well you've been on an awesome run! unsalt Canaan. and if its a ploy to get out, im sure justice will be dealt. regardless, im unsalting you
Im salting TROYLONEY. its a good hunch of mine. i feel like troy is the one playing the nice slug.
he might be lying you know!!!
well do you wanna take that chance? if we salt him and he lied, then we saved the bird a nom. if we're wrong, then we cost us the bird and took his nom. Not that i trust you... just saying...
on the flipside... i looked back a while back and im confident in revealing my next tier of candidates...
This includes SOLIDSNAKE, TROYLONEY, and NPV. and on the brim of it is PFIDC. cause I feel i dismissed him on not enough info.
well do you wanna take that chance? if we salt him and he lied, then we saved the bird a nom. if we're wrong, then we cost us the bird and took his nom. Not that i trust you... just saying...
on the flipside... i looked back a while back and im confident in revealing my next tier of candidates...
This includes SOLIDSNAKE, TROYLONEY, and NPV. and on the brim of it is PFIDC. cause I feel i dismissed him on not enough info.
no...i'd just rather someone besides me get salted..
we should lay off him, and if he is lying the real bird will eat him tonight
Senka wrote:Canaan, i suggest you kill PFIDC tonight... i think its a wise choice. What you thinkin tho?
i've followed you since it became apparent what your role is i tried to push PFIDC out a couple of "days" ago, but it didnt gain any steam and i've backed off of my suspicions. i honestly have no clue.
Senka wrote:Canaan, i suggest you kill PFIDC tonight... i think its a wise choice. What you thinkin tho?
If you wanna wack a villager...go ahead
I'll unsalt jay as that seems to not be unified with the village. I'm willing to go with the majority here since it seems I will be birded this evening.
I agree, Canaan is most probably telling the truth. If he were a regular villager, he'd have no reason to claim to be the bird at this point - even if he "baited" the slugs away from the real bird, he'd also bait the real bird away from the slugs. If he were a slug, claiming to be the bird would out himself. If he thought he was going to go anyway, that might make some sort of sense - maybe then the slugs could get the real bird with a salt vote today, and make us spend tomorrow on Canaan - but scenarios like that don't sound that likely to me. The best path at the moment seems to be to trust him, and if he's lying, it will become obvious tonight.
Dan H wrote:I agree, Canaan is most probably telling the truth. If he were a regular villager, he'd have no reason to claim to be the bird at this point - even if he "baited" the slugs away from the real bird, he'd also bait the real bird away from the slugs. If he were a slug, claiming to be the bird would out himself. If he thought he was going to go anyway, that might make some sort of sense - maybe then the slugs could get the real bird with a salt vote today, and make us spend tomorrow on Canaan - but scenarios like that don't sound that likely to me. The best path at the moment seems to be to trust him, and if he's lying, it will become obvious tonight.
well since we're all out in the open why not plan this together. Like last game malkimaniac discussed with us who he was killing. My vote is to kill PFIDC, cause hes the only one on my NOT SURE list right now. but where did canaan go?
i tried to push PFIDC out a couple of "days" ago, but it didnt gain any steam and i've backed off of my suspicions. i honestly have no clue.
