The Dark Knight Game Thread

[canaan]

that was fun.

[slappybrown]

lololol

Please tell me you didnt recruit NAN.

[Crankshaft]

haha, wow.

[count2infinity]

I sent canaan a message asking him how in the hell did no one figure him out after slappy's death. He was red as red can be. His response: "lulz"

[columbia]

lololol

Please tell me you didnt recruit NAN.

Nope, he was just kind enough to help us out.

[slappybrown]

That was the worst luck ever hitting cranky the first night. It was a cool game Pavel but strangely unfortunate that I hit him the first night. I think you could re-adjust by giving another town role to balance.

[newarenanow]

PS - the League of Shadows hired the Scarecrow and Carmine Falcone to help do their dirty work in Batman Begins.

That is WK and CBear.

[slappybrown]

lololol

Please tell me you didnt recruit NAN.

Nope, he was just kind enough to help us out.

lolololol

[Crankshaft]

That was the worst luck ever hitting cranky the first night. It was a cool game Pavel but strangely unfortunate that I hit him the first night. I think you could re-adjust by giving another town role to balance.

I wasn't red, at that point.

[newarenanow]

Woops.

[newarenanow]

So was there a real seer or anyone else that was green?

[slappybrown]

Not having a recruit-heavy game in a long while also helped. No one really pushed that theory as an explanation. In this context, blindly listening to claimed RPs killed us because there was no counter-claiming force. So cranky was red when I called him, and I had columbia.

lol@NAN/THG

[Willie Kool]

PS - the League of Shadows hired the Scarecrow and Carmine Falcone to help do their dirty work in Batman Begins.

That is WK and CBear.

Well, they got my help the last two days...

[slappybrown]

So was there a real seer or anyone else that was green?

knan was but he got recruited. cranky was but he got recruited. The role blocks allowed them to recruit. Having a pure role block role adds little IMO.

[slappybrown]

That was the worst luck ever hitting cranky the first night. It was a cool game Pavel but strangely unfortunate that I hit him the first night. I think you could re-adjust by giving another town role to balance.

I wasn't red, at that point.

Right, but when I called you out, you were, no?

[slappybrown]

Really cool game structure Pavel, thanks. I would run that style game back for sure.

[Crankshaft]

That was the worst luck ever hitting cranky the first night. It was a cool game Pavel but strangely unfortunate that I hit him the first night. I think you could re-adjust by giving another town role to balance.

I wasn't red, at that point.

Right, but when I called you out, you were, no?

Nope, they recruited me the day after. I was still the green doctor. I protected myself night one.

[newarenanow]

So was there a real seer or anyone else that was green?

knan was but he got recruited. cranky was but he got recruited. The role blocks allowed them to recruit. Having a pure role block role adds little IMO.

Well, that made it almost impossible for the village to win with such a small game.

[relantel]

MRandall goining out early turned out to be critical. He was the potential balance (and likely an earlier discovery of the League)

[columbia]

Killing off randall so early in the game made for an interesting dynamic.....and a much easier one.

[slappybrown]

Crank was telling the truth.

After I died, and this was canaans first post, I immediately PMd Pavel that canaan and cranky were red. So canaan doesnt investigate cranky the night before, has a retarded explanation for it, no one listens when I call him out, then he comes back and clears him the very next night conveniently? Once no one put heat on knan there it was over.

[slappybrown]

MRandall goining out early turned out to be critical. He was the potential balance (and likely an earlier discovery of the League)

How so?

[Crankshaft]

Crank was telling the truth.

After I died, and this was canaans first post, I immediately PMd Pavel that canaan and cranky were red. So canaan doesnt investigate cranky the night before, has a retarded explanation for it, no one listens when I call him out, then he comes back and clears him the very next night conveniently? Once no one put heat on knan there it was over.

Yea but when you thought I was red, you were wrong. It doesn't make you right when I was recruited after the fact.

[relantel]

MRandall goining out early turned out to be critical. He was the potential balance (and likely an earlier discovery of the League)

How so?

he was the night shot, presumably he would have shot one of the League, outing it before it achieved critical mass.

[newarenanow]

Crank was telling the truth.

After I died, and this was canaans first post, I immediately PMd Pavel that canaan and cranky were red. So canaan doesnt investigate cranky the night before, has a retarded explanation for it, no one listens when I call him out, then he comes back and clears him the very next night conveniently? Once no one put heat on knan there it was over.

Yea but when you thought I was red, you were wrong. It doesn't make you right when I was recruited after the fact.

slappy = EPP