This adds more to the confusion. It would seem that you are the sexta, or you're a slug saying maybe you're the sexta to stay off the vote line. Or you're a regular villager just trying to avoid getting killed.
This was brought up a few days ago, but do we want to consider outing the sexta? Is there a downside to this, other than relying too much on one person too much for voting purposes.
I think at this point it with 60 pages done, we can atleast go through and look at one person who has not tried to decieve teh village at all...you know what i mean...
but if the sexta wants to wait now till maybe be the slugs try to eat him and waste a night i'd be fine with that...because its not really like knowing the identity of one person is really going to help at this point.
This adds more to the confusion. It would seem that you are the sexta, or you're a slug saying maybe you're the sexta to stay off the vote line. Or you're a regular villager just trying to avoid getting killed.
This was brought up a few days ago, but do we want to consider outing the sexta? Is there a downside to this, other than relying too much on one person too much for voting purposes.
I think at this point it with 60 pages done, we can atleast go through and look at one person who has not tried to decieve teh village at all...you know what i mean...
but if the sexta wants to wait now till maybe be the slugs try to eat him and waste a night i'd be fine with that...because its not really like knowing the identity of one person is really going to help at this point.
Exactly, beating around the bush is pointless, it adds confusing, especially when you can protect yourself. If the Mayor and bird isn't known. You don't have to protect them. Out yourself, and protect yourself.
Malkamaniac wrote:
Exactly, beating around the bush is pointless, it adds confusing, especially when you can protect yourself. If the Mayor and bird isn't known. You don't have to protect them. Out yourself, and protect yourself.
I'm fine with this as long as we're not missing some advantage it would give the slugs. It gives us one trustworthy person. Of course, it also probably leads to my demise since pfidc has mentioned me a few times.
Malkamaniac wrote:
Exactly, beating around the bush is pointless, it adds confusing, especially when you can protect yourself. If the Mayor and bird isn't known. You don't have to protect them. Out yourself, and protect yourself.
I'm fine with this as long as we're not missing some advantage it would give the slugs. It gives us one trustworthy person. Of course, it also probably leads to my demise since pfidc has mentioned me a few times.
Maybe, Maybe not. It could also lead to my demise for me calling for this. But adding another 5 pages because were going through this, is he or isn't he stage and clouding up the situation more, isn't worth it.
I've been suspicious of Juice & JC the entire game, but every time I've been on, the vote hasn't been going either of their ways. (I've also been suspicious of npv but I'm not sure if that's because I'm getting slug vibes from him or it's just his super confusing "logic" that makes me look at him that way.) I don't know, I'm terrible at theorizing.
And, FWIW, I'm not trying to be "under the radar" or whatever. On Tuesday, I came down with the flu and it has been kicking my *kittens* since, so I haven't been able to participate as much as I'd like.
I'm not a big fan of the "pick someone at random" strategy, but if it gets used, the best way is if the sexta comes out, and, if unchallenged, just does the randomization among all the other players. It will have about a 1/3 chance of picking a slug. Any other way of doing things lets the slugs manipulate their "random" lists to almost certainly keep themselves near the bottom.
I'm honestly confused. I really think Canaan & Juice are prime people to be slugs, but the whole back and forth stuff with dagny and JC keeps jumping out at me. I mean, they say it goes back to the chat, but dagny has been ready to salt him this entire game.
And PFIDC, seriously, what are you doing? This I may be, I may not be... it's making me want to salt you out of spite.
IrishEyes wrote:Wow. There was so much to catch up on!
I'm honestly confused. I really think Canaan & Juice are prime people to be slugs, but the whole back and forth stuff with dagny and JC keeps jumping out at me. I mean, they say it goes back to the chat, but dagny has been ready to salt him this entire game.
And PFIDC, seriously, what are you doing? This I may be, I may not be... it's making me want to salt you out of spite.
Please do. I've been consistent all game with my votes. Why doesn't everyone just vote for JC, see if he's a slug and if he's not you can all salt me next?
Malkamaniac wrote:Exactly, beating around the bush is pointless, it adds confusing, especially when you can protect yourself. If the Mayor and bird isn't known. You don't have to protect them. Out yourself, and protect yourself.
Echo?
Juice from way earlier in the game like page 10 or some **** wrote:Hey sexta, out yourself so we have someone to trust now that the gardener is dead
Idjit villagers wrote:Now why would we do that the slugs might gain a night
Juice then wrote:But having the slugs gain a night will be better than later on looking back and seeing that we were just being mislead the whole time, cause we had nobody to completely trust
Idjit Villagers wrote:But omg no that person may be stoopid and lead us astray
I have no idea what to think of pfidc right now. If we do salt JC and he's a slug I don't think that really puts the heat off pfidc. He could easily also be a slug and trying to gain trust. He seems awfully confident about JC. I just don't understand what good it does to the rest of the village to do the whole "I am, I'm not" thing. It helps him maybe, but not everyone else. But I guess even if he is a slug and JC is also, we'd at least be down one slug by going with JC.
)
