Ok so here is the development of the Malks vote:
Bhaw opens the voting, with suspicions on shaf and npv as well.
Malks then votes jaysmiter, and tfrizz joins him. Something that has been completely forgotten is that both senka and jay strongly defended redwill who turned up baddie. Kicksave does vote for Senka though and he was bad at this point if I am understanding how that worked correctly.
Shaf then comes in with:
shafnutz05 wrote:fire malkamaniac
He was absolutely all over the map the last couple rounds...combined with his late and unexplained switch to CK with me, that is enough for my vote.
Senka adds another vote for Malks with zero explanation -- just fire malka and nothing else.
Shaf again:
shafnutz05 wrote:If you're the angel, why don't you just protect yourself tonight? Hmm?
and again:
shafnutz05 wrote:Malkamaniac, there is no way in hell I am taking back my vote. If I end up voting to fire the angel, this is going to be a case of:
And you have to admit that comment from dags was funny
Bhaw then says:
bhaw wrote:rehire malkamaniac
fire shafnutz
I'm looking at this one of two ways. Either Malk IS the angel, in which case, no point in killing him. If he's a baddy, we can keep him around and simply not put much worth into what he says until we figure out for sure.
Shafnutz was my other vote, and the fact that he is one of the few still pushing to kill the potential angel doesn't help his position with me
I'd suggest others follow suit and just leave Malk's opinions aside until we figure it out. Why waste a night?
For whatever reason, sometime between here and the end of the thread, bhaw decides I am pushing hard for Malks even though I say that I tend to agree with not killing him at that point, prior to continued blow ups.
sdm then says:
sdm5055 wrote:bhaw wrote:rehire malkamaniac
fire shafnutz
I'm looking at this one of two ways. Either Malk IS the angel, in which case, no point in killing him. If he's a baddy, we can keep him around and simply not put much worth into what he says until we figure out for sure.
Shafnutz was my other vote, and the fact that he is one of the few still pushing to kill the potential angel doesn't help his position with me
I'd suggest others follow suit and just leave Malk's opinions aside until we figure it out. Why waste a night?
this makes sense but it never works everyone will come back to him each day phase and this will consume the game and divert attention
After having earlier in the page jumped in on the vote right after kicksave and shaf voted for malks one after the other (also an odd coincidence that those two vote together).
shaf again:
shafnutz05 wrote:
I understand your logic, and this is something that I have advocated before (to no avail). It's a risk, so I dunno. What if he is actually some new Godfather and he gets another night to kill someone?
(in full disclosure, I supported this as a potential stumbling block, because of the damage Malks did in NHL)
Shaf then goes revenge type response to bhaw:
shafnutz05 wrote:whoa whoa whoa bhaw.....really? again? I am willing to withdraw my vote for Malkamaniac. In the last game, Malks claimed IE was a baddie with no evidence. I begged the rest of the town to give IE time, and to not listen to him, but no one listened. I am willing to withdraw my vote for now until someone investigates him.
Bhaw, you are even more suspicious to me now. I am willing to "kill the potential angel"? Everyone and their brother has seen these types of antics before from Malks. Not saying he is guilty, but you are making it sound like I am extremely suspicious for not trusting Malks. That isn't exactly a stretch, considering his track record.
Oddly defensive.
So basically, based on that, and knowing that I am not a baddie, the Malks vote leaves me with suspicions on Shaf, sdm, zaro as posted previously, and senka. Jay wouldnt vote for him in the end, so I think he is clear.
In looking at it, I think shaf pushed the hardest. The fact that he posted only three times since this day period started is also odd -- he posted once to jump on the wagon for me, then again to say "I have a raging clue", and then once more to say he was leaving -- and completely different than what he normally woudl do. Knowing that based on the above, he was the one "irrationally" voting malks and being "harsh" about it as bhaw said, plus the fact that he said he was voting with bhaw after saying last night that that was his big suspicion, and I am going to have to
hire senka and
fire shaf. Reviewing this and it looks like a better case as compared to senka.
I am probably going down anyways, but if you look at the facts, I dont think that it makes sense to vote me off. But good luck village!
