History Mafia -- GAME THREAD

[crayz]

Here is my theory....based on the changed votes and stuff....let's just kill off nan. I think that will now tell us the most.

[relantel]

Wow, a busy workday and the thread explodes. I don't have much to go on, but if we're not going to random, bhaw's quiet theory is as good as any. And since I don't have any better ideas, sdm works for me.

lynch sdm

[Letang Is The Truth]

do you want me to color that for you

[count2infinity]

last time i checked confusion and off topic talk = good for baddies?

[relantel]

Wow, a busy workday and the thread explodes. I don't have much to go on, but if we're not going to random, bhaw's quiet theory is as good as any. And since I don't have any better ideas, sdm works for me.

lynch sdm

color fail!

[relantel]

do you want me to color that for you

I got it, but thanks for noticing!

[redwill]

lynch sdm

NAN's reaction to the votes he was getting makes me think he wwas blue.

I would vote CupKeeper but I think sdm usually somes on when he gets heat. I want to see if he comes on.

Yeah, because of his non-urgent defense, I'm beginning to have a blue feeling about nan, too. I think he just screwed up with the night post.

I like your thinking about flushing out sdm.

unlynch nan
lynch sdm

[Kicksave]

Here is my theory....based on the changed votes and stuff....let's just kill off nan. I think that will now tell us the most.

Are we agreeing?

[MWB]

Alright, well I'm going to be gone for the next 2 hours or so in meetings, then driving home. I'm going to put in my vote for MWB. He's usually a bit more active, even at this point in the game and is usually clever as a mafia. There isn't a ton to go on right now, but I think MWB is a safe bet.

lynch MWB

I don't really get why people are going overboard with the active/inactive stuff at this point. The first day phase began sometime last night and the voting for thg took place during the Pens game. I checked back this morning and it was the night phase... have only just now been able to get on again and it's day.

[the wicked child]

meetings are fun. :/

nan seems blue to me... Would have fought a bit more IMO if he were red. He's also a vet so unlikely to make a dumb night mistake.

I have nothing much to offer atm but I think we need to make a decision... So in that vein...

Lynch sdm. Color please.

[MWB]

I'll lynch sdm

Like I said before, I think it's good to get the quiet players out early... players who are quiet every game, not just the first few hours of a game. sdm is always quiet. Cup keeper would be my second choice.

[Kicksave]

meetings are fun. :/

nan seems blue to me... Would have fought a bit more IMO if he were red. He's also a vet so unlikely to make a dumb night mistake.

I have nothing much to offer atm but I think we need to make a decision... So in that vein...

Lynch sdm. Color please.

[Kicksave]

[MWB]

meetings are fun. :/

nan seems blue to me... Would have fought a bit more IMO if he were red. He's also a vet so unlikely to make a dumb night mistake.

I have nothing much to offer atm but I think we need to make a decision... So in that vein...

Lynch sdm. Color please.

nan, however, would be smart enough to know that a quiet defense is a lot more effective than a defense.

[beerman]

Count:

sdm - 12 - troy, cupkeeper, nan, azkar, bhaw, ie, pfidc, zaro, relantel, redwill, twc, mwb
nan - 6 - slappy, jays, litt, kicksave, hockeynut, corvi
cupkeeper - 1 - c2i
redwill - 1 - crayz
mwb - 1 - npv

fixed missed relantel

[beerman]

13 to lynch

[tfrizz]

Vote Count

Code: Select all

11 – sdm5055 (Troy Loney, cup keeper, newarenanow, Azkar, bhaw, IrishEyes, PensFanInDC, Zarovich, relantel, the wicked child, MWB)
7 – newarenanow (slappybrown, jaysmiter, Letang Is The Truth, Kicksave, Hockeynut!, Corvidae, redwill)
1 – cup keeper (count2infinity)
1 – MWB (npv708)
1 – redwill (crayz)

Have Not Voted

Code: Select all

sdm5055, Senka, tfrizz, Twisted Wrister

Changed Votes

Code: Select all

* npv708 unlynched jaysmiter; lynched newarenanow (00:02)
* Troy Loney unlynched newarenanow; lynched sdm5055 (00:28)
* newarenanow unlynched cup keeper; lynched sdm5055 (00:07)
* IrishEyes unlynched newarenanow; lynched sdm5055 (00:43)
* PensFanInDC unlynched newarenanow; lynched sdm5055 (00:41)
* npv708 unlynched newarenanow; lynched sdm5055 (01:07)
* npv708 unlynched sdm5055 (00:25)
* redwill unlynched newarenanow; lynched sdm5055 (01:25)

The number at the end is the time between votes. (hh:mm)

[crayz]

unlynch redwill
lynch sdm

[tfrizz]

Vote Count

Code: Select all

12 – sdm5055 (Troy Loney, cup keeper, newarenanow, Azkar, bhaw, IrishEyes, PensFanInDC, Zarovich, relantel, the wicked child, MWB, redwill)
6 – newarenanow (slappybrown, jaysmiter, Letang Is The Truth, Kicksave, Hockeynut!, Corvidae)
1 – cup keeper (count2infinity)
1 – MWB (npv708)
1 – redwill (crayz)

Have Not Voted

Code: Select all

sdm5055, Senka, tfrizz, Twisted Wrister

Changed Votes

Code: Select all

* npv708 unlynched jaysmiter; lynched newarenanow (00:02)
* Troy Loney unlynched newarenanow; lynched sdm5055 (00:28)
* newarenanow unlynched cup keeper; lynched sdm5055 (00:07)
* IrishEyes unlynched newarenanow; lynched sdm5055 (00:43)
* PensFanInDC unlynched newarenanow; lynched sdm5055 (00:41)
* npv708 unlynched newarenanow; lynched sdm5055 (01:07)
* npv708 unlynched sdm5055 (00:25)
* redwill unlynched newarenanow; lynched sdm5055 (01:25)

The number at the end is the time between votes. (hh:mm)

Forgot to switch redwill's vote over, sorry.

[Kicksave]

lynch sdm
unlunch nan
I'll finish it

[Twisted Wrister]

just woke up gonna read.

[beerman]

That was 13 with crayz's vote

write up coming

[newarenanow]

meetings are fun. :/

nan seems blue to me... Would have fought a bit more IMO if he were red. He's also a vet so unlikely to make a dumb night mistake.

I have nothing much to offer atm but I think we need to make a decision... So in that vein...

Lynch sdm. Color please.

nan, however, would be smart enough to know that a quiet defense is a lot more effective than a defense.

Or it's better just not to cause a ton of confusion when you are just a blue guy.

[tfrizz]

I feel like this is a bad move...

[bhaw]

I feel like this is a bad move...

Like I said... worst case is that he's blue. If he were a good rp, he'd have to be online to get his PMs in. According to those that looked it up, he hasn't even been around.