*** JELLYFISH INVASION I GAME THREAD ***

[Corvidae]

I'm going away now so someone else has to jump on the tally sticks.

[redwill]

I only agree with bandwagon votes on the first day if the player involved has proven to be a detriment to the game. That definitely does not include Senka.

On the other hand, this thg obsession has gotta end sooner or later. I guess it'll be later.

net thehockeyguru

[bhaw]

I'll be around for a write up, but I need you guys to keep track of votes plz.

kthxbi

[Juice]

Think this through my friends.
Random.org'in someone is only good when you have nothing else to go on (see: a typical day 1.)
But this is not a typical day 1. Someone in this game has already given more of a reason than a random lynch to get rid of them.
Not only are we going to net someone on a random.org, we are going to net a good player, and we are going to ignore the chance to get rid of someone who has demonstrated the inability to think through one of the proven basic game concepts.
How many times, as a baddie, when a game is over, do people have to say "something was said at night that made us change what we were going to do" before we realize how bad it is to talk at night?

net count2infinity

[crayz]

Senka is a solid player and could be valuable down the road

I debated on it for a while after I got the results. Senka IS a good player. But, it's day 1 and no evidence.

I'm holding off because of this.

for me it came down to...random is random. There is an equal chance senka is bad as THG, if actually better chance senka is bad (since THG was boss last game)

[Juice]

even if count2infinity is a good guy, we're getting rid of someone that couldn't see why what they were saying was bad. How is that a bad thing?

[wallflower]

for me it came down to...random is random. There is an equal chance senka is bad as THG, if actually better chance senka is bad (since THG was boss last game)

This is contradictory, IMO. There is an equal chance either Senka or thg are jellies (or regular travelers). Just because one was a boss game last game means nothing; wasn't Troy Loney a bad guy a couple games in a row?

[tfrizz]

Code: Select all

11 Senka (PFIDC, slappybrown, sdm5055, Malkamaniac, count2infinity, crayz, jwienand, tfrizz, MWB, Hockeynut!, beerman)
7 thehockeyguru (wallflower, Kicksave, relantel, newarenanow, canaan, mac5155, redwill)
1 jaysmiter (Azkar)
1 count2infinity (Juice)

Updated.

[Azkar]

for me it came down to...random is random. There is an equal chance senka is bad as THG, if actually better chance senka is bad (since THG was boss last game)

he's got the same chance, these two events are independent of each other

[dagny]

*yawn*

Morning guys!

(Wow! I've never seen that before! I hit submit on my post and it took me to a screen saying that at least one new post has been submitted and I may want to review my post in light of this, and it shows the new posts made. ) CRAZY!

[Azkar]

*yawn*

Morning guys!

(Wow! I've never seen that before! I hit submit on my post and it took me to a screen saying that at least one new post has been submitted and I may want to review my post in light of this, and it shows the new posts made. ) CRAZY!

same thing happened to me, it was pretty neat

[IrishEyes]

Ehhh... I don't want to get rid of senka so early. He is a good player... and could be a definite help to the vilage down the road.

net THG

I don't really want to do it, but I'm not about to try to start my own bandwagon.

[Senka]

Dont net me.

[Senka]

Dont do it, dont do it dont do it... I really assumed I wouldnt be the first one called out.

[newarenanow]

for me it came down to...random is random. There is an equal chance senka is bad as THG, if actually better chance senka is bad (since THG was boss last game)

This is contradictory, IMO. There is an equal chance either Senka or thg are jellies (or regular travelers). Just because one was a boss game last game means nothing; wasn't Troy Loney a bad guy a couple games in a row?

I know I was the angel like 3 times in 5 games once.

And I think Troy was a wolf 2 in a row (or someone was).

It is independent.

I fell bad for thehockeyguru, but I'm not ready to get rid of Senka just yet. He can do a ton more good if he is a good guy.

And once the population goes down, that is where you can look at players like him.

[Senka]

net THG

[count2infinity]

even if count2infinity is a good guy, we're getting rid of someone that couldn't see why what they were saying was bad. How is that a bad thing?

is this going to be your goal the whole game? to get me netted? i tend to think you're a very good player in this game, and i'd rather not have you blinded by what you think is a bad move on my part. i have never been a part of a game that night talk is allowed, and my thought process was that if a baddie wants to continue to be thought of as a villager, they would have to keep up with the chat and slip up eventually.

[dagny]

net thg

There's no way I'd go after Senka this early, unless I was sure, or had SOME evidence, that he's a bad guy.

Again, great idea guys, go after the active/thinking players first.

[Senka]

for the record, Im all about keeping THG around for a few days... but im not your answer. I suggest we look elsewhere.

[count2infinity]

senka is here defending himself... THG is not

release senka
net THG

[thehockeyguru]

Wait 1 sec.

[dagny]

*yawn*

Morning guys!

(Wow! I've never seen that before! I hit submit on my post and it took me to a screen saying that at least one new post has been submitted and I may want to review my post in light of this, and it shows the new posts made. ) CRAZY!

same thing happened to me, it was pretty neat

I wonder if The Gorilla set it that way, on purpose, for the games. Cuz it is quite helpful for this.

[slappybrown]

Well senka is intimating "something" so release senka

but Im not bandwagoning THG out of principle, dude should get to play

[slappybrown]

*yawn*

Morning guys!

(Wow! I've never seen that before! I hit submit on my post and it took me to a screen saying that at least one new post has been submitted and I may want to review my post in light of this, and it shows the new posts made. ) CRAZY!

same thing happened to me, it was pretty neat

I wonder if The Gorilla set it that way, on purpose, for the games. Cuz it is quite helpful for this.

Agreed, i kep trying to get it to pop up haha

[Senka]

Im suggesting a NET Malkamaniac..

THG never gets to play. have a <3.

PFIDC leading me out, whatevs.. but may I be first to suggest someone other than BOTH of us?