History Mafia -- GAME THREAD

[bhaw]

Lynch THG!

^this guy? WTF?

He never signed up and was never listed in the initial post. I think his vote was just a joke.

Ok... mac can you confirm?

[tfrizz]

Senka is a def possibility... but he is so wacky that you never know. If he survives much longer, he's probably bad, IMO... I would think the bad guys would take him out pretty early rather than risk him going on a SWI-esque run against them.

I def have to look back through Day 2 a bit cuz I skimmed most of it on my phone during a meeting... Still like where my vote is atm though.

Another one is Troy Loney. He is usually an early target if he's not mafia, and is still alive. It's a similar situation to Pavel last game... still alive on Day 3-4, but dismissed because the mafia has been killing RPs.

[mac5155]

Lynch THG!

^this guy? WTF?

He never signed up and was never listed in the initial post. I think his vote was just a joke.

yeah he wasnt signed up. i dont have any record of it.

[slappybrown]

Lynch THG!

^this guy? WTF?

He never signed up and was never listed in the initial post. I think his vote was just a joke.

We put him up to in the chat. It was a joke.

Lynch NAN

He had a possible tell, the village never should have moved off of him in the first place, and there is the chance that a lot of information will come out of his kill.

[bhaw]

lynch Azkar

For reasons I've said before and the fact that jays usually votes off azkar. I'm 2 hours behind, so if the vote happens in the AM, it will probably be done before I am back.

[Senka]

Here's what I'm thinking:

I'm thinking that the Godfather is one of these, and at least one of the other mafia members is in this list. They are definitely experienced to go after the vets and such. We'll probably see them turn away from the vets and go after somebody newer to throw the scent.

5. Troy Loney - JP Morgan
8. MWB - Robert E. Lee
10. Zarovich - Ben Franklin
13. Kicksave - Andrew Carnegie
15. Corvidae - Richard Nixon
19. bhaw - Jesse James
20. cupkeeper - Robert Morris
23. Senka - Joseph Schantz
27. Azkar - Betsy Ross
29. newarenanow - John Hancock

Umm.. Out of the list of Godfather potential..
Im led to believe its more along the possibility of bhaw, kicksave, and yourself--npv.

Im not the godfather, cuz if yu ever noticed, i like to leave the vets around. in fact i tend to take all most of the middle people. the noobs get voted out and everything falls into place lol but its not I this game...

[Senka]

Lynch npv

[bhaw]

He had a possible tell, the village never should have moved off of him in the first place, and there is the chance that a lot of information will come out of his kill.

Just putting this out there to put in the memory bank... talking down to the village like you knew better is usually a baddie trait. Not saying slappy is bad YET, but something to remember.

[the wicked child]

**** Comcast... my damn internet has been dropping in and out all damn night since I got home from work.

[Corvidae]

I'm trying to figure out what's more likely: A bad NAN that killed jay, or the Jellies killing jay to setup NAN.

[dagny]

can i make a request to reduce the amount of images? it makes it excruciating to view on phone

x2 and this is coming from the moderator

youtubes are fine.

I'm happy to go through with my pruning shears.

[bhaw]

Here's what I'm thinking:

I'm thinking that the Godfather is one of these, and at least one of the other mafia members is in this list. They are definitely experienced to go after the vets and such. We'll probably see them turn away from the vets and go after somebody newer to throw the scent.

5. Troy Loney - JP Morgan
8. MWB - Robert E. Lee
10. Zarovich - Ben Franklin
13. Kicksave - Andrew Carnegie
15. Corvidae - Richard Nixon
19. bhaw - Jesse James
20. cupkeeper - Robert Morris
23. Senka - Joseph Schantz
27. Azkar - Betsy Ross
29. newarenanow - John Hancock

Umm.. Out of the list of Godfather potential..
Im led to believe its more along the possibility of bhaw, kicksave, and yourself--npv.

