One other potential thought - the slugs don't know who the gardner is, they did just muff night 2....but they do know that Pavel is neither slug nor gardener because one of the people he says he researched, and said is a villager is actually a slug?Juice wrote:you have the opportunity to kill the villages last rp, and you pass on it hoping the village kills the rp themselves? monumentally stupid if that's the case...
Juice wrote:ok... let's think about this in terms of what we gain the most.
if we let pavel live today, and he's the gardener, the slugs kill him tonight. what do we gain? i guess we would give ourselves a shot at getting an actual slug today.
if we kill pavel today, and he's the gardener, it wouldn't matter because they're going to kill him tonight and he won't get to tell us who he researched.
if we kill pavel today, and he's a slug, we're awesome.
1) We may get an actual slug today or he can clear another villagerJuice wrote:ok... let's think about this in terms of what we gain the most.
if we let pavel live today, and he's the gardener, the slugs kill him tonight. what do we gain? i guess we would give ourselves a shot at getting an actual slug today.
if we kill pavel today, and he's the gardener, it wouldn't matter because they're going to kill him tonight and he won't get to tell us who he researched.
if we kill pavel today, and he's a slug, we're awesome.
I'm with you. I'm not voting for him today at all.Malkamaniac wrote:If Pavel scoped someone last night and he says its a slug, take that named player down. If Pavel is right he lives the next day, if he's wrong he dies. Simple as that. Vote on him after this next night phase and see what happens.
Yeah...I HATE the fact that it's Friday today! If I could, I would rewind the clock to Wednesday. Granted, there would be two more days of work again, but we could get this resolved!!newarenanow wrote:This sucks that this had to happen on Friday! Why couldn't this be mid week.
Blasphemy....I'm totally content revisiting this on monday...totally something to look forward to when i begrudgingly make my way in monday morning.shafnutz05 wrote:Yeah...I HATE the fact that it's Friday today! If I could, I would rewind the clock to Wednesday. Granted, there would be two more days of work again, but we could get this resolved!!newarenanow wrote:This sucks that this had to happen on Friday! Why couldn't this be mid week.
while trying not to reveal themself.I just saw that too. Awesome catch. Defnitely something to think about.dagny wrote:After posting my last post, I see one post unaware that Pavel claimed to be the gardener, and one asking to see the post where he claimed that.
I reiterate my mentioning of the Alpha not following the thread, thus not knowing Pavel outed himself, if he's the real gardener.
Also, possibility of "real" gardener (should Pavel not be), asking wtf?
I remember the post of him clearing names.Can you direct me to this?shafnutz05 wrote:wait, nevermind, I just found it.......WOW. I don't believe for a second that the slugs would let Pavel go if he was the seer. I am 100% sure he is a slug....at the same time, I am 95% sure he is just a lil slooger. The question isn't whether or not he is the seer. The question is, is it worth keeping Pavel the slug around (and not take anything he says seriously)? i don't want to waste a valuable vote on kicking off a known slooger.
I'll jump on board with you. I also brought up beerman about a page or so back, pretty much saying the same thing as you.Senka wrote:After thinking on this, Ive come to the conclusion im salting TroyLoney today for a few reasons.
Was bent on DanH first vote, and with a coinflip being decided with him alive, the following night, He did NOT vote for DanH this time, but instead, did not vote at all. Ive just been following so far and ive noticed 2 things: All his responses either introduce a "possible" idea or are pretty neutral. Being in the action, but not putting his head out there. After packing heat on DanH he followed it up without voting at all... Instead he had a vote logged on Bure, which im still curious about, and then took it off...Maybe up to this point i was wrong with PFIDC & maybe SDM, but I was against the DanH vote.
*Its just a theory but this one sticks with me. 2 games ago i said "i bet my game on it that MWB was a slug", yet i got very little support and im not as confident, but I feel as if im right. Ive kept with SDM through 2, although if i was around I probably wouldve changed it..
Spoiler:
Here you goPavel Bure wrote:Alright I said I wasn't gonna do this unless the vote was locked into a coin flip situation and I guess it's my fault for being so active. I was of the whole "hide in plain sight" thought process. Especially after the first two role players went down so fast. I'm guessing the slugs tried to recruit me last night and failed hence the no kill. I am the seer.
Night 1 - I investigated NAN cause well I've never played this game and it was a shot in the dark for me. NAN is town.
Night 2 - I investigated Juice since he was pushing for Dan without reason. Juice is also town.
Sorry guys, should have just taken my own advice and sat back. From what I've done today I think Troy Loney and Dagny are clear as well. I was going to investigate MWB tonight but even if he isn't a slug I'm dead. There's the info. Sorry I suck but I didn't want to risk a coin flip.