Zarovich wrote:I think we are going to sit here for another 2 and a hlaf hours and then Dagny or JC will get salted....
I'm trying to get some discussion going here, but it seems either no one is around or nobody wants to say anything or make any decisions.
Not much too discuss. JC may or may not be the gardener. Those who think he isn't are still voting for him, those who think he is, pulled the votes out. Dagny is being let go for being an intelligent thinker who can help the village, or the slugs if she is one. CupKeeper is in the same position as Dagny was, a random brought up salt. Then CK brought up the village would be sorry if we commenced salting. So that pulled him off.
I voted Neo because he had tons of posts last game and only 1 this game. Could be an RP, could be a slug or could be nothing. I'm not gonna push for a salting at this point. Not much to go on and eventually we will out all the RP's and have made the slugs job easy...
crayz wrote:if as a village we decide lets just move on someone and if we screw up we screw up...that's fine, but not enough are saying thats what they want.
in class writing on my phone so i hope this makes sense
yeah, I've been saying this all day which is why I'm not changing my vote anymore, it's pointless
I don't like the dagny vote and I'm not convinced that both JC and CK are both RPs. I know that doesn't help move things along and I'm not even going to bother voicing any ideas since most of the people are out for the day and I don't want to get devoured.
Well what if Jose is the gardener, it seems rather risky to just vote him off because a couple people think he's lying. I'm not 100% sold on the theory that he's the gardener but if he is I don't want to have a hand in voting him out either.
crayz wrote:at this point i'd rather lose JC than dagny...so if in another hour it's still a close vote, I will vote JC so auto-vote doesn't get dagny.
what about jc is making everyone suspicious? At least tell me that much, I haven't seen anything from him or well from anybody to be honest.
Jc and Dagny just throw votes back and forth at one another, if anything they're probably both innocent, but we don't need them to be in a pissing match back and forth all game, so let's get one of em.
the wicked child wrote:So I see 2 possibilities with JC...
1) He actually is the gardener
2) He is a slug and it is an attempt to throw us off the case and/or force the real gardener to reveal themselves.
whadda ya think?
I think it's very early for a slug to off himself by claiming to be the gardener. However, it was also early in the vote to say you're the gardener. Bottom line, I don't know what to think.