NHL WARS I GAME THREAD

[redwill]

SORRY!!! I hit edit instead of quote!!

[slappybrown]

SORRY!!! I hit edit instead of quote!!

SUICIDED

[Malkamaniac]

As I said in my post above, I understand that we need to be careful and wait.

But I'll also put forward the odds. Presuming (just presuming) that there are 3-4 Goon left, then she is 3-4 times more likely to be Goon than the one Superstar Doctor. (If there's only one Superstar Doctor... )

This looks to me like someone is trying to do it. I enjoy people flipping out and saying "LOLZ YOUR DEFENDING HER WITH A 1 POST NUB"

Bottom line, we need a goon.

[beerman]

Personally it's not worth to vote for her until she makes her peace. I'm surprised at the people actually pushing for her to be voted, no questions asked, then figure it out after the rubble settles.

No one has done anything remotely like this.

Actually, I guess Kicksave kind of did...

EDIT!!!

[Kicksave]

Personally it's not worth to vote for her until she makes her peace. I'm surprised at the people actually pushing for her to be voted, no questions asked, then figure it out after the rubble settles.

No one has done anything remotely like this.

Actually, I guess Kicksave kind of did...

I wouldn't vote for her today, all I'm saying is it always seems she's a silent killer. I can see why Malka said what he said, though.

At this point, I don't have any strong feelings towards anyone however I wouldn't mind taking a look at Zarovich, for the reasons mentioned already. He's always around, never posts and doesn't contribute. In addition, he always seems to fly under the radar.

That's just a gut feeling at this point, nothing of substance.

[Troy Loney]

actually...i'm not voting for irish eyes...i dont think there is a goon role that can protect them from the independent or village killer.

[redwill]

actually...i'm not voting for irish eyes...i dont think there is a goon role that can protect them from the independent or village killer.

Oh, yeah. You're right. Hmm.

[redwill]

actually...i'm not voting for irish eyes...i dont think there is a goon role that can protect them from the independent or village killer.

Well, most of what I said before about IrishEyes just fell apart.

[Troy Loney]

actually...i'm not voting for irish eyes...i dont think there is a goon role that can protect them from the independent or village killer.

Well, most of what I said before about IrishEyes just fell apart.

but i can't say for sure...none of the roles we had last game could prevent a night kill...but things can change...i'd still like to hear something from IE...just to confirm.

[redwill]

There is this:

http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Godfather

which suggests that a Godfather role might sometimes be immune from night kills if there is a vig in the game.

Just an idea.

[count2infinity]

it'd certainly be helpful to know what kind of roles (not necessarily how many) were handed out at the beginning.

[PensFanInDC]

Not at work today and wont be on the cpu most of the day. A very good friend passed away yesterday morning. He was only 28.

My vote is for tfrizz because he voted with Azkar. I have nothing else to go on.

If someone in the game has my cell number, you can text me if some major evidence comes up. Thanks!

[PensFanInDC]

oops...just to be sure

Waive tfrizz

[Zarovich]

actually...i'm not voting for irish eyes...i dont think there is a goon role that can protect them from the independent or village killer.

Well, most of what I said before about IrishEyes just fell apart.

but i can't say for sure...none of the roles we had last game could prevent a night kill...but things can change...i'd still like to hear something from IE...just to confirm.

Not true about no night protection from a role last game.

waive tfrizz

I threw this out day 2 and all I got was admonishment from kicksave. I'll go with it again since it has been pointed out earlier about his vote posts.

As far as contributing, early in the game is a crapshoot and the only thing I see are people going crazy, ie THG, when there name is brought up. It is better to put a name out and see what happens. If you are not a good rp, just take one for the team. I don't post much because I am just looking for vote patterns and what other people say.

I do like that you guys are starting to think I'm a silent killer lol. I've been a RP the previous 3 games. A break is nice.

[Zarovich]

Waive tfrizz

color fail. I'm on my phone. sorry....

[redwill]

Not true about no night protection from a role last game.

Only from a roleblocker, right? Last game it was slappybrown as the JOAT.

[tfrizz]

waive tfrizz

Just going back through the last couple of day patterns, and tfrizz is the only one I can garner any suspicion for. In the Senka vote, he switched over towards the very end. Same with the THG vote. That's a nice way to show that you are just "going with the flow" when a superstar is offed.

He did not vote for Azkar...I know normally goons will go ahead and switch over to sacrifice their own, but I can't see them doing that with Azkar. The seer is a huge role to lose. While I believe tfrizz is extremely suspicious (hence why I am voting), I don't think we can ignore the other players that didn't vote for Azkar.

His votes:

jwienand (superstar): jumped on the bandwagon
Senka (superstar): jumped on right at the end
Azkar (goon detective): did not vote for him
THG (superstar): switched over from redwill at the last second to THG, with what I thought was kind of a weak reason to switch. I believe that since he knew redwill and THG were BOTH superstars, it would make him look good if he refused to join the THG bandwagon right away.

Not the best reasoning I have had, just my gut feeling.

oops...just to be sure

Waive tfrizz

Didn't you guys lead the votes against Senka and thehockeyguru as well?

[slappybrown]

COUNT

tfrizz - 3 (shaf, pfidc, zaro)

8 to waive.

[tfrizz]

Didn't you guys lead the votes against Senka and thehockeyguru as well?

That and we might as well kiss our butts goodbye. We'll be lynched by the village if we are wrong.

I don't think so...kinda like Senka, everyone was pretty much in general agreement about this. Although you and I both got the ball rolling on Senka as well

[Troy Loney]

waive tfrizz

We don't have a ton to go on....but if we look at the azkar vote, he's the most suspicious.

[sdm5055]

waive cupkeeper

I have been on him since day 1 and i am sticking with it he is goon

[slappybrown]

COUNT

tfrizz - 4 (shaf, pfidc, zaro, troy)
cupkeeper - 1 (sdm)

8 to waive.

[shafnutz05]

I will wholeheartedly admit that I flubbed the Senka vote. But I think you will be hardpressed to find one person in this game that didn't think Senka was acting in a bizarre manner. He is normally dead-on when picking out goons, but this game he was making bizarre vote selections and kind of staying in the shadows (in addition to a comment that appeared to be protecting Azkar). I will 100% take the responsibility for that...

As far as THG goes, the writing was on the wall with him a long time before he ever got voted off. Other people have called you out long before I cast the vote. There is simply no one else I can see as being a goon (at least right now). Who do YOU think we should vote for?

[count2infinity]

so are we just chalking up redwill/thg thing to a villager vs. villager fight?

[shafnutz05]

so are we just chalking up redwill/thg thing to a villager vs. villager fight?

For now? I am