*** JELLYFISH INVASION I GAME THREAD ***

[Malkamaniac]

What is everyone's consensus that Tfrizz was so sure PFiDC was baddie, but turned out to be good.

Him and Jaysmiter.

[Malkamaniac]

Crap -- messed up my msg above and cant edit.

Why would that be lose lose? If THG is a good RP, then laying low is a reasonable move.

I refuse to believe that he's had a role 3-4 games in a row like myself. I'm not voting for him.

I'm questioning tfrizz and jaysmiter this time.

[mac5155]

So what is the consensus on PFiDC not dying?

I think he was converted to something.. Possibly a bad rp but I doubt it.. It says in his writeup "the rest of the village went to sleep while he was out at the strip club" suggesting he can now be active at night

[slappybrown]

So what is the consensus on PFiDC not dying?

Typically a failed lynch would mean mob protection (mob doctors protect during the day, good doctors protect during the night)... but since he was just one of us, I can't see that being the case. Could it be a JOAT-type role where one of the actions prevents lynching?

First, the mob doctors thing isnt entirely accurate. In NHL Wars, we had it at night. Also why again were you so sure on him being bad?

[Hockeynut!]

I'd still like to vote out Dagny. She was one of the tipping points that got PFiDC voted out and he was innocent. And he proclamations early on really make me think she's bad. Anyone else on board?

If everyone against taking out Dagny (or wants to again wait until she can defend herself) then I think I think it's time to vote out Pavel. He was extremely defensive of Dagny yesterday and said he would be gunning for anyone who was against her, although at that point there were only 2 Dagny votes. Why fly off the handle like that when, at that point, she was clearly out of danger? Then he was jumped on the PFiDC train and even changed his vote to ensure PFiDC was voted off.

Any thoughts?

I stuck by my guns yesterday and didn't vote for PFiDC who was just a tourist. Let's try to take out a baddie today.

[tfrizz]

So what is the consensus on PFiDC not dying?

Typically a failed lynch would mean mob protection (mob doctors protect during the day, good doctors protect during the night)... but since he was just one of us, I can't see that being the case. Could it be a JOAT-type role where one of the actions prevents lynching?

First, the mob doctors thing isnt entirely accurate. In NHL Wars, we had it at night. Also why again were you so sure on him being bad?

That's true... the traditional way is mob protect at day, town protect at night.

I thought PFIDC was bad because of how defensive he got when I threw that theory out there. I suppose the same thing happened with Zarovich last game; I threw a theory out there, he got really defensive and we ended up voting out a good RP. At least in this case PFIDC was saved.

[IrishEyes]

Holy jumping the gun, Batman!

release thg

I'm exhausted, and therefore not thinking clearly.

[thehockeyguru]

I'd still like to vote out Dagny. She was one of the tipping points that got PFiDC voted out and he was innocent. And he proclamations early on really make me think she's bad. Anyone else on board?

If everyone against taking out Dagny (or wants to again wait until she can defend herself) then I think I think it's time to vote out Pavel. He was extremely defensive of Dagny yesterday and said he would be gunning for anyone who was against her, although at that point there were only 2 Dagny votes. Why fly off the handle like that when, at that point, she was clearly out of danger? Then he was jumped on the PFiDC train and even changed his vote to ensure PFiDC was voted off.

Any thoughts?

I stuck by my guns yesterday and didn't vote for PFiDC who was just a tourist. Let's try to take out a baddie today.

1. Redwill brought evidence against him and is dead
2. Pavel backs Dagny who is questionable.
3. Pavel says Sdm is bad, which turns out wrong.

Pavel is off his game or is bad

Net Pavel Bure

[tfrizz]

I'd still like to vote out Dagny. She was one of the tipping points that got PFiDC voted out and he was innocent. And he proclamations early on really make me think she's bad. Anyone else on board?

If everyone against taking out Dagny (or wants to again wait until she can defend herself) then I think I think it's time to vote out Pavel. He was extremely defensive of Dagny yesterday and said he would be gunning for anyone who was against her, although at that point there were only 2 Dagny votes. Why fly off the handle like that when, at that point, she was clearly out of danger? Then he was jumped on the PFiDC train and even changed his vote to ensure PFiDC was voted off.

Any thoughts?

I stuck by my guns yesterday and didn't vote for PFiDC who was just a tourist. Let's try to take out a baddie today.

