bhaw wrote:Difference between "good" and "not a big deal." Losing the vig isn't a huge detriment due to things like you mentioned. Just b/c a good rp dies doesn't mean it's time. The loss of the doctor was far more brutal than the masons.
No, I understand that. And I wasn't just talking about you. Troy Loney an Twisted Wrister made similar remarks.
The nonchalance just surprised me a bit. But when reflecting on it further I didn't think a bad guy would say anything like that, so I don't think any of the 3 of you are necessarily bad.
Made 7 posts, 2 are simple votes for THG and sdm, 3 are , other 2 are "how do we know anything?" and "is this payback for last game?".
That's what I am thinking atm... jaysmiter would have inevitably turned to Azkar at some point, so getting him early would be a priority if Az was bad IMO... or the very least would have given him reason to look up jays if he were a bad seer.
npv708 wrote:Also if it helps...during the Holiday Wars game...cupkeeper and MWB picked off a ton of good RP's in a row, and I think Senka and MWB did it in the game before that.
Even though this post implicates me, I agree with the sentiment. Whoever is leading the charge is someone with experience. They are picking off the players that think the most and participate a lot.
crayz wrote:oh and we learned this is a role blocker (good or bad we don't know)....but someone role blocked J from self-protection and someone then killed him. I assume bad rp role blocker....but ya never know
Role blocking is typically one of the abilities of the JOAT.
I'm thinking that the Godfather is one of these, and at least one of the other mafia members is in this list. They are definitely experienced to go after the vets and such. We'll probably see them turn away from the vets and go after somebody newer to throw the scent.
5. Troy Loney - JP Morgan
8. MWB - Robert E. Lee
10. Zarovich - Ben Franklin
13. Kicksave - Andrew Carnegie
15. Corvidae - Richard Nixon
19. bhaw - Jesse James
20. cupkeeper - Robert Morris
23. Senka - Joseph Schantz
27. Azkar - Betsy Ross
29. newarenanow - John Hancock
I think Senka/Azkar make the most sense here. MWB maybe, but it's like cupkeeper. He's bad so often, the chances of him being bad yet again are pretty slim. Senka still hasn't said much for whatever reason. Azkar is being vague.
Who typically has feuds with dagny AND jaysmiter? Is there anyone?
bhaw wrote:I think Senka/Azkar make the most sense here. MWB maybe, but it's like cupkeeper. He's bad so often, the chances of him being bad yet again are pretty slim. Senka still hasn't said much for whatever reason. Azkar is being vague.
Who typically has feuds with dagny AND jaysmiter? Is there anyone?
bhaw wrote:I think Senka/Azkar make the most sense here. MWB maybe, but it's like cupkeeper. He's bad so often, the chances of him being bad yet again are pretty slim. Senka still hasn't said much for whatever reason. Azkar is being vague.
Who typically has feuds with dagny AND jaysmiter? Is there anyone?
didn't PFIDC get into with them two games ago?
I'm thinking if someone has a recurring battle with them, not just once.
I've got no problem with the Senka route. After 2 rounds of voting, he has yet to cast a single one (Twisted Wrister is the only other that hasn't). He's typically quiet, so nothing out of the ordinary there... but he is always dangerous because of that.
Senka is a def possibility... but he is so wacky that you never know. If he survives much longer, he's probably bad, IMO... I would think the bad guys would take him out pretty early rather than risk him going on a SWI-esque run against them.
I def have to look back through Day 2 a bit cuz I skimmed most of it on my phone during a meeting... Still like where my vote is atm though.
the wicked child wrote:Senka is a def possibility... but he is so wacky that you never know. If he survives much longer, he's probably bad, IMO... I would think the bad guys would take him out pretty early rather than risk him going on a SWI-esque run against them.
I def have to look back through Day 2 a bit cuz I skimmed most of it on my phone during a meeting... Still like where my vote is atm though.
lol... I like these comments b/c now you've just given the bad guys reason NOT to kill him if he's good.
time. The loss of the doctor was far more brutal than the masons.
