Hollywood Wars: Game Thread

[bhaw]

slappy... thanks for posting... you said that you want to let Malk slide then voted for him anyways.

[slappybrown]

A rational move would have been to let it play out as I stated. There was zero reason to kill off Malkamaniac. Unfortunately more than just the bad guys voted for him, but slappy (among MANY others) pushed for Malkamaniac to die for really no reason. I understand Malk had a history, but I threw out a perfectly reasonable solution that several people pushed hard against to get rid of the angel.

As I said, if you re-read, he was all over the place, and got caught in an open lie and has a history of getting out of circumstances similar to this and continuing to do damage. I dont think voting for him in those circumstances is irrational as you apparently do. I obviously wish I hadnt voted for him now knowing he is the angel.

[Zarovich]

Alright, here is why nobody died on Night 2.

I am the Lawyer for the actors. The evil RP's can only kill every other night while I'm alive. They cannot kill tonight. The new killer can. I do not know which side the new killer is on, but I'm hoping they are on the good side.

This is why I was so sure Malks was lying. I KNEW nobody could be killed night 2...

I'm putting this out there now so it can clear up why nobody died night 2.

[slappybrown]

slappy... thanks for posting... you said that you want to let Malk slide then voted for him anyways.

Right, as he continued to post as we deliberated and indicate to me he was a baddie.

[Troy Loney]

A rational move would have been to let it play out as I stated. There was zero reason to kill off Malkamaniac. Unfortunately more than just the bad guys voted for him, but slappy (among MANY others) pushed for Malkamaniac to die for really no reason. I understand Malk had a history, but I threw out a perfectly reasonable solution that several people pushed hard against to get rid of the angel.

As I said, if you re-read, he was all over the place, and got caught in an open lie and has a history of getting out of circumstances similar to this and continuing to do damage. I dont think voting for him in those circumstances is irrational as you apparently do. I obviously wish I hadnt voted for him now knowing he is the angel.

Ok....are you working with zaro & azkar, and if so in what capacity?

[slappybrown]

A rational move would have been to let it play out as I stated. There was zero reason to kill off Malkamaniac. Unfortunately more than just the bad guys voted for him, but slappy (among MANY others) pushed for Malkamaniac to die for really no reason. I understand Malk had a history, but I threw out a perfectly reasonable solution that several people pushed hard against to get rid of the angel.

As I said, if you re-read, he was all over the place, and got caught in an open lie and has a history of getting out of circumstances similar to this and continuing to do damage. I dont think voting for him in those circumstances is irrational as you apparently do. I obviously wish I hadnt voted for him now knowing he is the angel.

Ok....are you working with zaro & azkar, and if so in what capacity?

No. I dont know anything about zaro or azkar or what they are or arent, Im a villager or whatver it is this game.

[Troy Loney]

Alright, here is why nobody died on Night 2.

I am the Lawyer for the actors. The evil RP's can only kill every other night while I'm alive. They cannot kill tonight. The new killer can. I do not know which side the new killer is on, but I'm hoping they are on the good side.

This is why I was so sure Malks was lying. I KNEW nobody could be killed night 2...

I'm putting this out there now so it can clear up why nobody died night 2.

hhmm...weird...

[tfrizz]

Alright, here is why nobody died on Night 2.

I am the Lawyer for the actors. The evil RP's can only kill every other night while I'm alive. They cannot kill tonight. The new killer can. I do not know which side the new killer is on, but I'm hoping they are on the good side.

This is why I was so sure Malks was lying. I KNEW nobody could be killed night 2...

I'm putting this out there now so it can clear up why nobody died night 2.

There were 2 deaths last night -- night #4. Even if the vigilante has the option to use X number of bullets at any time, why would they kill dagny after she called out two bad RPs? I am almost positive that Kicksave was converted on night 2 - which means paparazzi kill on odd nights, and stalkers kill on even nights.

In other words... I'm not buying it.

[Senka]

ohh snapp

[sdm5055]

Alright, here is why nobody died on Night 2.

I am the Lawyer for the actors. The evil RP's can only kill every other night while I'm alive. They cannot kill tonight. The new killer can. I do not know which side the new killer is on, but I'm hoping they are on the good side.

This is why I was so sure Malks was lying. I KNEW nobody could be killed night 2...

I'm putting this out there now so it can clear up why nobody died night 2.

well that wasn't very smart to come out with it. I understand you have a few votes, but now if the new killer is bad your dead and they kill every night or they wait till next night kill you and then can kill every night

[Zarovich]

Alright, here is why nobody died on Night 2.

I am the Lawyer for the actors. The evil RP's can only kill every other night while I'm alive. They cannot kill tonight. The new killer can. I do not know which side the new killer is on, but I'm hoping they are on the good side.

This is why I was so sure Malks was lying. I KNEW nobody could be killed night 2...

I'm putting this out there now so it can clear up why nobody died night 2.

There were 2 deaths last night -- night #4. Even if the vigilante has the option to use X number of bullets at any time, why would they kill dagny after she called out two bad RPs? I am almost positive that Kicksave was converted on night 2 - which means paparazzi kill on odd nights, and stalkers kill on even nights.

In other words... I'm not buying it.

We start on night 1, tonight will be night 4...

[tfrizz]

Alright, here is why nobody died on Night 2.

I am the Lawyer for the actors. The evil RP's can only kill every other night while I'm alive. They cannot kill tonight. The new killer can. I do not know which side the new killer is on, but I'm hoping they are on the good side.

