*** SLUG WARS I GAME THREAD ***

[crayz]

anyone have the count?

i think 12...but I don't have a spreadsheet or anything going today

[JoseCuervo]

Unsalt zaro

Salt kicksave

Someone color me plz on phone

gotya

[crayz]

Unsalt zaro

Salt kicksave

Someone color me plz on phone

[jaysmiter]

Unsalt zaro

Salt kicksave

Someone color me plz on phone

[bhaw]

someone count it up so I know if we need a write up yet.

[PensFanInDC]

Wow...3 players really want to hear this. One of them even says Ill get eaten either way.

Maybe that should tell you something about my theory.

Oh well...what the heck.

Jaysmiter, JC and MWB

I've been suspicious of JC and MWB since day 2 and Jaysmiter as of today. It's about the way you post, your theories and your treatment of my "I have a solid theory" post, which did exactly what I wanted it to.

unsalt kicksave

salt Jose Cuervo

[crayz]

someone count it up so I know if we need a write up yet.

was 13 until PFIDC changed....so now 12

[jaysmiter]

My treatment of your "I have a theory post"? LOL

It's ridiculous to say "I know who to go after if Kicksave isn't a slug, but I'm not saying who"

Why say anything at all?

And, you can be suspicious of me all you want, it just goes to show that I was excited for nothing when I expected a "solid theory"

[MWB]

Wow...3 players really want to hear this. One of them even says Ill get eaten either way.

Maybe that should tell you something about my theory.

Oh well...what the heck.

Jaysmiter, JC and MWB

I've been suspicious of JC and MWB since day 2 and Jaysmiter as of today. It's about the way you post, your theories and your treatment of my "I have a solid theory" post, which did exactly what I wanted it to.

unsalt kicksave

salt Jose Cuervo

I'm glad you got it out... but again, what is the downside of not posting it now? The moment you said you had a solid theory you've become a target.

[crayz]

1 more vote and kicksave gets some salty love

[PensFanInDC]

My treatment of your "I have a theory post"? LOL

It's ridiculous to say "I know who to go after if Kicksave isn't a slug, but I'm not saying who"

Why say anything at all?

And, you can be suspicious of me all you want, it just goes to show that I was excited for nothing when I expected a "solid theory"

Right on my man...

[JoseCuervo]

Wow...3 players really want to hear this. One of them even says Ill get eaten either way.

Maybe that should tell you something about my theory.

Oh well...what the heck.

Jaysmiter, JC and MWB

I've been suspicious of JC and MWB since day 2 and Jaysmiter as of today. It's about the way you post, your theories and your treatment of my "I have a solid theory" post, which did exactly what I wanted it to.

unsalt kicksave

salt Jose Cuervo

wait... so you were incredibly confident in salting kicksave... but instead you want to lynch a villager using common sense?

[the errey i breathe]

checking in from class, ill go along with salt kicksave, ill try to be more active too. You know how it is w/ the first week of school.

[Dan H]

I'm not on the Kicksave train. Just don't have a sluggy feeling to me.
Then again, I'm not really on anyone's train at the moment. Glancing through people's posts trying to turn anything up...

[JoseCuervo]

My treatment of your "I have a theory post"? LOL

It's ridiculous to say "I know who to go after if Kicksave isn't a slug, but I'm not saying who"

Why say anything at all?

And, you can be suspicious of me all you want, it just goes to show that I was excited for nothing when I expected a "solid theory"

I now believe jay is a villager.

[bhaw]

STOP! If it was 13, it's over regardless of what happened since then.

[PensFanInDC]

I'm glad you got it out... but again, what is the downside of not posting it now? The moment you said you had a solid theory you've become a target.

I can see that. I guess it's trying to figure out how the slugs would think.

Me personally, IF I were a slug, I would have no idea WHAT the theory was and therefore would have no idea if the person was wrong or not. It makes it 50/50. If they say what it is it makes it 100/0 (either right or wrong). If, as a slug, I knew a RP and was deciding between them and this player with some unknown theory, I would go with the RP. If the theory was made known and it was right, I would nom the player.

Like I said, it all comes down to trying to think like a slug.

[JoseCuervo]

Then again, I'm not really on anyone's train at the moment.

[bhaw]

13 for sure now... write up coming...

[Senka]

Im sticking with MAC. i still think the alpha is someone experienced and has played enough... and Macs been playing the percentages so far and its just sticking out to me. ill continue to vote for Mac until hes dead.

[crayz]

STOP! If it was 13, it's over regardless of what happened since then.

ok, we are at 13 regardless with my count even after the change.

write-up please kind sir

[jaysmiter]

Stop! Take some time to think! Think about what's important to you! Stop! Take some time to think!

[PensFanInDC]

Man....I hope I was right

[MWB]

I'm glad you got it out... but again, what is the downside of not posting it now? The moment you said you had a solid theory you've become a target.

I can see that. I guess it's trying to figure out how the slugs would think.

Me personally, IF I were a slug, I would have no idea WHAT the theory was and therefore would have no idea if the person was wrong or not. It makes it 50/50. If they say what it is it makes it 100/0 (either right or wrong). If, as a slug, I knew a RP and was deciding between them and this player with some unknown theory, I would go with the RP. If the theory was made known and it was right, I would nom the player.

Like I said, it all comes down to trying to think like a slug.

This really confused me. I would think neither a slug nor a villager would have any idea what the theory was before it was presented.

[JoseCuervo]

If, as a slug, I knew a RP and was deciding between them and this player with some unknown theory, I would go with the RP. If the theory was made known and it was right, I would nom the player.

Like I said, it all comes down to trying to think like a slug.

I used to be a good wolf, and nomming you after picking out a wolf would only seal that wolf's fate. No need for a villager-wolf tradeoff. There's a better chance of getting nommed if you were wrong because it would seal that other villager's fate.