Im not the godfather, cuz if yu ever noticed, i like to leave the vets around. in fact i tend to take all most of the middle people. the noobs get voted out and everything falls into place lol but its not I this game...

I don't think either of the 3 you stated make sense as the godfather (and you know this) because all 3 of us have put a lot out there. Usually the head baddie is more quiet to keep people off of him/her. Could npv, kicksave, or npv be supporting baddies based on what you are saying, yes. But to say it makes sense that we are the godfather doesn't fit how it normally goes down.

I don't like to pay attention to lists like this b/c he's basically accusing 1/3 of the village. So yeah, "chances are pretty good" there's at least one bad guy in there.

[mac5155]

i think its funny how the bad guys have like 30 different names

[mac5155]

can i make a request to reduce the amount of images? it makes it excruciating to view on phone

x2 and this is coming from the moderator

youtubes are fine.

I'm happy to go through with my pruning shears.

we will be sure to keep it to a minimum from here on out.. let's see if they can be responsible

[bhaw]

Lol ^ should read

"Could npv, kicksave, or bhaw be supporting baddies... I used npv twice.

[Corvidae]

I don't like to pay attention to lists like this b/c he's basically accusing 1/3 of the village. So yeah, "chances are pretty good" there's at least one bad guy in there.

I almost want to vote for him because of that. Very wolf/slug/jelly/mod/grinchy to accuse a ton of people. It causes people to come out and defend themselves, thus causing .

[slappybrown]

He had a possible tell, the village never should have moved off of him in the first place, and there is the chance that a lot of information will come out of his kill.

Just putting this out there to put in the memory bank... talking down to the village like you knew better is usually a baddie trait. Not saying slappy is bad YET, but something to remember.

What? I dont think we should have moved off of a NAN vote. What are you talking about?

[bhaw]

He had a possible tell, the village never should have moved off of him in the first place, and there is the chance that a lot of information will come out of his kill.

Just putting this out there to put in the memory bank... talking down to the village like you knew better is usually a baddie trait. Not saying slappy is bad YET, but something to remember.

What? I dont think we should have moved off of a NAN vote. What are you talking about?

Why? Because NAN is obviously a bad guy? You know nothing more than the rest of us who know nothing unless you are the seer. NAN said one thing at night. Again, not defending nan but trying to figure out why it's so obvious we shouldn't have changed votes. What do we learn by bandwagoning active people?

[Corvidae]

*I meant mob, not mod. Freudian slip?

[bhaw]

I don't like to pay attention to lists like this b/c he's basically accusing 1/3 of the village. So yeah, "chances are pretty good" there's at least one bad guy in there.

I almost want to vote for him because of that. Very wolf/slug/jelly/mod/grinchy to accuse a ton of people. It causes people to come out and defend themselves, thus causing .

unlynch azkar

lynch corvidae

Corvi keeps agreeing with me, which is bad. Despite PFIDC's praise, I am terrible at this game when it comes to voting for bad guys.

[mac5155]

*I meant mob, not mod. Freudian slip?

hey, who you associatin me wit yo?!

[bhaw]

PS -

[mac5155]

4 - nan
1 - cupkeeper
2 - npv
1 - corvidae/quote]

[mac5155]

i think that count is right.

[Corvidae]

I don't like to pay attention to lists like this b/c he's basically accusing 1/3 of the village. So yeah, "chances are pretty good" there's at least one bad guy in there.

I almost want to vote for him because of that. Very wolf/slug/jelly/mod/grinchy to accuse a ton of people. It causes people to come out and defend themselves, thus causing .

unlynch azkar

lynch corvidae

Corvi keeps agreeing with me, which is bad. Despite PFIDC's praise, I am terrible at this game when it comes to voting for bad guys.

You're voting with me because I agreed that voting for quiet people is good (which I normally say) and huge lists are bad, but disagree that we can indite Senka for not posting much in one day?

Also, if you're bad at voting for good guys, does that mean you're saying I'm definitely a good guy?

Thanks?