NHL WARS I GAME THREAD

[count2infinity]

with suspicion still on cup keeper... i got my eye on you pal...

[thehockeyguru]

I'd bet my life (Mafia Wars) that Redwill is a Goon.

Waive Redwill

[Malkamaniac]

and yet again, THG goes after redwill.

[Kicksave]

waive thehockeyguru

[Kicksave]

thehockeyguru - 5 (Kicskave, count2infinity, Troy Loney, shafnutz05, PensFaninDC)
redwill - 1 (thehockeyguru)

[shafnutz05]

lol the redwill obsession is disturbing....redwill hasn't been around too terribly much would like to hear his imput.

And yeah, cup keeper is still very much on my radar....he has made some goony statements, and been around MUCH more than he has in previous games

[count2infinity]

what if... and i'm just saying, what if. THG is the village seer? what if he is casting his vote on redwill because he knows that redwill is a very very bad bad guy? just a thought to take into consideration. My vote is still on him, but thought i would bring that up quick.

[thehockeyguru]

Ouch. Looks like we have a few "Goons" amongst that five.

[thehockeyguru]

Shaf- you were terribly wrong about Senka, who I didn't vote for. Who is going to believe you when I'm gone?

[count2infinity]

since we can't edit.. that last line should read "thought i should bring that up real quick" meaning before this vote is completely cast...

[Troy Loney]

what if... and i'm just saying, what if. THG is the village seer? what if he is casting his vote on redwill because he knows that redwill is a very very bad bad guy? just a thought to take into consideration. My vote is still on him, but thought i would bring that up quick.

Then he'd be dead by now.

[Kicksave]

what if... and i'm just saying, what if. THG is the village seer? what if he is casting his vote on redwill because he knows that redwill is a very very bad bad guy? just a thought to take into consideration. My vote is still on him, but thought i would bring that up quick.

Then he'd be dead by now.

Exactly. How he's stayed alive this long...there can only be one reason.

[Troy Loney]

what if... and i'm just saying, what if. THG is the village seer? what if he is casting his vote on redwill because he knows that redwill is a very very bad bad guy? just a thought to take into consideration. My vote is still on him, but thought i would bring that up quick.

Why would azkar (goon) have voted for redwill earlier in the game?

[count2infinity]

what if... and i'm just saying, what if. THG is the village seer? what if he is casting his vote on redwill because he knows that redwill is a very very bad bad guy? just a thought to take into consideration. My vote is still on him, but thought i would bring that up quick.

Then he'd be dead by now.

are you sure... the village is pretty much always on his case... goons figured they'd get a cheap kill and go after someone else instead? just spit balling here...

[shafnutz05]

Then he'd be dead by now.

Hmm....would he? This is an interesting question. Is he protected? That's a huge IF, but something you would have to consider.

And THG, I admit being 100% wrong about Senka. However, I think a lot of superstars agreed with me on that him. He was acting MUCH more differently than usual, and casting some bizarre votes.

[tfrizz]

Well. Here is my thinking..

slappybrown on Wed Dec 02, 2009 12:06 pm
redwill - 2 (azkar, tfrizz)

Azkar was killed that day and turned out to be a goon.

And then this vote the following day from THG.

thehockeyguru on Thu Dec 03, 2009 9:24 am

My dieing words are going to be:

Waive Redwill

Cant change that now.

He wants to vote off someone who was voted on by a goon. No Bueno!

Waive THG

and tfrizz is on my radar too.

I used the same reasoning then as I am using now:

waive redwill

As confusing as THG has been... I still feel like he's an independent RP and has something "extra?" on redwill. If this turns out to be wrong, and THG is a goon... then I guess I've got more to learn about reading players in the game.

[shafnutz05]

Why would azkar (goon) have voted for redwill earlier in the game?

This is a great point.

[count2infinity]

THG could also be the preist and saving his own backside every RP vote

[shafnutz05]

My only concern is that the goons have tried to kill redwill already, been unsuccessful, and realized that he was some type of RP that cannot be killed by a goon vig (or something similar). Knowing that, they realized the only way to kill him is through a daytime vote. As count2infinity said, I am throwing spitballs here, but if they know that he is an RP they can't kill at night, it makes sense for them to push hard on him in the daytime.

