History Mafia -- GAME THREAD

[Letang Is The Truth]

i think it was he spoke at night coupled with the fact about what he said. i think you are reading too much into it

[Troy Loney]

I'm gonna throw this out there one more time even though it is destined to be futile...

Let's take out a quiet person who has shown us absolutely nothing. THere's little to go off of, so let's get rid of someone who won't give us anything until we say "Oh yeah, I forgot ____ was playing." Then they chime in on day 5 after everyone else has been talking for 4 days.

I just looked at the list...who would you consider quiet?

[slappybrown]

Jay is doing it because nan spoke at night, not because it was necessarily a baddie tell?

Your post seems too eager to jump on this because of a "strong" tell? Everyone is else is jumping on because...well....it's nan?

your post comes off red imo

I'm doing it because its a baddie tell.

[jaysmiter]

It actually had two baddie tells in it for me...

the "woe is me, we lost someone" tell and then the whole "deputy/seer" thing.

I mean, I could be wrong...but, I hate people trying to glean info at night.

[Kicksave]

I voted for nan because he's teh nan.

[bhaw]

I'm gonna throw this out there one more time even though it is destined to be futile...

Let's take out a quiet person who has shown us absolutely nothing. THere's little to go off of, so let's get rid of someone who won't give us anything until we say "Oh yeah, I forgot ____ was playing." Then they chime in on day 5 after everyone else has been talking for 4 days.

I just looked at the list...who would you consider quiet?

Senka, sdm, Azkar, slappy (I think), relantel, MWB - all just on first glance... will go through the thread to confirm my list...

[jaysmiter]

I don't necessarily think that you can call someone "quiet" in the game from one day. I didn't post at all day 1.

[count2infinity]

i personally think it's a little early to be voting off quiet people. the first round we had it done in a matter of hours as everyone knew THG was gone. This round has only been going for a little bit now, other than that it's all been night time.

[Corvidae]

weren't you just saying in your other post how you want to stop the same people from dying early every game

The village has always talked a good NAN lynch but seldom has NAN been lynched. Once, that I can think of.

[crayz]

weren't you just saying in your other post how you want to stop the same people from dying early every game

The village has always talked a good NAN lynch but seldom has NAN been lynched. Once, that I can think of.

truth. usually mafia gets him before the village can

[bhaw]

azkar has 2 posts: one emote and one lynch thg vote with nothing else
senka has 2 posts with no substance or votes
sdm has 0 posts
mwb has 0 posts
slappy - nix that... has posts
relantel has 2 posts: one vote for cupkeeper and one vote saying he's doing it to lynch someone other than thg

[Azkar]

[Troy Loney]

azkar has 2 posts: one emote and one lynch thg vote with nothing else
senka has 2 posts with no substance or votes
sdm has 0 posts
mwb has 0 posts
slappy - nix that... has posts
relantel has 2 posts: one vote for cupkeeper and one vote saying he's doing it to lynch someone other than thg

how many do i have

[redwill]

Yep. It's a strong tell. The best we've got this early on. Good call jaysmiter.

lynch nan

lynch redwill

Jay is doing it because nan spoke at night, not because it was necessarily a baddie tell?

Your post seems too eager to jump on this because of a "strong" tell? Everyone is else is jumping on because...well....it's nan?

your post comes off red imo

Well, jumping on immediately after a write-up (or in this case, before a write-up) to bemoan the loss of a good RP is indeed a strong mafia tell. There's no denying that.

The only problem is that it can possibly be a tell for a good RP, at least according to the mafiascum web site. However, I don't think that's the case here. nan hasn't made any attempt to claim a good role.

On a related note, why are you opposed to nan? I don't mean that as an accusation, I just want to know why you think we shouldn't go with him.

[bhaw]

I don't necessarily think that you can call someone "quiet" in the game from one day. I didn't post at all day 1.

some people have a history of being quiet. it doesn't help for us to bandwagon 3 votes just "beacuase" and then have a bunch of people who can hide under "you guys went so fast so I just haven't been able to participate."

MWB and Senka strike me as the oddest from my list of being quiet so far.

[jaysmiter]

Dude...bhaw...it is way too early to start breaking out post counts. There are probably a lot of people without a lot of posts.

[Letang Is The Truth]

5000

[newarenanow]

It actually had two baddie tells in it for me...

the "woe is me, we lost someone" tell and then the whole "deputy/seer" thing.

I mean, I could be wrong...but, I hate people trying to glean info at night.

I don't see how it was gleening info though.

I always say it sucks when a good RP gets killed or voted off. Like I said, if anyone is stupid enought to further elaborate on that, they shouldn't be part of the village.

Oh well. Like I said, the wagon is rolling though. I'm willing to vote off someone quiet too this early in the game. If people are supspicous of me later in the game, then vote me off.

I personally think I could be more help than a quiet person, but that is up to you guys.

[bhaw]

azkar has 2 posts: one emote and one lynch thg vote with nothing else
senka has 2 posts with no substance or votes
sdm has 0 posts
mwb has 0 posts
slappy - nix that... has posts
relantel has 2 posts: one vote for cupkeeper and one vote saying he's doing it to lynch someone other than thg

how many do i have

now 3

2 questioning my "quiet" thing and 1 vote for nan.

Add loney to the list

[Azkar]

What is anyone supposed to say in the first two days? I've been in class/work/sleeping a lot. There is really nothing on the table for us to work with yet.

[count2infinity]

mwb and sdm are ALWAYS quiet the first few day phases...


always...

[jaysmiter]

What is anyone supposed to say in the first two days? I've been in class/work/sleeping a lot. There is really nothing on the table for us to work with yet.

And then when there is something mild, he's wholly against it.

a lose-lose apparently.

[bhaw]

Dude...bhaw...it is way too early to start breaking out post counts. There are probably a lot of people without a lot of posts.

Dude... fine, so let's just quickly vote out 5 people and then realize we've killed 5 people and have 1/2 the village that hasn't participated. It's always made sense to get rid of people who have a history of not talking until late in the game but no one does it. Why? Because chances right now are equally good that NAN and someone like sdm are good/bad. But at least NAN will talk and we can make a determination. sdm (or someone like him) will lay low until he has to talk then pop up and we have to start fresh with him. Why are you so eager to bandwagon and end the first 3 days? With no talking, we are going to start day 3 exactly where we started day 2.

[bhaw]

mwb and sdm are ALWAYS quiet the first few day phases...


always...

exactly... they don't help the village.

[Corvidae]

azkar has 2 posts: one emote and one lynch thg vote with nothing else
senka has 2 posts with no substance or votes
sdm has 0 posts
mwb has 0 posts
slappy - nix that... has posts
relantel has 2 posts: one vote for cupkeeper and one vote saying he's doing it to lynch someone other than thg

I agree with jay that's it's way too early for post counts.

I would prefer a CK or MWB vote to NAN, as they often stay under the radar as bad guys. However, NAN is NAN.

There's a significant drop off after that.