** SLUG WARZ III - GAME THREAD **

[newarenanow]

mac - 5 (nan, Zarovich, Troy, Malkamaniac, Senka)
crayz - 1 (beerman)
Zarovich - 1 (crayz)

[mac5155]

im here dont salt me (yet). on page 60 catching up

[crayz]

um...MWB, before we go anywhere....Can you explain this...

crayz - 5 (Troy, slappy, beerman, mwb, Malk)
Mac - 1 (nan)
Zaro - 1 (crayz)

This is today's earlier vote. If you KNEW I was safe...why would you salt me?

[MWB]

The thing holding me back on mac is that is in the dan h / pavel vote he switched to Pavel very late to tie it. However, that was before Pavel voted, so he still had the chance to put dan ahead.

[newarenanow]

i meant to say that you were the first person i trusted....then recently malk and nan....those were the only people that trusted.

I actually thought you were the gardener.

That is why I put my blind faith in your for the Senka vote and didn't change it to cupkeeper even though he was high on my list. It seemed like you knew something and was trying to push it w/o pushing too hard.

And that's why I ultimately checked on you.... since you didn't switch your vote to ck I thought you suspicious.

Yeah, I thought that was going to get me in trouble, but I felt strongly that Troy was the gardener, and he was pushing Senka. So I went with it, knowing cupkeeper could have gotten it in the next round.

I didn't check in until the next morning though and it got closer than I ever thought it would.

[Senka]

wait a second -- ?

[MWB]

um...MWB, before we go anywhere....Can you explain this...

crayz - 5 (Troy, slappy, beerman, mwb, Malk)
Mac - 1 (nan)
Zaro - 1 (crayz)

This is today's earlier vote. If you KNEW I was safe...why would you salt me?

I put either the first or second vote on you. I wanted to get discussion going on, then it just snowballed, which is why i unsalted you so quickly. I was trying to see who else would go for you.

[newarenanow]

unsalt mac

For now.

[Senka]

crayz was cleared by mwb...

we have a 50% chance right now..

mac, senka, zarovich & slappy are the only potential slugs

Yes, hence why I posted read fail lol

where did that quote come from?? and why arent you on this list??

[slappybrown]

So, the question is...Who is the alpha? Zaro or Mac? I think Zaro. We need to get the alpha before they recruit and really f things up. At that point it will be like a new game because we have nothing to really go on.

Question - Can the alpha kill someone AND make a recruit? Or can they do one or the other that night? If so, mwb needs to check out zaro or mac, see who is alpha...If they recruit, we will at least have one slug name for sure and know if they are the alpha or not....if not, they can't recruit and we have a 50/50 shot of getting the alpha?

Alpha can only do one or the other.

P.S. Stop pushing for Zaro. You're really coming across as trying to deflect in my eyes.

crayz was cleared by mwb...

we have a 50% chance right now..

mac, senka, zarovich & slappy are the only potential slugs

And Malk I believe.

[newarenanow]

mac - 4 (Zarovich, Troy, Malkamaniac, Senka)
crayz - 1 (beerman)
Zarovich - 1 (crayz)

[Senka]

unsalt Mac.

[crayz]

Someone unsalt until we figure this out....

This MWB thing is a bit confusing.....He salted me earlier while he knew I was innocent. He listed out his "safe people" and no slugs. That gives us 4 players left.

Let's say we vote off mac and we are wrong and alpha recruits someone. We still believe MWB cause it was a 25% chance Mac was bad. That buys him another night and possibly another pick. We could go from 11 total down to 8 with an alpha and 2 slugs left and a seer we aren't 100% about.

[MWB]

Troy trusts malk, but he isn't cleared. I've gotta say, I trust him also, but that could be dangerous I guess.

[Troy Loney]

And Malk I believe.

He's clear in my mind...thats from going back and investigating the pavel & cupkeeper votes.

[Malkamaniac]

crayz was cleared by mwb...

we have a 50% chance right now..

mac, senka, zarovich & slappy are the only potential slugs

Yes, hence why I posted read fail lol

where did that quote come from?? and why arent you on this list??

I'm not on the list because I wasn't looked at? Quote came from last troy loney post?

[mac5155]

ok. so is MWB realy the gardener? dang. wish he would have cleared me because im blue.

[Troy Loney]

Someone unsalt until we figure this out....

This MWB thing is a bit confusing.....He salted me earlier while he knew I was innocent. He listed out his "safe people" and no slugs. That gives us 4 players left.

Let's say we vote off mac and we are wrong and alpha recruits someone. We still believe MWB cause it was a 25% chance Mac was bad. That buys him another night and possibly another pick. We could go from 11 total down to 8 with an alpha and 2 slugs left and a seer we aren't 100% about.

He used it to get information about the people still in the game...he also made sure that you didnt get salted...he asked people to pull off of you.

[MWB]

This MWB thing is a bit confusing.....He salted me earlier while he knew I was innocent.
.

Read above as to why I did this. I was hoping to get some info before I came out. I was planning in doing it during this phase since we've got a good numbers advantage. However, before I came out I wanted to see if we could see some voting patterns on todays vote. I tried it with nan yesterday but not much happened.

[mac5155]

i find it awful convenient that every single person he's researched are still in the game.... aside from the 2 slugs we killed...

[crayz]

But when he came out...Mac had 3 votes and was leading. If that stayed as was, mac would be gone (just like current vote) and he would still be safe for another night.

MWB - Why would you come out when the vote was already against one of the slugs?

I'm not saying I don't believe you at all, but just some odd timing and very coincidental that out of the 11 people you had 6 villagers and neither of the slugs.

maybe i'm over-analyzing too much i guess

[slappybrown]

i find it awful convenient that every single person he's researched are still in the game.... aside from the 2 slugs we killed...

If we believe MWB to be the gardener, then this post is slugtown.

[Malkamaniac]

i find it awful convenient that every single person he's researched are still in the game.... aside from the 2 slugs we killed...

This round is even more confusing.

[newarenanow]

Here are the five people that aren't cleared:

- Malkamaniac
- slappybrown
- mac
- Senka
- Zarovich

Two are slugs. We have a 40% chance of getting one. Let's go from this.

[slappybrown]

i find it awful convenient that every single person he's researched are still in the game.... aside from the 2 slugs we killed...

If we believe MWB to be the gardener, then this post is slugtown.