[PensFanInDC]

by thehockeyguru on Wed Dec 02, 2009 10:56 am

I am interested to see how night time plays out with both Redwill and I around

And let us not forget the PM incident...

And then there is this...

Me thinks that Azkar in trying to save his own backside switched his vote for a "Goon" (Redwill) in hopes of making himself look good if a vote came down on Redwill.

by Azkar on Wed Dec 02, 2009 10:10 am

said: waive redwill

slappybrown on Wed Dec 02, 2009 12:06 pm

Count

Azkar - 12 (pavel, redwil, pfidc, malks, mwb, shaf, troy, jaysmiter, THG, count2, kicksave, irisheyes)
THG - 1 (mac)
cupkeeper -1 (sdm)
JS - 1 (senka)
tfrizz - 1 (zaro)
redwill - 2 (azkar, tfrizz)

LIMIT REACHED WRITE UP COMING...

I think he would have switched to a goon much later then he did if it was to distract voters.

[beerman]

I went back to look at the Azkar vote to see if anything would stand out. At 9-3 in favor of Azkar, Azkar had his vote in for redwill, IE and tfrizz also had their votes in for redwill.

The last 4 votes for Azkar's waiving were THG, count2infinity, kicksave (switched over at the end), IE (switched to "go with the majority").

People who didn't vote for Azkar and are still alive: myself, mac, sdm, zaro, tfrizz, and cup keeper.

So IE had a vote with Azkar and was a late switch to end it, tfrizz was voting along with Azkar and never voted for him. THG was a late vote and has been suspicous throughout, my vote would go with one of those 3 right now.

[PensFanInDC]

I went back to look at the Azkar vote to see if anything would stand out. At 9-3 in favor of Azkar, Azkar had his vote in for redwill, IE and tfrizz also had their votes in for redwill.

The last 4 votes for Azkar's waiving were THG, count2infinity, kicksave (switched over at the end), IE (switched to "go with the majority").

People who didn't vote for Azkar and are still alive: myself, mac, sdm, zaro, tfrizz, and cup keeper.

So IE had a vote with Azkar and was a late switch to end it, tfrizz was voting along with Azkar and never voted for him. THG was a late vote and has been suspicous throughout, my vote would go with one of those 3 right now.

Ah ha...This actually goes with THGs theory that Azkar switched to a goon in order to look good.

Hmmm...Couldnt THG have done the same exact thing?

[Malkamaniac]

Personally it's still way to early to get a deciding vote. THG is certainly at the top of my list, as it seems most others, but I'm unwilling to throw the vote in until it seems as if everyone's cool.

This whole redwill/thg really is distracting the group to be honest. It's too much confusion and in the long run will not help the group.

[tfrizz]

I went back to look at the Azkar vote to see if anything would stand out. At 9-3 in favor of Azkar, Azkar had his vote in for redwill, IE and tfrizz also had their votes in for redwill.

The last 4 votes for Azkar's waiving were THG, count2infinity, kicksave (switched over at the end), IE (switched to "go with the majority").

People who didn't vote for Azkar and are still alive: myself, mac, sdm, zaro, tfrizz, and cup keeper.

So IE had a vote with Azkar and was a late switch to end it, tfrizz was voting along with Azkar and never voted for him. THG was a late vote and has been suspicous throughout, my vote would go with one of those 3 right now.

I wasn't "voting along with Azkar". I was following THG under the same belief I posted above. I just looked back and saw that after I voted, THG changed to Azkar... if I had seen that before, I may have changed my mind as well.

[thehockeyguru]

My only concern is that the goons have tried to kill redwill already, been unsuccessful, and realized that he was some type of RP that cannot be killed by a goon vig (or something similar). Knowing that, they realized the only way to kill him is through a daytime vote. As count2infinity said, I am throwing spitballs here, but if they know that he is an RP they can't kill at night, it makes sense for them to push hard on him in the daytime.

If the only way to kill him was during a day phase then why am I the only person to press on Redwill. And since I keep doing it the only other person to be suspicious of him, Troy Loney, has turned on me. Last round Loney saw my point and withdrew his vote on me, now he is quick to vote on me again?

Makes no sense.