Dagny was also the one who pushed very, very hard to save Senka on Day 1

I do agree with the possibility Pavel is bad... he is playing differently this time, and hasn't really contributed. Whether that's because of school or because he's bad, I don't know... but he isn't being very helpful for the resort in any case.

[tfrizz]

Holy jumping the gun, Batman!

release thg

I'm exhausted, and therefore not thinking clearly.

That's an awful quick change of heart there Irish...

[IrishEyes]

Holy jumping the gun, Batman!

release thg

I'm exhausted, and therefore not thinking clearly.

That's an awful quick change of heart there Irish...

I know. I don't know why I did that in the first place. Sorry if it seemed odd.

[Malkamaniac]

I know. I don't know why I did that in the first place. Sorry if it seemed odd.

In this game, apologizing for something odd is very dangerous. A slip up perhaps?

[crayz]

So what is the consensus on PFiDC not dying?

Typically a failed lynch would mean mob protection (mob doctors protect during the day, good doctors protect during the night)... but since he was just one of us, I can't see that being the case. Could it be a JOAT-type role where one of the actions prevents lynching?

I was thinking vampire role? the write up said he felt something different (forgot exact quote).....so maybe as he was voted off, he was transferred to the jellies?

[tfrizz]

I know. I don't know why I did that in the first place. Sorry if it seemed odd.

In this game, apologizing for something odd is very dangerous. A slip up perhaps?

It's a definite possibility.

[thehockeyguru]

PFinDC is an interesting case, but can someone provide some closure on NPV. Why is he still around?

[IrishEyes]

I know. I don't know why I did that in the first place. Sorry if it seemed odd.

In this game, apologizing for something odd is very dangerous. A slip up perhaps?

Nope. He noticed it, so obviously he thought it odd. Hence the apology.

If the quick vote-on, vote-off thing is enough to get me netted, oh well. I can sit here and daydream about getting some z's.

[crayz]

net kicksave

I'm still stickin with kicksave from my posts yesterday.

HE IS TEH EVIL!!!!!!!!

Spoiler:

i think

[Malkamaniac]

I know. I don't know why I did that in the first place. Sorry if it seemed odd.

In this game, apologizing for something odd is very dangerous. A slip up perhaps?

Nope. He noticed it, so obviously he thought it odd. Hence the apology.

If the quick vote-on, vote-off thing is enough to get me netted, oh well. I can sit here and daydream about getting some z's.

No chance. I'm not gonna just do a quick net in hopes of a bandwagon. We need to think logically and get a baddie this time around.

[slappybrown]

net kicksave

I'm still stickin with kicksave from my posts yesterday.

HE IS TEH EVIL!!!!!!!!

Spoiler:

i think

Kicksave and tfrizz are who I am likely to vote for.

[tfrizz]

So what is the consensus on PFiDC not dying?

Typically a failed lynch would mean mob protection (mob doctors protect during the day, good doctors protect during the night)... but since he was just one of us, I can't see that being the case. Could it be a JOAT-type role where one of the actions prevents lynching?

I was thinking vampire role? the write up said he felt something different (forgot exact quote).....so maybe as he was voted off, he was transferred to the jellies?

PFIDC didn't know why he was able to escape, but used the near death experience to gain a new perspective on life. And that new perspective was "I need to go to a strip clubs as much as possible."

Sounds like some kind of night-time role. I read about one yesterday where a villager can "leave town" every other night

[IrishEyes]

net kicksave

I'm still stickin with kicksave from my posts yesterday.

HE IS TEH EVIL!!!!!!!!

Spoiler:

i think

The thing with kicksave is that he plays the same way, whether he's good or bad, every game. He's pretty hard to get a handle on.

[wallflower]

I'm going to net canaan.

I am now convinced he is a jelly. He's been suspicious to me from the beginning and the fact that he continually jumped on my thg bandwagon (when I very much believe thg to just be a regular traveler) has convinced me.

[Kicksave]

The thing with kicksave is that he plays the same way, whether he's good or bad, every game. He's pretty hard to get a handle on.

Badly?

[crayz]

net kicksave

I'm still stickin with kicksave from my posts yesterday.

HE IS TEH EVIL!!!!!!!!

Spoiler:

i think

The thing with kicksave is that he plays the same way, whether he's good or bad, every game. He's pretty hard to get a handle on.

well, he has been bad for like 5 straight games it seems! I've done a little looking and when he is bad, he tends to push votes more and do that "village piss match" thing to diffuse a battle.

[Kicksave]

And by badly, I mean as in not having skills.