Ok....i'm back on board with this right now...around page 37 or so he said a couple of things that seem real suspicious...i feel like his identity is important to know right now.newarenanow wrote:Unless someone else convinces me otherwise, I'm sticking with mac this round.
He is been on my list for like 3 rounds now.
I genuinely have no idea who to vote for. I still have a dags suspicion, but she has moved down my list.newarenanow wrote:mac - 3 (nan, Zarovich, Troy)
crayz - 1 (beerman)
Zarovich - 1 (crayz)
NAN - 1 (Senka)
MWB wrote:Ok, I've gone back and forth for awhile about this, but I think it's most beneficial to come out now. I'm the Garderner
I found the following things:
Night 1. Pavel Bure. Researched him first because he was the new guy and experienced. Wanted to know if he could be trusted. When he started being more aggressive with his posts on Day 2 I started pushing harder for him.
Night 2. crayz. Was curious about some of the quieter ones and he said something that stuck out.
Night 3. beerman. Wasnt posting much so wanted to make sure he wasn't a slug again.
Night 4. Troy Loney. Came under a lot of suspicion and was very active. Wanted to know if he could be trusted.
Night 5. cup keeper. He was getting some heat along with Troy when Pavel came out. I really though Pavel had a reason for his timing so I checked on ck. That's why I was pushing so hard to get him salted the next day.
Night 6. dagny. Wasn't sure what to think of her.
Night 7. NAN. Waited a while for him because I really thought he was okay, but then talked myself into being suspicious because he was so under the radar.
Sorry I didn't find more slugs, but thought it was important to get it out now knowing that we've got 6 trusted villagers right now. It will be 5 after tonight, but no one will be recruited I assume, so they will stay trusted for another day.
Thank you for posting this. Let's get this finished! Wish you could of got more slugs but you cleared some namesMWB wrote:Ok, I've gone back and forth for awhile about this, but I think it's most beneficial to come out now. I'm the Garderner
I found the following things:
Night 1. Pavel Bure. Researched him first because he was the new guy and experienced. Wanted to know if he could be trusted. When he started being more aggressive with his posts on Day 2 I started pushing harder for him.
Night 2. crayz. Was curious about some of the quieter ones and he said something that stuck out.
Night 3. beerman. Wasnt posting much so wanted to make sure he wasn't a slug again.
Night 4. Troy Loney. Came under a lot of suspicion and was very active. Wanted to know if he could be trusted.
Night 5. cup keeper. He was getting some heat along with Troy when Pavel came out. I really though Pavel had a reason for his timing so I checked on ck. That's why I was pushing so hard to get him salted the next day.
Night 6. dagny. Wasn't sure what to think of her.
Night 7. NAN. Waited a while for him because I really thought he was okay, but then talked myself into being suspicious because he was so under the radar.
Sorry I didn't find more slugs, but thought it was important to get it out now knowing that we've got 6 trusted villagers right now. It will be 5 after tonight, but no one will be recruited I assume, so they will stay trusted for another day.
Mac and zaro are atop my list.Troy Loney wrote: 1. Mac
2. Senka
3. Zarovich
4. Beerman
Interesting...Not 100% sure I believe him, but it seems legit. I would have rather another night...I guess we will no for sure tonight if it is him or not. In the meantime, the 2 people not on his safe list are mac & zaro...We can grab either of those tonight.MWB wrote:Ok, I've gone back and forth for awhile about this, but I think it's most beneficial to come out now. I'm the Garderner
I found the following things:
Night 1. Pavel Bure. Researched him first because he was the new guy and experienced. Wanted to know if he could be trusted. When he started being more aggressive with his posts on Day 2 I started pushing harder for him.
Night 2. crayz. Was curious about some of the quieter ones and he said something that stuck out.
Night 3. beerman. Wasnt posting much so wanted to make sure he wasn't a slug again.
Night 4. Troy Loney. Came under a lot of suspicion and was very active. Wanted to know if he could be trusted.
Night 5. cup keeper. He was getting some heat along with Troy when Pavel came out. I really though Pavel had a reason for his timing so I checked on ck. That's why I was pushing so hard to get him salted the next day.
Night 6. dagny. Wasn't sure what to think of her.
