thread than in any of the previous games?

I'm also still not liking the posters who were talking about the game during the night phase, which includes tfrizz, c2i, and bhaw.

I'm definitely posting more, but that's because I'm actually available to play now...

Also I forgot to mention that I had a lot of nonsense night posts too.

[cup keeper]

Just because they're dead doesn't mean they know anything more than the rest of us that are still alive.

Although some of them claim that they do.

[Senka]

Yesss. Redwill called me out. and now got called out from the dead.

unlynch npv, lynch redwill

[cup keeper]

I mean they could be right and redwill is bad but it would just be a good guess. If the investigator was dead I might put a little more stock in what the dead were saying. An earlier dead message told us to go after jaysmiter and he was the doctor. Let's not just blindly follow the messages from the dead.

[npv708]

I mean they could be right and redwill is bad but it would just be a good guess. If the investigator was dead I might put a little more stock in what the dead were saying. An earlier dead message told us to go after jaysmiter and he was the doctor. Let's not just blindly follow the messages from the dead.

The way I look at it is that the dead are all cleared...as of now, with little to go on, I feel more comfortable following their words as opposed to people who are still in question...