Mad Scientist Warz Game Thread

[Benny Fitz]

So what are we going to do here gents? Go for a silent player or take a stab at one of us?

[columbia]

You have a 50/50 shot on ps87.

[Willie Kool]

You have a 50/50 shot on ps87.

You're advocating a 50/50 gamble on killing a green? Really?

[MWB]

No, and redwill said it first but won't talk about it.

He did? I completely missed that.

[MWB]

You have a 50/50 shot on ps87.

You're advocating a 50/50 gamble on killing a green? Really?

[Willie Kool]

No, and redwill said it first but won't talk about it.

He did? I completely missed that.

Really? It was in a conversation with you.

The shaf vote was a mistake.

A mistake how?

I thought he was red. He's not. He's blue.

I will not answer any questions about how I know that.

But it's true.

[columbia]

I don't think he's green; we obviously differ.

[MWB]

Yeah, just checked the red will thing. Forgot about that. Columbia, can you communicate with red will? And did he tell you shaf was blue, or did you know that already?

[Willie Kool]

I don't think he's green; we obviously differ.

I don't totally trust him, but no one has disputed his angel claim either.

[MWB]

I don't think he's green; we obviously differ.

Do you have any more information than any of us on ps87? If not, voting for him makes zero sense.

[Benny Fitz]

I'd like to hear more from goucho on his case for not believing columbia

[the errey i breathe]

i suggested before that perhaps the vig shot at the angel, i still think this is likely what happened so i'm hesitant to put any votes on ps87 at this point. Willie is still trying really hard to head a charge against others which is furthering my suspicions

[Gaucho]

ps87's role claim was very specific. Fwiw, it seemed more plausible to me than columbia's claim.

[Willie Kool]

Willie is still trying really hard to head a charge against others which is furthering my suspicions

Just laying out the facts as I see them.

[MWB]

I think Benny's the way to go. Already outlined some of it, but found something else looking back. He voted for redwill early after he came back. I also expressed my concern, but I think Benny tries to get a quick vote through, knowing that he must be green.

[MWB]

ps87's role claim was very specific. Fwiw, it seemed more plausible to me than columbia's claim.

They're probably both being truthful.

[Gaucho]

I'd like to hear more from goucho on his case for not believing columbia

Again, it seemed like a strange time for that claim and it also seemed unnecessary to expose redwill at the same time. Didn't make sense to me.

[Willie Kool]

teib - do you not see the inconsistency to TH24's story? If I was randomly going after someone, fine. I'm just a blue that was ****** off about non participation. And I happened to turn up what I think is some pretty damning evidence against TH24.

[Gaucho]

ps87's role claim was very specific. Fwiw, it seemed more plausible to me than columbia's claim.

They're probably both being truthful.

Hopefully not.

[TheHammer24]

Willie definitely isn't a red. Just an over zealous villager who thinks he has cracke allot codes, IMO.

[the errey i breathe]

teib - do you not see the inconsistency to TH24's story? If I was randomly going after someone, fine. I'm just a blue that was ****** off about non participation. And I happened to turn up what I think is some pretty damning evidence against TH24.

It's damning because you were already looking at him so anything will look to be 'proof' I've never been a fan of voting for people based on posting patterns. I'd rather look at the voting history and look for trends. If his forgetting about the game is proof for you then vote that way.

[MWB]

Benny or Doc is how I'm voting. Doc put an early vote on Kraftster (first page), which at the time I thought was odd, and his explanation was pretty weak. He may have been trying to get a good player out with a quick day one bandwagon. He also put in votes for redwill early on. Other than that, he hasn't had much to say.

[TheHammer24]

My last post will be interpretted by Willie: "hammer is red because he knows I outted him and now is trying to side with me to act like he's good. I figured it all put!!!"

[TheHammer24]

Benny or Doc is how I'm voting. Doc put an early vote on Kraftster (first page), which at the time I thought was odd, and his explanation was pretty weak. He may have been trying to get a good player out with a quick day one bandwagon. He also put in votes for redwill early on. Other than that, he hasn't had much to say.

FWIW, kraft was a non participant in re game doc ran so it may have been carry over. I'm only through page 7 and then 16 on but Bennys redwill votes were strange because if a red knew he wasn't red when he came back, then they would want to kill instantly. But again, that seems obvious and super risky.

[Willie Kool]

It's damning because you were already looking at him so anything will look to be 'proof' I've never been a fan of voting for people based on posting patterns.

I'm basing it on his acknowledging the game starts 'tomorrow morning' and then saying he forgot. The posting patterns just back it up.