Night 7. NAN. Waited a while for him because I really thought he was okay, but then talked myself into being suspicious because he was so under the radar.
Sorry I didn't find more slugs, but thought it was important to get it out now knowing that we've got 6 trusted villagers right now. It will be 5 after tonight, but no one will be recruited I assume, so they will stay trusted for another day.
Alpha can only do one or the other.So, the question is...Who is the alpha? Zaro or Mac? I think Zaro. We need to get the alpha before they recruit and really f things up. At that point it will be like a new game because we have nothing to really go on.
Question - Can the alpha kill someone AND make a recruit? Or can they do one or the other that night? If so, mwb needs to check out zaro or mac, see who is alpha...If they recruit, we will at least have one slug name for sure and know if they are the alpha or not....if not, they can't recruit and we have a 50/50 shot of getting the alpha?
Well, at least you did an excellent job of finding the remaining villagers!MWB wrote:Ok, I've gone back and forth for awhile about this, but I think it's most beneficial to come out now. I'm the Garderner
I found the following things:
Night 1. Pavel Bure. Researched him first because he was the new guy and experienced. Wanted to know if he could be trusted. When he started being more aggressive with his posts on Day 2 I started pushing harder for him.
Night 2. crayz. Was curious about some of the quieter ones and he said something that stuck out.
Night 3. beerman. Wasnt posting much so wanted to make sure he wasn't a slug again.
Night 4. Troy Loney. Came under a lot of suspicion and was very active. Wanted to know if he could be trusted.
Night 5. cup keeper. He was getting some heat along with Troy when Pavel came out. I really though Pavel had a reason for his timing so I checked on ck. That's why I was pushing so hard to get him salted the next day.
Night 6. dagny. Wasn't sure what to think of her.
Night 7. NAN. Waited a while for him because I really thought he was okay, but then talked myself into being suspicious because he was so under the radar.
Sorry I didn't find more slugs, but thought it was important to get it out now knowing that we've got 6 trusted villagers right now. It will be 5 after tonight, but no one will be recruited I assume, so they will stay trusted for another day.
oh wait...nevermind...i missed that you had beerman on your safe list...MWB wrote:Mac and zaro are atop my list.Troy Loney wrote: 1. Mac
2. Senka
3. Zarovich
4. Beerman
slappybrown wrote:I sat back to see who would be the first to vote. The fact that Troy and Malk voted for mac immediately gives me a little bit of suspicion, but not enough to vote them right now.
yea that was epic, i was like wtf??!Malkamaniac wrote:lol read fail by me.
Sorry crayz.
I actually thought you were the gardener.Troy Loney wrote:i meant to say that you were the first person i trusted....then recently malk and nan....those were the only people that trusted.
crayz was cleared by mwb...Malkamaniac wrote:Alpha can only do one or the other.So, the question is...Who is the alpha? Zaro or Mac? I think Zaro. We need to get the alpha before they recruit and really f things up. At that point it will be like a new game because we have nothing to really go on.
Question - Can the alpha kill someone AND make a recruit? Or can they do one or the other that night? If so, mwb needs to check out zaro or mac, see who is alpha...If they recruit, we will at least have one slug name for sure and know if they are the alpha or not....if not, they can't recruit and we have a 50/50 shot of getting the alpha?
P.S. Stop pushing for Zaro. You're really coming across as trying to deflect in my eyes.
I was wondering about that. I figured you just meant beerman for later after recruitment had happened.Troy Loney wrote:oh wait...nevermind...i missed that you had beerman on your safe list...MWB wrote:Mac and zaro are atop my list.Troy Loney wrote: 1. Mac
2. Senka
3. Zarovich
4. Beerman
And that's why I ultimately checked on you.... since you didn't switch your vote to ck I thought you suspicious.newarenanow wrote:I actually thought you were the gardener.Troy Loney wrote:i meant to say that you were the first person i trusted....then recently malk and nan....those were the only people that trusted.
That is why I put my blind faith in your for the Senka vote and didn't change it to cupkeeper even though he was high on my list. It seemed like you knew something and was trying to push it w/o pushing too hard.
Yes, hence why I posted read fail lolcrayz was cleared by mwb...
we have a 50% chance right now..
mac, senka, zarovich & slappy are the only potential slugs