This is why I was so sure Malks was lying. I KNEW nobody could be killed night 2...

I'm putting this out there now so it can clear up why nobody died night 2.

There were 2 deaths last night -- night #4. Even if the vigilante has the option to use X number of bullets at any time, why would they kill dagny after she called out two bad RPs? I am almost positive that Kicksave was converted on night 2 - which means paparazzi kill on odd nights, and stalkers kill on even nights.

In other words... I'm not buying it.

We start on night 1, tonight will be night 4...

Night 1: Pavel_Bure was killed
Day 1: thehockeyguru was fired
Night 2: No kill
Day 2: redwill was fired
Night 3: canaan was killed
Day 3: Malkamaniac was fired
Night 4: dagny and Kicksave were killed

We're currently on Day 4, which makes tonight Night 5.

[Zarovich]

Alright, here is why nobody died on Night 2.

I am the Lawyer for the actors. The evil RP's can only kill every other night while I'm alive. They cannot kill tonight. The new killer can. I do not know which side the new killer is on, but I'm hoping they are on the good side.

This is why I was so sure Malks was lying. I KNEW nobody could be killed night 2...

I'm putting this out there now so it can clear up why nobody died night 2.

well that wasn't very smart to come out with it. I understand you have a few votes, but now if the new killer is bad your dead and they kill every night or they wait till next night kill you and then can kill every night

I feel the night 2 no killing caused a lot of confusion and I'm trying to clear it up.

[sdm5055]

Alright, here is why nobody died on Night 2.

I am the Lawyer for the actors. The evil RP's can only kill every other night while I'm alive. They cannot kill tonight. The new killer can. I do not know which side the new killer is on, but I'm hoping they are on the good side.

This is why I was so sure Malks was lying. I KNEW nobody could be killed night 2...

I'm putting this out there now so it can clear up why nobody died night 2.

There were 2 deaths last night -- night #4. Even if the vigilante has the option to use X number of bullets at any time, why would they kill dagny after she called out two bad RPs? I am almost positive that Kicksave was converted on night 2 - which means paparazzi kill on odd nights, and stalkers kill on even nights.

In other words... I'm not buying it.

well couldnt the baddies have killed dagny last night and vig killed kicksave?
zaro said they can't kill tonight but did could last night

It still seems weird since it does very much seem there is two groups of bad guys and the logical thinking is they kill on opposite nights

[Senka]

new game new twists?

[slappybrown]

So did tfrizz just bust zaro??

[tfrizz]

well couldnt the baddies have killed dagny last night and vig killed kicksave?
zaro said they can't kill tonight but did could last night

It still seems weird since it does very much seem there is two groups of bad guys and the logical thinking is they kill on opposite nights

If Zarovich is telling the truth, then no bad guys could kill on nights 2, 4, 6, etc... however there were 2 kills last night (night 4). The write up for night #2 suggests that someone had been converted - which I feel was Kicksave, since we weren't told a role type. The write up for night #3 suggested the addition of the vigilante, which was backed up by 2 kills on night #4.

[Senka]

i believe zaro. if hes alive in two days we kill him.

im stickin on danH.

[dagny]

oh yeah:

WHY CAN'T I EVER HAVE A ROLE?!?!?!?!?

[Zarovich]

[quote="tfrizz]
Night 1: Pavel_Bure was killed
Day 1: thehockeyguru was fired
Night 2: No kill
Day 2: redwill was fired
Night 3: canaan was killed
Day 3: Malkamaniac was fired
Night 4: dagny and Kicksave were killed

We're currently on Day 4, which makes tonight Night 5.[/quote]

You're right. I thought tonight was night 4... Anyways, the vig is on the good side then. If I don't get fired today or whacked tonight, then they can't kill on night 6.

[tfrizz]

[quote="tfrizz]
Night 1: Pavel_Bure was killed
Day 1: thehockeyguru was fired
Night 2: No kill
Day 2: redwill was fired
Night 3: canaan was killed
Day 3: Malkamaniac was fired
Night 4: dagny and Kicksave were killed

We're currently on Day 4, which makes tonight Night 5.

[/quote]

You're right. I thought tonight was night 4... Anyways, the vig is on the good side then. If I don't get fired today or whacked tonight, then they can't kill on night 6.[/quote][/quote]

I can believe a vigilante killed Kicksave, but there is no way I see them killing dagny. Not only did she call out two bad RPs, but they were from separate groups. After doing that, I don't see any villager taking her out.

[Zarovich]

fire cupkeeper

I still stand by there was no recruit on night 2 and the vig is on the good side.

[Senka]

the vig is always tryin to kill role playrs... or its a bad vig killin other baddies. if the killing power is random like you stated, i can see each side having a vig with very limited powers... or the serial killer is trying to eliminate all role players, is he not?? or okay -- its the good vig.

[tfrizz]

the vig is always tryin to kill role playrs... or its a bad vig killin other baddies. if the killing power is random like you stated, i can see each side having a vig with very limited powers... or the serial killer is trying to eliminate all role players, is he not?? or okay -- its the good vig.

A bad killer role would be too big of an advantage for them, but an independent killer is possible.

[Zarovich]

the vig is always tryin to kill role playrs... or its a bad vig killin other baddies. if the killing power is random like you stated, i can see each side having a vig with very limited powers... or the serial killer is trying to eliminate all role players, is he not?? or okay -- its the good vig.

I'm 100% positive the vig is on the good side because of my role.